Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

RE MAGAREY FARLAM LAWYERS TRUST ACCOUNTS

[2007] SASC 307

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Nyland, The Honourable Justice White and The Honourable Justice Kelly)

23 August 2007

PROCEDURE - COSTS - APPEALS AS TO COSTS - MISTAKE OF LAW OR FACT

PROCEDURE - COSTS - APPEALS AS TO COSTS - DISCRETION

Appeal by Attorney-General - construction of s 47(2) of Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) - whether the costs payable from the Legal Practitioners Guarantee Fund in respect of a supervisor's or manager's application for directions include costs incurred by persons other than the supervisor or manager - whether the Court has discretion with respect to such costs.

Held: appeal dismissed - costs incurred in relation to the application for directions by persons other than a supervisor or manager are payable from the Legal Practitioners Guarantee Fund - s 40 of the Supreme Court Act and r 101 of the Supreme Court Rules 1987 (SA) provide a discretion in the Court in relation to such costs.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) s 5, s 44, s 45, s 47, s 48, s 56, s 57, s 57A, s 60, s 63, s 64; Supreme Court Rules 1987 (SA) r 63, r 101; Crown Proceedings Act 1992 (SA) s 9; Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 40; Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 479, s 1335; Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 134; Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) s 69; Trustee Act 1936 (SA) s 91; Corporations Law s 479, s 1335, referred to.
Australian Securities Commission v Melbourne Asset Management Nominees Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 334; Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Account (No 2) [2006] SASC 382; (2006) 246 LSJS 306; Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Account (No 3) [2007] SASC 9; (2007) 246 LSJS 417; Re GB Nathan & Co Pty Ltd (1991) 24 NSWLR 674; Farrow Finance Co Ltd (in Liq) v ANZ Executors and Trustee Co Ltd (1997) 23 ACSR 521, discussed.
Clyne v Wrigley (1980) 1 NSWLR 599; Re JJT; Ex Parte Victoria Legal Aid [1998] HCA 44; (1998) CLR 184; Devenish v Jewel Food Stores Pty Ltd (1991) 172 CLR 32; Bull v Attorney-General (NSW) (1913) 17 CLR 384; Re GPI Leisure Corporation Ltd (in Liq) (1994) 130 ALR 256; Re Ansett Australia Ltd [2002] VSC 114; Paglia v Trice (1991) 56 SASR 62; Re Masureik & Allan Pty Ltd (1981) 6 ACLR 39; Re New Cap Reinsurance Corp Holdings Ltd [2001] NSWSC 1001, considered.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"Legal Practitioners Guarantee Fund"
"Discretion as to costs"

RE MAGAREY FARLAM LAWYERS TRUST ACCOUNTS
[2007] SASC 307

Full Court: Nyland, White and Kelly JJ

  1. NYLAND J:          I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons expressed by White J.  I have nothing further to add.

  2. WHITE J: By s 47(1) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) (“the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts concerned a dispute regarding the costs associated with the application for directions made by the supervisor of Magarey Farlam Lawyers' trust accounts. The Attorney-General of South Australia appealed against the decision of a single judge of the Supreme Court, which held that the costs incurred by persons other than the supervisor or manager in relation to the application for directions could be paid from the Legal Practitioners Guarantee Fund. The appeal raised two primary legal issues: the interpretation of section 47(2) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA), and the extent of the Court's discretion regarding the costs payable from the Guarantee Fund.

The Court addressed the interpretation of section 47(2) of the Legal Practitioners Act, which grants the Supreme Court the power to order that the costs of an application for directions be paid out of the Guarantee Fund. The Court held that the section does not limit the costs payable from the Fund to those incurred by the supervisor or manager alone, but rather includes the costs of other parties involved in the application. The Court reasoned that the purpose of the Guarantee Fund is to ensure clients of legal firms do not suffer loss due to fiduciary or professional defaults, and that the discretion provided by section 47(2) aligns with the broader objectives of the Fund.

Furthermore, the Court examined the extent of its discretion under section 40 of the Supreme Court Act and rule 101 of the Supreme Court Rules 1987 (SA) regarding the costs payable from the Guarantee Fund. The Court concluded that while Parliament intended the Guarantee Fund to cover certain costs, it did not intend to remove the Court's discretion to order costs. The Court retains the ability to exercise its discretion, particularly in cases where an application is deemed inappropriate or where parties act unreasonably or pursue unmeritorious claims.

The appeal was dismissed by the Court, affirming the decision of the single judge that costs incurred by persons other than the supervisor or manager in relation to the application for directions are payable from the Guarantee Fund, subject to the Court's discretion. This decision underscores the importance of the Guarantee Fund in protecting clients from loss due to professional defaults, while also preserving the Court's discretion to ensure fair and just outcomes in legal proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

