Re Burton, L.R. v Ex Parte Wily, H.J.

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA                 )
GENERAL DIVISION  )
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE STATE          )       No NB 2172 of 1993
OF NEW SOUTH WALES  )

RE:  LESLIE ROSS BURTON
  of 25 Overett Avenue Kemps Creek
  in the State of New South Wales

EX PARTE:          HUGH JENNER WILY

Applicant/First Cross-Respondent

BRANDOWN PTY LIMITED
  ACN 003 830 304

First Respondent

NJW CONTRACTORS PTY LIMITED
  ACN 000 730 192

Second Respondent/Cross-Claimant

PATRICK JAMES HALLINAN
  MAX DAVID RODGERS and
  GEORGE FRANK RODGERS

Third Respondent/
  Second Cross-Respondent
  AND

EX PARTE:          LESLIE ROSS BURTON

Applicant

HUGH JENNER WILY

Respondent
Coram:        Davies J
Date:          26 July 1995
Place:         Sydney

CORRIGENDA

Amendments to the Reasons for Judgment delivered on 26 July 1995:-

  1. Page 40 - 5th line from bottom of page - laser printer error - should read "declare them to be void through some irregularity if the deed complied substantially .."

  1. Page 46, last paragraph, 2nd line.  The word "noted" should be "voted".

  1. Page 56, 2nd last line.  The sum "$4,000" should be "$5,000".

  1. Page 79, Order 2, third line.  The word "the" appears twice.  Delete second "the".

  1. Order 3 on page 79.  The name "Brandown Pty Ltd" is to be substituted for the name "NJW Contractors Pty Ltd".

Associate to Justice Davies
  2 August 1995

C A T C H W O R D S

BANKRUPTCY - application for declaration that a settlement of property of the bankrupt was void as against trustee in bankrutpcy - whether settlement was made within the period of 2 years before the commencement of the bankruptcy - transfer dated as executed before the commencement of the period - whether transfer made in good faith and for valuable consideration - nominal consideration given for asset which had substantial value - operation of s.120 Bankruptcy Act.

BANKRUPTCY - annulment - Court must be satisfied that sequestration order ought not to have been made and that the order ought to be anulled - bankrupt was insolvent at the time of the making of the sequestration order - factors relevant to exercise of discretion under s.153B Bankruptcy Act - no point of principle raised - affairs of the bankrupt and associated companies involved inadequate documentation, fabrication of debts and disposition of assets without good faith - public interest and interest of creditors that the affairs of the bankrupt be managed by a trustee - operation of s.153B Bankruptcy Act.

BANKRUPTCY - application that trustee in bankruptcy should be removed - whether trustee had acted independently in the best interests of creditors - actions taken by the trustee were reasonable in the circumstances - factors relevant to exercise of discretion under s.179 Bankruptcy Act.

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) - ss.120, 153B, 179, 306

Barton v Official Receiver (1986) 161 CLR 74
Chirigakis v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1986) 68 ALR 527
In Re La Rosa; Ex parte Norgard v Rocom Pty Ltd (1990) 21 FCR 270
Kleinwort Benson Australia Ltd v Crowl (1988) 165 CLR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Burton, L.R. v Ex Parte Wily, H.J. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] FCA 555
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved two main applications. The first application, brought by Hugh Jenner Wily, the trustee of Leslie Ross Burton's bankrupt estate, sought a declaration that a transfer of two shares in Brandown Pty Limited from Mr Burton to NJW Contractors Pty Limited was void as against the trustee in bankruptcy. The second application, brought by Mr Burton himself, sought an order annulling his bankruptcy or, alternatively, removing Mr Wily as his trustee in bankruptcy. The court had to decide whether the transfer of shares was a settlement void against the trustee and whether the sequestration order should be annulled or the trustee removed.

