Re QMT Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  No. 7058 of 1998

Brisbane

Before Justice Wilson

[Re QMT Constructions P/L]

IN THE MATTER of THE CORPORATIONS LAW

and

IN THE MATTER of QMT CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD

(ACN 001 714 290)

CATCHWORDS:     BUILDING AND ENGINEERING CONTRACTS - subcontractor’s charges - resp/contractor entered into a deed of company arrangement before notice of claim of charge given - whether action was a proceeding in respect of a charge under the Subcontractors’ Charges Act - failure to join employer - leave to proceed nunc pro tunc.

Corporations Law Part 5.3A, ss.436A, 473D, 444A, 444D, 444E, 468

Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974 ss.5, 10, 12, 15

Brash Holdings Ltd v Katile Pty Ltd 12 ACLS 472

Kemp, Re [1994] 1 Qd R 285

Lam Soon Australia Pty Ltd v Molit (No. 55) Pty Ltd (1996) 22 ACSR 169
Meehan v Stockmans Australian Cafe (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1996) 22 ACSR 123
Pavex Constructions, ex parte [1979] Qd R 318

Counsel:Mr C. Coulsen for the applicant

Mr M. Daubney for the respondent

Solicitors:Whitman & Co for the applicant

Crouch & Lyndon for the respondent

Hearing Date:              16 November 1998

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WILSON J

Judgment delivered 15 January 1999

  1. This is an application pursuant to s.444E of the Corporations Law by Zion Electrical Pty Ltd for leave nunc pro tunc to bring proceedings against QMT Constructions Pty Ltd, which is subject to a deed of company arrangement.

  2. QMT Constructions Pty Ltd as head contractor entered into a contract to perform building work at 628 Kingston Road, Loganlea for Davids Distribution Pty Ltd as employer. Part of the work was subcontracted to Zion Electrical Pty Ltd pursuant to an agreement between QMT Constructions Pty Ltd as head contractor and Zion Electrical Pty Ltd as subcontractor dated 26 September 1996.

  3. Work on the subcontract commenced on 15 November 1996. Several claims for payment were made and satisfied. On 26 May 1997 Zion Electrical Pty Ltd rendered an invoice in the sum of $11,442.82, which has never been paid.

  4. On 6 January 1998 administrators were appointed to QMT Constructions Pty Ltd pursuant to s.436A of the Corporations Law. Zion Electrical Pty Ltd lodged a proof of debt in the sum of $11,442.82 on 30 January 1998. A deed of company arrangement was entered on 12 February 1998. The admissible claim date under the deed is 6 January 1998.

  5. On 18 March 1998 Zion Electrical Pty Ltd served Davids Distribution Pty Ltd with notice of intention to claim a charge under the Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974, and it served QMT Constructions Pty Ltd with a notice of claim of charge under that Act.

  6. Initially there was dispute as to whether the notice of claim of charge had been given out of time (see s.10), QMT Constructions Pty Ltd asserting that the work had been completed as early as July 1997. However, for the purposes of the present application QMT Constructions Pty Ltd conceded that the notice was given within time.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re QMT Constructions Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QSC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Zion Electrical Pty Ltd applied for leave nunc pro tunc to bring proceedings against QMT Constructions Pty Ltd, which was in the process of a deed of company arrangement. QMT Constructions Pty Ltd had entered into a contract with Davids Distribution Pty Ltd for building work and subcontracted some of the work to Zion Electrical Pty Ltd. Zion Electrical Pty Ltd claimed $11,442.82 for work done, which remained unpaid. Administrators were appointed for QMT Constructions Pty Ltd, and Zion Electrical Pty Ltd lodged a proof of debt and served a notice of claim of charge. Zion Electrical Pty Ltd then commenced a plaint against QMT Constructions Pty Ltd, which was met with a defence based on the deed of company arrangement. The principal issues were whether the charge was initially effective, whether it had been extinguished, and whether leave should be granted to proceed with the action.
The court found that the charge was initially effective as it was created when the notice was given. The court also found that the charge had been extinguished because the action brought was not a proceeding in respect of a charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act, as it failed to join the employer, Davids Distribution Pty Ltd. The claim made was simply for moneys owing for work and labour done, which did not fit the description of a proceeding in respect of a charge under the Act. Therefore, the application for leave nunc pro tunc to bring the proceeding was dismissed.
The court based its decision on the provisions of the Subcontractors' Charges Act and relevant case law. The court considered the effect of the deed of company arrangement and the requirements for enforcing a charge under the Act. The court also considered the principles for the grant of leave discussed in relevant case law. The court held that the charge had been extinguished and that it would not have been appropriate to grant leave nunc pro tunc to bring the proceeding as it was not a proceeding in respect of a charge under the Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

