Re Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) ACN 158 431 148

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Re Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) ACN 158 431 148 [2017] QSC 25 

PARTIES:

JOANNE DUNN AND JOHN PARK AS LIQUIDATORS OF CLOUDZILLR PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)
(applicants)

v
CLOUDZILLR INC, A DELAWARE CORPORATION

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 7885 of 2016

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

8 March 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16 and 24 August 2016; written submissions on behalf of the respondent dated 12 September 2016; written submissions on behalf of the applicants dated 19 September 2016

JUDGE:

Burns J

ORDERS:

The orders of the court are that:

1.   It is declared that:

(a)   The meeting of the members of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) held on 5 May 2016 was validly called;

(b)   By the special resolution passed by the members of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) on 5 May 2016, the company was voluntarily wound up;

(c)   By the ordinary resolution passed by the members of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) on 5 May 2016, the applicants were appointed as liquidators of the company.

2.   The costs of and incidental to the application brought by the applicants shall be the applicants’ costs in the liquidation.

3.   The cross application is dismissed.

4.   The respondent shall pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to the cross application to be assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

CORPORATIONS – MEMBERSHIP, RIGHTS AND REMEDIES – MEMBERSHIP OF A COMPANY – WHO IS A MEMBER – where a meeting of members was called for the purpose of winding up the company now in liquidation – where it was resolved at the meeting that the company be voluntarily wound up and that the applicants be appointed as liquidators for that purpose – where the respondent contended that all of the shares in the company had previously been transferred to it – where the respondent contended that none of the persons who voted at the meeting of members was a member of the company and entitled to vote – where the name of the respondent was not recorded as a member of the company on the register maintained by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission – where no register for the company maintained in accordance with s 168 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) was produced or able to be located – whether the respondent was a member of the company pursuant to s 231 of the Corporations Act – whether the persons who resolved that the company be voluntarily wound up were members of the company and entitled to vote.

CORPORATIONS – WINDING UP – WINDING UP VOLUNTARILY – RESOLUTIONS – VALIDITY – where a meeting of members was called for the purpose of winding up the company now in liquidation – where it was resolved at the meeting that the company be voluntarily wound up and that the applicants be appointed as liquidators for that purpose – where there were procedural irregularities associated with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) ACN 158 431 148 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QSC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved a dispute over the membership of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd, a company that was in the process of being wound up. The applicants, who were appointed liquidators, sought to have it declared that the meeting of the company's members held on 5 May 2016 was validly called and that the company was voluntarily wound up. The respondent, who claimed to be the holder of all the shares in the company, argued that the persons who voted at the meeting were not members of the company and were therefore not entitled to vote. The respondent also argued that the resolution passed at the meeting was invalid due to procedural irregularities.

The legal issues before the court were whether the respondent was a member of the company and whether the persons who voted at the meeting were members and entitled to vote. The court had to determine whether the meeting was validly called, whether the resolution passed at the meeting was valid, and whether the respondent was a member of the company.

The court held that the meeting of the members of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd was validly called and that the resolution passed at the meeting was valid. The court found that the members of the company on registration were the persons identified in the application for registration and that each of those persons was entitled to vote in support of the resolutions passed on 5 May 2016. The court also held that the respondent was not a member of the company and that the persons who voted at the meeting were members and entitled to vote.

The orders of the court were that the meeting of the members of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd held on 5 May 2016 was validly called, that the company was voluntarily wound up by the special resolution passed by the members on that day, and that the applicants were appointed as liquidators of the company by the ordinary resolution passed by the members on that day. The costs of and incidental to the application brought by the applicants were to be the applicants' costs in the liquidation, and the cross application was dismissed. The respondent was ordered to pay the applicants' costs of and incidental to the cross application to be assessed on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders of the court are that:

1. It is declared that:

(a) The meeting of the members of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) held on 5 May 2016 was validly called;

(b) By the special resolution passed by the members of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) on 5 May 2016, the company was voluntarily wound up;

(c) By the ordinary resolution passed by the members of Cloudzillr Pty Ltd (in liq) on 5 May 2016, the applicants were appointed as liquidators of the company.

2. The costs of and incidental to the application brought by the applicants shall be the applicants’ costs in the liquidation.

