Re Hunter, Lindsay v Ex Parte Webb, Luci Mary

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

CATCHWORDS

BANKRUPTCY - application to review sequestration order made by Registrar - whether bankruptcy petition should have been dismissed "for other sufficient cause" - consideration of complex of conflicting evidence.

Bankruptcy Act 1966, ss.31A(6), 52(2)(b).

LINDSAY HUNTER v LUCI MARY WEBB
No. P515 of 1995, No. WB994 of 1995

CORAM:    SHEPPARD J

PLACE:    PERTH

DATE:     19 JULY 1996

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA     )
   )    No. P515 of 1995
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN DISTRICT REGISTRY  )    No. WB994 of 1995
  )
BANKRUPTCY DIVISION                   )

RE:      LINDSAY HUNTER
  Debtor

EX PARTE: LUCI MARY WEBB
  Petitioning Creditor

MINUTES OF ORDER

CORAM:    SHEPPARD J
PLACE:    PERTH

DATE:     19 JULY 1996

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The notice of motion filed by the applicant on 8 September 1995 as amended by the notice of motion filed on 6 October 1995 be dismissed.

  1. The petitioning creditor's costs of the notice of motion be paid out of the assets of the bankrupt, the debtor, Lindsay Hunter.

  1. The application made by Lindsay Hunter for a stay of proceedings be refused.

  1. Direct that Lindsay Hunter not be permitted to file in this Court any application or other document including any subpoena or summons to witness whether in this or any other matter without the leave of a judge of this Court.

NOTE:     Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in
         Rule 124 of the Bankruptcy Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )    No. P515 of 1995
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN               )    No. WB994 of 1995
DISTRICT REGISTRY                )
BANKRUPTCY DIVISION              )

RE:LINDSAY HUNTER

Debtor

EX PARTE: LUCI MARY WEBB
  Petitioning Creditor

CORAM:    SHEPPARD J

PLACE:    PERTH

DATE:     19 JULY 1996

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:   The critical application to be dealt with is an amended notice of motion which was filed on 6 October 1995 on behalf of Mr Hunter in which there is sought an order that the sequestration order made by Registrar Jan on 21 August against Mr Hunter be set aside and declared a nullity or, alternatively, that there be a permanent stay of that sequestration order.  Other relief is sought, but I do not find it necessary to refer to it.  The primary relief sought is that which I have indicated.

The amended notice of motion replaced an earlier notice of motion which was filed on 6 September 1995.  It had sought similar relief.  Both the notice of motion and the amended notice of motion were filed in matter no. P515 of 1995 but the proceedings to which they gave rise were subsequently given the number no. WB994 of 1995.  That is why I have included both numbers in the heading to this judgment and in the Court's formal orders.

On 17 May last directions were given by French J so that this matter might be got ready for hearing.  On that day his Honour set down the application for hearing on 15 and 16 July.  He directed that any further affidavits in support of the application be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Hunter, Lindsay v Ex Parte Webb, Luci Mary and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] FCA 701
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lindsay Hunter, the debtor, sought to have a sequestration order set aside or stayed, which had been made by Registrar Jan in his absence on 21 August 1995. The petitioning creditor, Luci Mary Webb, opposed the application. The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether Mr Hunter's application to set aside or stay the sequestration order should be successful and whether there was sufficient evidence to show that the sequestration order should not have been made for other sufficient cause. The court needed to consider the complex of conflicting evidence, including the circumstances surrounding the transactions between the parties and the evidence of fraud and forgery alleged by Mr Hunter.

The court rejected Mr Hunter's claims of fraud and forgery, finding his evidence unreliable and accepting Mrs Webb's evidence as truthful. The court found that Mr Hunter had notice of the hearing but chose not to attend, which weakened his argument for setting aside the sequestration order. The court also found that the taxation of the costs, which led to the bankruptcy notice, was conducted regularly and the order was properly made.

The court dismissed Mr Hunter's amended notice of motion and ordered that the petitioning creditor's costs be paid from the bankrupt's estate. The court also refused Mr Hunter's application for a stay of proceedings and directed that he not file any application or document in the court without the leave of a judge due to the nature of the documents filed in the case and the language used in them.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lindsay Hunter was declared bankrupt following a sequestration order made by Registrar Jan on 21 August 1995. The order was based on a bankruptcy petition by Luci Mary Webb, who claimed that Hunter failed to comply with a bankruptcy notice. The notice was issued in response to an order of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, where Hunter sought injunctive relief against Webb, which was dismissed. The injunctive relief was based on proceedings initiated by Hunter against the Gardiners regarding the purchase of land at 114 Empire Avenue, Wembley Downs. Hunter alleged that he was not properly served with the notice of the hearing before the Registrar and that the sequestration order should be set aside for other sufficient cause. Hunter claimed that there was fraudulent conduct involved in the transactions concerning the property, particularly regarding the involvement of Webb as a nominee.

The matter was initially heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, where Hunter's application for injunctive relief against Webb was dismissed, and he was ordered to pay costs. Webb subsequently filed a petition for specific performance of a contract for the purchase of the rear portion of the property, which was granted by the Supreme Court. Hunter appealed the decision, but the appeal was dismissed. Hunter filed an application to review the sequestration order made by the Registrar, seeking to set it aside or for a permanent stay. The application was heard by Sheppard J, who dismissed the application and ordered Hunter to pay Webb's costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the sequestration order made by the Registrar should be set aside or stayed for other sufficient cause.
2. Whether the evidence supports Hunter's claim of fraudulent conduct in the transactions concerning the property.
3. Whether Hunter's failure to attend the hearing before the Registrar provides a ground for setting aside the sequestration order.
4. Whether the taxation of costs upon which the bankruptcy notice was founded was conducted regularly and properly.

Held
1. The court dismissed the amended notice of motion filed by Lindsay Hunter on 6 October 1995, which sought to set aside or stay the sequestration order made by Registrar Jan on 21 August 1995.
2. The court found that Lindsay Hunter's claim of fraudulent conduct in the transactions concerning the property was not supported by the evidence.
3. The court determined that Lindsay Hunter's failure to attend the hearing before the Registrar did not provide a ground for setting aside the sequestration order as he had notice of the hearing.
4. The court concluded that the taxation of costs upon which the bankruptcy notice was founded was conducted regularly and properly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the application filed by Lindsay Hunter under subsection 31A(6) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966, seeking to review the sequestration order made by Registrar Jan. The court noted that this was not a typical case where the debtor sought to go behind the judgment on which the act of bankruptcy was founded, but rather involved broader considerations under subsection 52(2) of the Act. The court referenced the decision in Bourke v Beneficial Finance Corporation Limited (1993) 47 FCR 264, which discussed the principles for setting aside a judgment on the ground of fraud, and applied them by analogy to the present case. The court found that there was insufficient evidence to establish the alleged fraudulent conduct, and thus dismissed Hunter's application. The court also found that Hunter's absence at the hearing before the Registrar did not constitute a ground for setting aside the sequestration order. Additionally, the court ruled that the taxation of costs was conducted properly, thereby upholding the validity of the bankruptcy notice. The binding legal principle established in this case is that the court will not set aside a sequestration order based on insufficient evidence of fraudulent conduct, even when the debtor alleges such conduct.