Re De Simone and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

De Simone and Commissioner of Taxation [2017] AATA 1005 (29 June 2017)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION   

File Number(s):      2014/3948

Re:Giuseppe De Simone  

APPLICANT

Commissioner of TaxationAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:F D O’Loughlin, Senior Member

Date:29 June 2017

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms dismissal of the application without reinstatement.

........................................................................

F D O’Loughlin, Senior Member 

REVIEW OF INCOME TAX OBJECTION

Tribunal procedural powers – whether failure to observe a self-executing direction dismissed an application for review - whether self-executing direction can be made - powers of reinstatement.

Cases

Carey and the Commissioner of Taxation (2014) 145 ALD 236.
Berry v Commissioner of Taxation [2015] FCA 1244.
Brehoi v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 772.
Goldie V Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCAFC 367.
Myers and Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2004] AATA 1337
Taxpayer and Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2002] AATA 523
Wicke-Fitzgerald and Secretary, Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations [2008] AATA 811

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 33, 42A

REASONS FOR DECISION

F D O'Loughlin, Senior Member

29 June 2017

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant contends that his substantive application[1] for review of an objection decision concerning an income tax assessment has not been dismissed, because the Tribunal had no power to make the direction it did, or because he should be taken to have complied with the direction made. In the alternative, the Applicant contends that the Tribunal has power to reinstate his application pursuant to either s 42A(9) or s 42A(10) of the Act[2]  and that the Tribunal should exercise that power.

    [1]An application for review of an objection decision concerning an income tax assessment in which losses claimed as part of a participation in a retirement village development collective investment scheme were disallowed.

  2. Conversely, the Respondent Commissioner contends that the substantive application was validly dismissed by reason of what has been described in the present matter as a self-executing direction that was not complied with, that the Tribunal has the power to make such a direction and there are now no means by which the effect of that direction can be changed by the Tribunal.

  3. For the reasons that follow the dismissal is confirmed and the substantive application cannot be reinstated by the Tribunal. 

    THE FACTS

  4. Among other directions, on 26 November 2015, 12 April 2016, 13 May 2016, 14 June 2016, 6 July 2016 and 19 August 2016 the Tribunal directed the Applicant to prepare and file documents with the Tribunal. The 6 July 2016 and 19 August 2016 directions were self-executing directions, that were made after the Tribunal rejected the Respondent’s submission that the Applicant’s substantive application ought be dismissed pursuant to s 42A(5) of the Act. The Applicant has not observed the 26 November 2015, 12 April 2016, 13 May 2016, 14 June 2016, and 6 July 2016 directions, and whether he observed the 19 August 2016 direction is in issue.

  5. The relevant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re De Simone and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1005
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) by the Applicant, Mr De Simone, against the Commissioner of Taxation. The core of the dispute revolved around the Applicant's failure to comply with multiple directions issued by the Tribunal for the filing and service of documents, including witness statements and supporting documentation.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Applicant's substantive application had been validly dismissed due to non-compliance with its directions, and if so, whether the Tribunal possessed the power to reinstate the application. Specifically, the Tribunal considered the effect of self-executing directions issued on 6 July 2016 and subsequently varied on 19 August 2016, which stipulated deadlines for the lodgement of evidence.

The Tribunal found that the Applicant had failed to comply with the Tribunal's directions, including the self-executing direction of 6 July 2016, which was later extended to 31 August 2016. Despite the extension, not all required materials were lodged by the stipulated deadline, with some documents being filed on 31 August, 1 September, and 3 September 2016. The Tribunal concluded that there had been no error in its previous decision to dismiss the substantive application, as the Applicant's non-compliance with a properly made direction had triggered the consequence contemplated by the relevant legislation. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed that the substantive application was dismissed and that it lacked the power to reinstate it.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow the dismissal is confirmed and the substantive application cannot be reinstated by the Tribunal. THE FACTS Among other directions, on 26 November 2015, 12 April 2016, 13 May 2016, 14 June 2016, 6 July 2016 and 19 August 2016 the Tribunal directed the Applicant to prepare and file documents with the Tribunal. The 6 July 2016 and 19 August 2016 directions were self-executing directions, that were made after the Tribunal rejected the Respondent’s submission that the Applicant’s substantive application ought be dismissed pursuant to s 42A(5) of the Act. The Applicant has not observed the 26 November 2015, 12 April 2016, 13 May 2016, 14 June 2016, and 6 July 2016 directions, and whether he observed the 19 August 2016 direction is in issue. The relevant parts of the 6 July 2016 self-executing direction were in the following terms:The Tribunal DIRECTS:1.The Tribunal vacates the Directions 2, 3 and 4 made in this matter on 14 June and replaces them with the following:2.....3.On or before 4:00pm on 19 August 2016, the Applicant shall lodge with the Tribunal and serve on the Respondent:a.witness statements setting out the evidence of the Applicant, his brother Mr Serafino De Simone, Mr Jurblum, Mr Lustig and any other witness proposed to be called at the Hearing other than Mr Hall;b.a list identifying each document, if any, on which witnesses rely in support of each fact asserted in their witness statements substantially in the form of Table 1; On 19 August 2016 the Applicant requested an extension of time to comply with the 6 July 2016 directions. That request was provided to the Respondent, but in the time available to consider the Applicant’s request before the dismissal aspect of the 6 July 2016 direction would have become effective, the Respondent did not express any view as to whether an extension ought be granted. Before the dismissal aspect of the 6 July 2016 direction would have become effective, the Tribunal allowed the extension sought without hearing from the Respondent on the question. As a consequence, on 19 August 2016, in terms as to dates as sought by the Applicant, the Tribunal made a further direction, the relevant parts were in the following terms: The Tribunal DIRECTS:1.The Tribunal vacates the Directions made in this matter on 6 July 2016 and replaces them with the following:2......3.On or before 4:00pm on 31 August 2016, the Applicant shall lodge with the Tribunal and serve on the Respondent:a.witness statements setting out the evidence of the Applicant, his brother Mr Serafino De Simone, Mr Jurblum, Mr Lustig and any other witness proposed to be called at the Hearing other than Mr Hall;b.a list identifying each document, if any, on which witnesses rely in support of each fact asserted in their witness statements substantially in the form of Table 1; Not all of the materials meeting the terms of the 19 August 2016 direction were received from the Applicant by 4.00 pm on 31 August 2016. Some were filed and served later that day, others the following day and yet further documents were filed on 3 September 2016.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Here, there has been no error. There has been non-compliance with a direction that was appropriately made. And the consequence of that non-compliance, as contemplated by the Act, has arisen.CONCLUSION For the above reasons, the Tribunal affirms that the substantive application was dismissed and that there is no power to reinstate it.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established