3. The cross application is dismissed.

4. The respondent shall pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to the cross application to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before considering these competing claims, it is useful to set out something of the background to the issues that now divide the parties as well as some observations about the effect of the affidavit evidence before the court.Background In April 2012, Mr Falkenstein was working on a part-time basis as a consultant to a firm of solicitors in Brisbane. It was in this capacity that he was introduced to Mr Stuart Guest-Smith and Mr Surendranath Tippireddy. Mr Guest-Smith and Mr Tippireddy had developed, or caused to be developed, an Internet-based content delivery platform that was designed for use by subscribers from the health and fitness industry to distribute instructional training files in a digital (as opposed to a CD or DVD) format. They wanted to commence business in the marketing and sale of subscriptions to the platform and, to that end, it was proposed that a company be incorporated as the vehicle for that business. According to Mr Falkenstein, it was further proposed that:(a)Mr Guest-Smith would be the company’s chief executive officer and largest shareholder;(b)Mr Tippireddy would be the company’s chief technical officer and second largest shareholder;(c)Four other people would become shareholders and take up positions in the company, as follows: (i) Mr Dallas Clarke – lead engineer;(ii) Mr Aidan Green – lead designer;(iii) Ms Marietta Mehanni – industry adviser; and (iv) Ms Donna Ellerton – industry adviser; and(d)Mr Falkenstein would also become an adviser in exchange for a fixed proportion of the issued capital in the company. In the event, the company now in liquidation was registered on 18 May 2012. Mr Guest-Smith, Mr Tippireddy and Mr Falkenstein were appointed as the directors and Mr Falkenstein was also appointed as the secretary. A total of 9,450,000 ordinary shares was issued in the company. They were held by its members as follows:(a)Mr Guest-Smith – 3,800,000;(b)Mr Tippireddy – 1,950,000;(c)Mr Clarke – 1,650,000;(d)Mr Green – 1,500,000;(e)Ms Mehanni – 200,000;(f)Ms Ellerton – 100,000; and(g)Mr Falkenstein – 250,000.[2][2]These particulars are recorded in the application for registration completed by Mr Guest-Smith and lodged with ASIC on 18 May 2012. See Affidavit of Matthew Justin Hocking filed on 18 August 2012; Exhibit MJH-2. A little over a month later, Mr Falkenstein, Mr Guest-Smith and Mr Tippireddy entered into discussions that the respondent now contends culminated in the “exchange” of all of the shares in the company now in liquidation for shares in the respondent. This, the respondent argued, meant that the company became a wholly owned subsidiary of the respondent and, further, that the persons listed in the preceding paragraph ceased to be members of the company. If that was so, none of those persons was entitled to vote at the meeting of 5 May 2016. At first, Mr Falkenstein made an offer on behalf of an entity of which he was the sole director – Sunship Capital Partners Pty Ltd[3] – to invest up to $150,000 in the company. This was communicated in an email dated 21 June 2012 from Mr Falkenstein to Mr Guest-Smith and Mr Tippireddy. Mr Falkenstein proposed that the funds to be invested be “used to secure revenue & relationships in the USA” and that a “USA-domiciled … entity (with a mirrored shareholding to Cloudzillr Pty Ltd)” be acquired for that purpose.[4] The offer was for Sunship Capital Partners Pty Ltd to “subscribe for an additional 12.5% of [the company now in liquidation] for $100,000” together with a promise to “fund another $50,000 if required by the business”. Mr Falkenstein wrote, “Our intention is that Cloudzillr will license the IP from Australia into [the USA entity] until it is necessary (if it ever is) to transfer the IP to the USA entity”. Although Mr Falkenstein deposed that this offer was accepted by Mr Guest-Smith and Mr Tippireddy on or about 26 June 2012,[5] that would not appear to have been the case.[6][3]Sunship Capital Partners Pty Ltd was said by Mr Falkenstein to be “a company that acts as the manager of a partnership of trusts between [Falkenbridge] Pty Ltd as trustee for the Sunstein Trust and TL Falkenstein Nominees Pty Ltd as trustee for the TL Falkenstein Family Trust” (Affidavit of Kurt Daniel Falkenstein filed on 24 August 2016 at par 2.1), although no additional proof of the existence of these arrangements was advanced. The company, Sunship Capital Partners was deregistered on 11 May 2014: Affidavit of Matthew Justin Hocking filed on 18 August 2012; Exhibit MJH-3.[4]Affidavit of Kurt Daniel Falkenstein filed on 24 August 2016; Exhibit KDF-3. This exhibit appears to have been mistakenly referred to in the body of the affidavit (par 2.1) as Exhibit KDF-2.