The court found that the transfer of the two shares in Brandown Pty Limited from Mr Burton to NJW Contractors Pty Limited was a settlement made within two years before the commencement of the bankruptcy and was not made in good faith and for valuable consideration. Therefore, the transfer was void as against the trustee in bankruptcy. The court also found that the sequestration order should not be annulled, and Mr Wily should not be removed as trustee in bankruptcy. The court held that Mr Burton was insolvent at the time of the making of the sequestration order, and there was no substantive injustice caused by the defects and irregularities in the conduct of the creditors' meeting. Furthermore, the court found that Mr Wily had acted properly and in the best interests of the creditors, and it would not be in the interests of creditors to annul the bankruptcy.

The final orders of the court were that the application to annul the bankruptcy and to remove Mr Wily as trustee of the bankrupt estate was dismissed, the transfer by the bankrupt of 2 shares in Brandown Pty Ltd to NJW Contractors Pty Ltd was void as against the trustee of the bankrupt estate, the records of NJW Contractors Pty Ltd be rectified to record Mr Wily as the holder of the shares, and costs be reserved. The cross-claim on behalf of NJW Contractors Pty Limited against the first respondent and the third respondents was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Leslie Ross Burton was involved in various business ventures, including the purchase of a valuable property known as the Kemp's Creek quarry, which was suitable for use as a tip. In 1989, Brandown Pty Limited was established to purchase the property. Burton, along with Patrick Hallinan and Max and George Rodgers, became shareholders in Brandown. However, Burton faced financial difficulties in the early 1990s and decided to transfer his shares in Brandown to NJW Contractors Pty Limited, a dormant company. The transfer was dated 1 August 1989 but was not signed until sometime between July and October 1992. Burton's estate was sequestrated on 8 July 1993, and the trustee of the bankrupt estate, Hugh Jenner Wily, sought to declare the transfer of shares to NJW void under s.120(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). Burton, the bankrupt, sought an order annulling his bankruptcy or removing Wily as his trustee, arguing that the sequestration order should not have been made.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia in the General Division, Bankruptcy District of the State of New South Wales. The proceedings involved multiple applications, including the Brandown application, which sought to declare the transfer of shares void, and the annulment application, which sought to annul Burton's bankruptcy and remove Wily as trustee. The cross-claim by NJW Contractors Pty Limited against Brandown Pty Limited and others was not pursued. The case was heard over several dates in 1994 and early 1995, with the final judgment delivered on 26 July 1995.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the transfer by the bankrupt, Leslie Ross Burton, of 2 shares in Brandown Pty Ltd to NJW Contractors Pty Ltd is void as against the trustee of the bankrupt estate under s.120(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).
2. Whether the sequestration order made on 8 July 1993 should be annulled or the trustee, Hugh Jenner Wily, should be removed, based on the arguments presented by the bankrupt, Leslie Ross Burton.

Held
1. The court declares that the transfer by the bankrupt, Leslie Ross Burton, of 2 shares in Brandown Pty Ltd to NJW Contractors Pty Ltd is void as against the trustee of the bankrupt estate under s.120(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).
2. The court dismisses the application to annul the bankruptcy and to remove Hugh Jenner Wily as trustee of the bankrupt estate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the transfer of two shares in Brandown Pty Ltd by Leslie Ross Burton to NJW Contractors Pty Ltd. It was established that the transfer occurred within two years before the bankruptcy and did not meet the criteria of a settlement made in good faith and for valuable consideration as required by s.120(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). The shares were transferred for a nominal consideration and were used to protect assets from creditors, indicating an intent to defraud. Thus, the transfer was void against the trustee in bankruptcy.

Regarding the annulment application, the court found that Leslie Ross Burton was insolvent at the time of the sequestration order and that annulling the bankruptcy would not be in the public interest or in the best interests of creditors. The trustee, Hugh Jenner Wily, had acted reasonably and in the best interests of creditors by seeking to recover assets and manage the bankrupt estate effectively. The court considered various factors, including Burton's lack of transparency, fabrication of debts, and inadequate record-keeping, concluding that annulling the bankruptcy was not warranted. The court also noted the creditors' confidence in the trustee's handling of the estate and rejected Burton's late-stage application for annulment.