SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction)
In the Estate of LISA KAREN HALL (DECEASED)
[2011] SASC 117
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Gray
20 July 2011
SUCCESSION - WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION - PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - GRANTS OF PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION
SUCCESSION - WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION - THE MAKING OF A WILL - REVOCATION - METHODS OF REVOCATION - DESTRUCTION OR MUTILATION, OR STRIKING OUT PORTIONS - PRESUMPTION OF DESTRUCTION OF LOST WILL ANIMO REVOCANDI
Application for an order that probate of the deceased's will, as contained in a copy, be granted to one of the executors of the deceased's will - the deceased's will was executed at her solicitor's office on 18 December 2009 - the deceased retained the original copy of the will - the deceased died on 9 June 2010 - the deceased's original will has not been found, but a copy has been located - where the presumption of revocation arises on the facts - whether the presumption of revocation has been rebutted.
Consideration of the principles relating to lost wills.
Held: application granted - the presumption of revocation has been rebutted - probate of the deceased's will, as contained in a copy, is granted limited until the original will or a more authentic copy is brought into and left in the Probate Registry of this Court.
Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 8; Probate Rules 2004 (SA) r 68 and r 77, referred to.
In the Estate of Engelhardt Deceased [2010] SASC 196; In the Estate of Roediger Deceased [1967] SASR 118; Cahill v Rhodes [2002] NSWSC 561; Curley v Duff (1985) 2 NSWLR 716; In the Will of Molloy [1969] 1 NSWR 400; Gair v Bowers (1909) 9 CLR 510; Allan v Morrison [1900] AC 604; Welch v Phillips (1836) 1 Moo PC 299; McCauley v McCauley (1910) 10 CLR 434; Whiteley v Clune (No 2); The Estate of Brett Whiteley (Unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Powell J, 13 May 1993); Colvin v Fraser (1929) 2 Hag Ecc 266; In the Estate of Gerard Deceased (2007) 251 LSJS 176; Gordon v Beere [1962] NZLR 257; Sugden v Lord St Leonards (1876) LR 1 PD 154; Finch v Finch (1867) LR 1 P & D 371; Re Estate of Simkin [1950] VLR 341, considered.
In the Estate of LISA KAREN HALL (DECEASED)
[2011] SASC 117Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction
GRAY J:
Introduction
This is an application by summons for an order that probate of the last will and testament of Lisa Karen Hall, the deceased, as contained in a copy, be granted to the applicant, Fred Michael Reiter, that grant being limited until the original will or a more authentic copy of it is brought into and left in the Probate Registry of this Court.
The application was supported by affidavits of the defendant’s solicitor, Tanya Ryan, of 11 May 2011 and 25 November 2010, an affidavit of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Estate of Hall (deceased) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] SASC 117
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the presumption of revocation could be rebutted and whether the copy of the will presented was a complete and accurate representation of the original. The court examined the evidence provided by the affidavits, including those from the deceased's solicitor, parents, and the applicant. The court considered whether the deceased had destroyed the will intentionally and whether there was evidence to suggest that the will was lost rather than intentionally destroyed.
The court concluded that the presumption of revocation had been rebutted based on the evidence presented. The deceased had executed the will in the presence of her solicitor and witnesses, and there was no evidence that she intended to revoke it. The court found that the copy of the will provided was accurate and complete. All persons who would be prejudiced by the grant of probate had consented and were sui juris. The court found it more probable that the will was lost rather than intentionally destroyed by the deceased.
Accordingly, the court granted the order that probate of the last will and testament of Lisa Karen Hall, as contained in a copy, be granted to Fred Michael Reiter, limited until the original will or a more authentic copy of it is produced. This decision ensures that the deceased's wishes as expressed in the will are honoured and that the estate can be administered according to her instructions.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's primary consideration was whether the presumption of revocation of the deceased's will could be rebutted. The presumption arises when a will is lost or destroyed, suggesting an intention by the deceased to revoke it. However, the court found that the evidence presented was sufficiently strong to rebut this presumption. This conclusion was based on the totality of the circumstances, including the fact that the deceased's will was not found and the circumstances surrounding its disappearance.
The court examined the degree of probability that the will was lost rather than destroyed by the deceased with the intention of revoking it. The evidence included testimonies from the deceased's parents, who searched the deceased's home but did not find the will. The parents deposed that they destroyed many outdated documents, including possibly the will. The court weighed this against the possibility that the deceased might have intentionally destroyed the will. Given the nature of the search and the fact that the deceased did not inform her parents or the executors of the will's whereabouts, the court found it more probable that the will was lost.
A significant part of the court's reasoning was determining whether the copy will presented in the application was a complete and accurate copy of the deceased's last will. The court accepted that the copy will was indeed a complete and accurate reflection of the deceased's last will. This conclusion was based on the affidavits and the fact that the deceased's solicitor had photocopied the will and handed the original to the deceased. The copy was also consistent with the solicitor's records, providing a strong basis for the court's acceptance.
The court also addressed whether the original will existed, was duly executed, and revoked any previous wills. The evidence showed that the will was executed on 18 December 2009 in the presence of the deceased's solicitor and two witnesses, who both attested and signed the will. The deceased had read the will in the presence of her solicitor and confirmed its contents. The court was satisfied that the will was duly executed and effectively revoked any previous wills.
Another key issue was whether there was sufficient evidence of the terms of the original will. The court found that the copy presented in the application, along with the affidavits and the solicitor's records, provided adequate evidence of the will's terms. This evidence was deemed sufficient to satisfy the requirements for probate.
The court considered whether all persons prejudiced by the application had consented to it and were sui juris. The evidence indicated that the deceased's parents and the executors had consented to the application and were sui juris, meaning they had the mental capacity to understand the implications of the proceedings.
Finally, the court evaluated whether the present application satisfied the considerations extracted from judicial commentary relating to the admission to probate of a copy of a missing will. The court concluded that the application met these considerations, as the evidence provided a strong basis to rebut the presumption of revocation and to grant probate based on the copy will.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that when the presumption of revocation of a lost will arises, it can be rebutted if there is sufficiently strong evidence that the will was lost rather than intentionally destroyed by the deceased. The court's decision also underscores the importance of the totality of the evidence in determining whether the copy will is a complete and accurate representation of the deceased's last will, and whether the terms of the original will can be sufficiently evidenced through other means. The court followed established principles regarding the execution of wills and the requirements for granting probate, while also considering the specific circumstances of the case in determining the appropriate course of action.