[5] Affidavit of Kurt Daniel Falkenstein filed on 24 August 2016 at par 2.2.[6]Mr Falkenstein purported to exhibit a “true copy of that acceptance”, but the document exhibited was not an acceptance. Rather, it was an email from Mr Guest-Smith to Mr Falkenstein (copying in Mr Tippireddy and Mr Tom Falkenstein) which was sent on 24 June 2012: see Affidavit of Kurt Daniel Falkenstein filed on 24 August 2016; the first of two exhibits marked Exhibit KDF-4. In it, Mr Guest-Smith acknowledged receipt of the offer of 21 June 2012 but indicated that he was seeking external advice in relation to it.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the sake of completeness, it should be recorded that an order was made at the hearing of 24 August 2016 (with the consent of the respondent) authorising the sale of the assets of the company now in liquidation.[33] [33] Transcript (24 August 2016), T. 1-27.Consideration A company’s members are those persons who are members on its registration along with such other persons who subsequently agree to be members and whose names are recorded in the company’s register as members: s 231 of the Act. As such, the recording of the person’s name on the register is a precondition to membership of the company. A mere entitlement to be recorded as a member is not enough; “the beneficial ownership of shares, without registration, does not make a person a shareholder.[34][34]Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Patcorp Investments Ltd (1976) 140 CLR 247 at 295; Kopilovic v Gatley (2005) 53 ACSR 64 at [48]. Largely for the reasons I have already expressed, and whilst it may be accepted that most (if not all) of the shareholders in the company now in liquidation agreed in 2012 to transfer their shares to the respondent in exchange for a proportionate allocation of shares in that corporation, it cannot be concluded on the evidence before the court that this in fact occurred. To the contrary, there are good reasons to doubt that what was then agreed was carried into effect. In the first place, if an exchange of shares actually took place so that the members of the company on registration became shareholders in the respondent, it is odd that, with notice of these applications, none of these persons came forward to support the respondent’s claims. The opinion expressed by Ms Dunn on behalf of the applicants is that the company in liquidation is likely to be hopelessly insolvent. On the other hand, there is no suggestion on the material that the affairs of the respondent are in that state. Accordingly, if the true position is that the members of the company on registration hold shares in a solvent corporation as opposed to shares in a company that is likely, in the opinion of the applicants, to be insolvent, I would have thought that those persons, or at least some of them, would have been concerned to support the respondent’s contentions, but none did. Secondly, neither the register for the company now in liquidation nor the register for the respondent was produced in evidence. So far as the company’s register is concerned, Mr Falkenstein swore that it was held by Mr Guest-Smith but that Mr Guest-Smith had not made any documentation available to the company since relocating to the United States of America in November 2014.[35] Why the company register would be held by Mr Guest-Smith when Mr Falkenstein was at all times the company secretary is not made clear but, even if that was capable of explanation, it is difficult to understand the submission otherwise made by Mr Falkenstein to the effect that the company kept a share register “in one place and at the company’s registered offices”.[36] The registered office of the company has changed over time but it has always been in Australia. It is in any event unnecessary to resolve that apparent conflict; the fact remains that no satisfactory evidence has been placed before the court to support the conclusion that the name of the respondent was entered on the register for the company or, indeed, that the respondent was entitled to be entered on the register. In the absence of such evidence, the court must proceed on the faith of the register maintained by ASIC.[37] Doing so, the members of the company in liquidation as at 5 May 2016 were the members on registration, that is to say, the persons identified above at [9] and each was entitled to vote in support of the resolutions passed that day. Those persons of course do not include the respondent.[35] Affidavit of Kurt Daniel Falkenstein filed on 24 August 2016 at par 1.11.[36] Submissions on behalf of the respondent dated 12 September 2016 at par 1.5.[37]In this regard, there is no requirement under the Act for the persons who were members of a company on its registration to also be entered on the company’s register before those persons may properly be regarded as members pursuant to s 231.