Re Carmichael

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Re Carmichael [2020] QSC 255

PARTIES:

IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION FOR BAIL BY TONY BOYD CARMICHAEL

TONY BOYD CARMICHAEL

(applicant)

v
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (QLD)

(respondent)

FILE NO:

BS No 5523 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

21 August 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

6 August 2020

Further written submissions received on 19 August 2020

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDER:

The application is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – PROCEDURE – BAIL – BEFORE TRIAL – MURDER CASES – where the applicant for bail is charged with one count of murder which is alleged to have occurred in 1997 – where this is the second application for bail – where the trial is set to begin on 12 October 2020 – where the application for bail is opposed by the Crown – where the applicant has a history of violence – where the applicant’s partner interfered with witnesses at the committal – where the Crown case is not without difficulties – whether there is a material change in circumstances – whether there is an unacceptable risk of interfering with witnesses – whether the applicant has demonstrated that his continued detention in custody pending trial is not justified

Bail Act 1980, s 9, s 13, s 16, s 21
Criminal Code, s 302, s 305, s 323
Drugs Misuse Act 1986
Justices Act
1886, s 71B
Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000

Fisher v Director of Public Prosecutions [2011] QCA 54, cited
IMM v R (2016) 257 CLR 300, cited
Keys v Director of Public Prosecutions [2009] QCA 220, cited
Lee v R (2014) 253 CLR 455, cited
R v Edwards [1989] 1 Qd R 139, followed
R v Hughes [1983] 1 Qd R 92, cited
Sica v Director of Public Prosecutions
[2011] 2 Qd R 254, cited
X7 v Australian Crime Commission (2013) 248 CLR 92, cited

COUNSEL:

D Walsh for the applicant

M Whitbread for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

AW Bale & Son Solicitors for the applicant

Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) for the respondent

  1. The applicant, Tony Boyd Carmichael, is charged with one count of murder.  He applies for bail.  This is his second application.  His first was refused by Bowskill J on 25 June 2019.

  2. An indictment has been presented in the Supreme Court at Brisbane in these terms:

    “that on a date unknown between the seventh day of May, 1997 and the seventh day of November, 1997 at Maryborough or elsewhere in the State of Queensland, TONY BOYD CARMICHAEL murdered GREGORY JOHN ARMSTRONG.” (emphasis in original)

  3. Particulars have been delivered as follows:

    “The accused is liable for the murder of GREGORY JOHN ARMSTRONG because he caused the death of GREGORY JOHN ARMSTRONG by deliberately shooting him in the head. (Section 7(1)(a) of the Criminal Code)”

  4. The trial on the indictment is listed to be heard by Applegarth J and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Carmichael and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QSC 255
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Carmichael, the applicant was seeking bail prior to the commencement of his trial for the murder of Gregory Armstrong. The trial was scheduled to begin on 12 October 2020 before Applegarth J in Brisbane. This was the second application for bail. The Crown opposed the application, citing the applicant’s history of violence and allegations that his partner had interfered with witnesses at the committal stage.

The court was required to decide whether there had been a material change in circumstances since the first bail application, and whether the applicant had demonstrated that his continued detention in custody pending trial was not justified. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the risk of the applicant interfering with witnesses was acceptable. The applicant had a history of violence, and the Crown case faced some difficulties. The court had to weigh these factors against the applicant’s right to liberty and the need to ensure the integrity of the trial process.

The court dismissed the application for bail. It found that the applicant had not demonstrated a material change in circumstances since the first application and that the risk of witness interference remained a significant concern. The history of violence and the Crown’s case difficulties weighed heavily against granting bail. The court concluded that the applicant’s continued detention was justified to ensure the proper administration of justice and to protect potential witnesses.

The final orders were that the application for bail was dismissed, and the applicant would remain in custody pending the commencement of the trial on 12 October 2020.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The trial on the indictment is listed to be heard by Applegarth J and is to commence on 12 October 2020 in Brisbane.Background Gregory Armstrong was a resident of Maryborough. He had some intellectual limitations. He went missing in 1997 around the time of his birthday on 7 May. The applicant, at the time of Mr Armstrong’s disappearance, was also a resident of Maryborough. A police investigation commenced and numerous witnesses were interviewed. These witnesses included Susan Gabrielle Messer and Robyn Frances McCullock.[1] They are of particular significance, as I will later explain. The witnesses who made statements shortly after Mr Armstrong’s disappearance covered various topics, including:(a)Mr Armstrong’s movements up until the time of his disappearance;(b)the fact that Mr Armstrong has not been seen since May 1997;(c)Mr Armstrong’s associates including an association with the applicant; and(d)Mr Armstrong’s association with illicit drugs.[1]Statement of Robyn Frances Gilmore (now McCullock), dated 26 November 1997; Statement of Susan Gabrielle Messer, dated 20 August 1998. In those witness statements, the applicant is mentioned quite regularly. The witnesses spoke of the applicant dealing in illicit drugs and committing acts of violence.[2] Suspicion is also cast on other persons.[2]For example, witnesses Jason Graham McCarthy and Nicole Lee Severs. The applicant left Maryborough in late August 1997. On 2 September 1997, he killed a man by shooting him. He was charged with murder and wounding.[3] He was arrested and remanded in custody.[3]Criminal Code, ss 302 and 323. On 21 May 1998, the applicant was convicted of manslaughter and wounding and sentenced to 11 years’ imprisonment. By about the year 2000, the investigation into Mr Armstrong’s disappearance had stalled. Witnesses had told police that there were rumours that the applicant had shot and killed Mr Armstrong over a drug debt.[4] There was no admissible evidence to support such a theory. Mr Armstrong remained missing. While the Crown alleges that Mr Armstrong is dead, his body has never been located.[4]For example, see witnesses Larney Joy Hancock, Robyn Frances Gilmore (now McCullock), Susan Gabrielle Messer, Andrew John Dobbermann, Terrence Edward Bristow, Dennis Ilka. Police then referred the case to the Queensland Crime Commission.[5] Various witnesses were summonsed and examined, including the applicant.[5]Crime Commission Act 1997 (now repealed). The functions of the Queensland Crime Commission are now fulfilled by the Crime and Corruption Commission by force of the Crime and Corruption Commission Act 2001. No-one was charged with any offence concerning Mr Armstrong’s disappearance and presumed death following the Queensland Crime Commission investigation. The matter was then referred to the Coroner and a coronial investigation was conducted. No inquest was heard but in due course a report of the Coroner was delivered. The coronial inquiry was governed by the now repealed Coroners Act 1958.[6] The coroner concluded that Mr Armstrong was likely dead but made no meaningful findings about the circumstances of the death. It seems that the investigation then again stalled. [6]Now see Coroners Act 2003.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established