-
MG (a pseudonym) v The King
[2025] VSCA 167
Citation 1
(Para 1)
…required to take into account and balance. These are not issues for which there is necessarily only one answer.[13] [13] MG (A Pseudonym) v The King [2025] VSCA 167, [126].…
-
FT v The King
[2024] VSCA 90
Citation 2
(Para 1)
…, ‘[t]he question of risk is forward-looking and involves a predictive exercise often based on incomplete material.’[47] [47] FT v The King [2024] VSCA 90, [79] (Beach, McLeish and Niall JJA).…
-
Zayneh v The King
[2023] VSCA 311
Citation 3
(Para 1)
…ces ‘may be established by a combination of circumstances which may, by themselves, not be considered exceptional’.[29] [28] Danny Zayneh v R [2023] VSCA 311, [33] (Walker, Taylor and Boyce JJA), citing Re Diab [2020] VSC 196, [34]. [29] Re Ali [2022] VSC 219, [21] (Tinney J).…
-
HA (a pseudonym) v The Queen
[2021] VSCA 64
Citation 4
(Para 1)
…of Re HA. [17] [16][2025] VSC 384. His Honour’s decision was upheld by the Court of Appeal in MG (a pseudonym) v The King [2025] VSCA 167. [17][2021] VSCA 64.…
-
Roberts v The Queen
[2021] VSCA 28
Citation 5
…[24][2021] VSCA 28.…
-
El Nasher v DPP
[2020] VSCA 144
Citation 6
…[44] Ali El Nasher v DPP [2020] VSCA 144, [51] (Priest, T Forrest and Weinberg JJA).…
-
Re Edwards
[2025] VSC 498
Citation 7
…shold, although high, is not intended to be near impossible to achieve, and may be established by a combination of circumstances.[26] [26] Re Edwards [2025] VSC 498, [12] (citations omitted).…
-
Re MG
[2025] VSC 384
Citation 8
(Para 1)
…with remand of the child being a last resort’ from s 3B(1)(b), primarily in the context of distinguishing the earlier decision of Re HA. [17] [16][2025] VSC 384. His Honour’s decision was upheld by the Court of Appeal in MG (a pseudonym) v The King [2025] VSCA 167. [17][2021] VSCA 64.…
-
Re HT
[2025] VSC 310
Citation 9
…[15][2025] VSC 310, [91] (citations omitted).…
-
Re KL
[2024] VSC 734
Citation 10
(Para 1)
…status.[19] These provisions apply to all children, including those charged with serious or very serious offending. [18]The Act, s 3B(1B). [19] Re KL [2024] VSC 734, [59].…
-
Re JB
[2024] VSC 549
Citation 11
…[40][2024] VSC 549.…
-
Re Thorpe
[2024] VSC 414
Citation 12
(Para 1)
…that the applicant’s youth and lack of prior criminal history were ‘significant factors weighing in favour’ of bail being granted.[37] [36][2024] VSC 414. [37]Ibid, [72]-[73].…
-
Re Ts
[2024] VSC 164
Citation 13
…[30][2024] VSC 164.…
-
Re PJ
[2024] VSC 97
Citation 14
(Para 1)
…[46] the serious decision to continue the incarceration of any child demands that the risk is demonstrated with cogent evidence to a high degree. [46][2024] VSC 97, [71].…
-
Re O'Connell
[2023] VSC 726
Citation 15
(Para 1)
…he greatest extent possible . [55] Re Prider [2023] VSC 294, [93] (Champion J). See also Re Gaylor [2019] VSC 46, [40] (Riordan J) and Re O’Connell [2023] VSC 726, [41] (Elliott J).…
-
Re Ali
[2022] VSC 219
Citation 16
(Para 1)
…xceptional’.[29] [28] Danny Zayneh v R [2023] VSCA 311, [33] (Walker, Taylor and Boyce JJA), citing Re Diab [2020] VSC 196, [34]. [29] Re Ali [2022] VSC 219, [21] (Tinney J).…
-
Re Abrhm Chol
[2020] VSC 580
Citation 17
…[34][2020] VSC 580.…
-
Re Diab
[2020] VSC 196
Citation 18
(Para 1)
…by themselves, not be considered exceptional’.[29] [28] Danny Zayneh v R [2023] VSCA 311, [33] (Walker, Taylor and Boyce JJA), citing Re Diab [2020] VSC 196, [34]. [29] Re Ali [2022] VSC 219, [21] (Tinney J).…
-
Re Sipser
[2019] VSC 362
Citation 19
(Para 1)
…umstances, when determining whether exceptional circumstances exist.[33] [32] Re Gloury-Hyde [2018] VSC 393, [30] (Priest JA). [33] Re Sipser [2019] VSC 362 [44]-[45] (Beach JA).…
-
Re Gloury-Hyde
[2018] VSC 393
Citation 20
(Para 1)
…nto account, together with other surrounding circumstances, when determining whether exceptional circumstances exist.[33] [32] Re Gloury-Hyde [2018] VSC 393, [30] (Priest JA). [33] Re Sipser [2019] VSC 362 [44]-[45] (Beach JA).…