QMT Constructions Pty Ltd, as the head contractor, entered into a contract with Davids Distribution Pty Ltd to perform building work at 628 Kingston Road, Loganlea. Part of this work was subcontracted to Zion Electrical Pty Ltd. Zion Electrical Pty Ltd began work on 15 November 1996, and made several claims for payment, which were satisfied. On 26 May 1997, Zion Electrical Pty Ltd issued an invoice for $11,442.82, which remained unpaid. On 6 January 1998, administrators were appointed to QMT Constructions Pty Ltd, and Zion Electrical Pty Ltd lodged a proof of debt for $11,442.82 on 30 January 1998. A deed of company arrangement was executed on 12 February 1998. On 18 March 1998, Zion Electrical Pty Ltd served Davids Distribution Pty Ltd with a notice of intention to claim a charge under the Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974, and served QMT Constructions Pty Ltd with a notice of claim of charge under the Act. On 15 May 1998, Zion Electrical Pty Ltd commenced a plaint against QMT Constructions Pty Ltd in the Magistrates Court at Brisbane for the sum of $11,442.82. QMT Constructions Pty Ltd filed a defence, stating that Zion Electrical Pty Ltd was bound by the deed of company arrangement and needed the court's leave to proceed with the action. On 24 August 1998, Davids Distribution Pty Ltd paid moneys into the District Court at Brisbane, which included the $11,442.82 claimed by Zion Electrical Pty Ltd.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland as an application by Zion Electrical Pty Ltd for leave nunc pro tunc to bring proceedings against QMT Constructions Pty Ltd. The application was filed pursuant to s.444E of the Corporations Law. The primary focus of the application was whether Zion Electrical Pty Ltd was entitled to bring the action against QMT Constructions Pty Ltd, which was subject to a deed of company arrangement. The court heard submissions from counsel for both parties and considered relevant prior decisions and legislative provisions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the charge initially effective?
2. If so, whether it has been extinguished?
3. If the charge was initially effective and not extinguished, whether the applicant ought to be given leave to bring the action against QMT Constructions Pty Ltd.

Held
1. The court held that the charge was initially effective.
2. The court concluded that the charge had been extinguished because the applicant failed to bring an appropriate action within two months of giving notice of the claim of charge.
3. As the charge had been extinguished, the court did not grant leave to bring the action against QMT Constructions Pty Ltd.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the effect of the deed of company arrangement on the subcontractor's charge. Under the Subcontractors' Charges Act, the charge was created when the notice of claim of charge was given. The court found that the creation of a charge does not constitute a transaction or dealing affecting company property that would require the administrator's consent under the Corporations Law. The deed of company arrangement bound all creditors, including secured creditors, unless the deed provided otherwise. The court held that the charge was initially valid but was extinguished because the applicant did not commence an action within the required time under the Subcontractors' Charges Act. The court noted that the claim made in the Magistrates Court was not a proceeding in respect of a charge under the Act because it did not fit the statutory description. The court referred to previous cases such as Re Kemp and Meehan v Stockmans Australian Cafe to support its reasoning. The binding principle established in this case is that a subcontractor's charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act is subject to the terms of a deed of company arrangement and must be enforced within the statutory time limits to remain effective. The court did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority in reaching its decision.