A judge of this Court held at first instance that the costs of such persons are capable, subject to an exercise of discretion by the Court, of being paid from the Guarantee Fund.[1] In my opinion that decision is correct, although my reasons for that conclusion are slightly different from those of the judge.[1] Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts (No 2) [2006] SASC 382.Background Circumstances Magarey Farlam Lawyers (“Magarey Farlam”) was formerly a firm of legal practitioners practising in Adelaide. As well as operating two trust accounts, the partners of Magarey Farlam controlled an unlimited liability company, Gimalo Administrators Pty (“Gimalo”). Funds of clients of the firm were invested in bank accounts operated by Gimalo. On 1 August 2005, the Council of the Law Society, acting pursuant to s 44 of the LPA, resolved to appoint a supervisor of the trust accounts of Magarey Farlam. Ms S R Bishop was appointed as Supervisor (“the Supervisor”). On 1 February 2006, the Council of the Law Society, acting pursuant to s 45 of the LPA, resolved to appoint a manager to the practice of Magarey Farlam. Ms K N Thomas was appointed as Manager. The circumstances giving rise to the respective appointments are not presently material. It is sufficient to note that they arose out of misappropriations of trust monies by William Brenton Willoughby, a non-legal employee of Magarey Farlam. Issues arose as to the manner of distribution by the Supervisor of monies held in the trust accounts of Magarey Farlam. Again, the precise nature of those issues is not presently important. It is sufficient to note that there was an issue as to whether the monies should be distributed in proportion to the amount or amounts contributed to the trust accounts by each claimant, or whether a tracing of particular monies, when that was possible, should be permitted. The clients of Magarey Farlam who had monies in trust took opposing positions on this issue. In addition, the partners of Magarey Farlam asserted an entitlement to be repaid amounts which they had contributed to the trust accounts in an early endeavour to restore the amount lost through Willoughby’s conduct. Because of these issues, the Supervisor sought directions from the Court pursuant to s 47(1) of the LPA. Initially, the Supervisor sought directions as to the manner in which she should solicit claims on the monies in the trust accounts, the method of administration of those claims, and a determination of the number and type of claimants. Later, on 31 August 2006, the Supervisor applied for directions as to the manner of distribution of the funds in the trust accounts and for determination of the competing claims of the claimants. Over a period of some months, the judge made orders and directions for the purpose of ensuring that all claimants were identified, that all classes of claimants and all other interested parties were present before the Court, and for the provision of relevant information to all claimants. The judge also made directions with respect to the hearing of the Supervisor’s application regarding the manner in which the monies in the trust accounts should be disbursed amongst the various claimants. The judge heard evidence and submissions concerning the manner of distribution on 19, 20 and 21 December 2006 and delivered his decision on that question on 18 January 2007.[2][2] Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts (No 3) [2007] SASC 9; (2007) 246 LSJS 417.Preliminary Matters

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Law Society has the responsibility for determining claims against the Guarantee Fund. A disappointed claimant has a right of appeal to the Supreme Court (s 63). The Society must satisfy any valid claim to the extent determined by it or the Supreme Court out of the Guarantee Fund (s 64).The Decision of the Single Judge The judge held that s 47(2) of the LPA vests the Supreme Court with a discretion to order that the costs of any application for directions be paid out of the Guarantee Fund. Those costs are not limited to the costs of a supervisor or manager, but may include the costs of other participants in the application for directions. The judge rejected a submission that s 47(2) simply provided a means for reimbursement of supervisors or managers for the costs incurred by them on an application for directions. The judge said:That conclusion is consistent with the fact that the supervisor or manager is appointed where there has been some fiduciary or professional default in the conduct of a legal practice and with the fact that the guarantee fund has been established with the object of seeking to ensure that clients of legal firms do not suffer loss in consequence of any fiduciary or professional default. It is clear on the face of s 47(2) that the costs of the supervisor and the manager will, as a general rule, be paid out of the guarantee fund. The terms of s 47(2) do not limit the persons whose costs might be paid out of the guarantee fund. Had Parliament intended that the costs only of the supervisor or manager should be paid out of the guarantee fund, it could have easily have expressed that intention. The fact that it has not reinforces the conclusion that the costs of other parties before the Court in consequence of the supervisor’s application are also payable out of the guarantee fund.A subsidiary question is whether any party has an unqualified entitlement to be paid his costs or whether the Court has its usual discretion whether to award costs. An examination of the purpose of the application for directions and of the provisions of the Legal Practitioners Act confirms the conclusion that the costs incurred by the parties before the Court on the supervisor’s application are payable out of the guarantee fund and indicates that the Court has a discretion whether to order that the costs be paid out of the guarantee fund.[6][6] Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts (No 2) [2006] SASC 382 at [17]-[19]. After examining the purpose of an application for directions by a supervisor or manager and the purposes of the Guarantee Fund, the judge concluded that the word “payable” in s 47(2) is used in the sense of “capable of being paid” rather than “what is owed and is to be paid”.[7][7] Ibid at [34]. In relation to the Court’s discretion with respect to costs the judge said:However, while Parliament has provided for the fund from which costs might be paid, I do not think it intended that any party should have an automatic entitlement for his or her costs to be paid out of the guarantee fund. Instead, it intended that the Court would retain its long established discretion as to costs. If Parliament had intended that any party to an application would have an automatic entitlement to costs, s 47(2) would have been expressed in quite different terms. As a general rule, the supervisor will be entitled to have his or her costs and the Court will order the costs to be paid out of the guarantee fund. However, the Court retains a discretion as to costs in the unlikely event that the supervisor makes an application which on any view should not have been made.There might also be occasions where a party or parties act unreasonably or seek to advance an unmeritorious claim or a claim without any reasonable prospects of success. The Court will, in those circumstances, or in like circumstances, consider whether in the exercise of its discretion a party is entitled to all or part of its costs. There might be occasions when it is appropriate for the Court to limit the amount of the costs which should be paid. …[8][8] Ibid at [32]-[33].Submissions on Appeal by the Attorney-General

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established