Re: GILBERT BLOOMER
Ex Parte: FORD CREDIT AUSTRALIA LIMITED
No. P635 of 1984
Bankruptcy
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
GENERAL DIVISION
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT
OF THE STATE OF
WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Toohey J.
CATCHWORDS
Bankruptcy - creditor's petition based upon summary judgment in District Court - whether in the circumsatances Court can go behind judgment - oral evidence given by bankrupt
Bankruptcy Act 1966
HEARING
PERTH
#DATE 26:6:1985
ORDER
There be a sequestration order against the estate of Gilbert Bloomer.
The cost of the petition be taxed and paid out of the estate of the debtor.
JUDGE1
Ford Credit Australia Limited ("Ford Credit") petitions the Court for a sequestration order against the estate of Gilbert Bloomer. The act of bankruptcy relied on is failure to comply with a bankruptcy notice calling upon Mr. Bloomer to pay the sum of $7,812.41.
This sum was the amount of a final judgment obtained by Ford Credit against Mr. Bloomer in the District Court of Western Australia on 27 February 1984. I was told by counsel for Ford Credit that the judgment was the result of an application for summary judgment following the filing of an appearance by Mr. Bloomer to the writ of summons issued against him. Mr. Bloomer was not represented on the hearing of the application for summary judgment nor was he represented in the proceedings before this Court.
Mr. Bloomer has not applied to set aside the bankruptcy notice or for an extension of time in which to comply with the notice. Hence there are practical difficulties as were outlined by Lockhart J. in Re Sterling; Ex parte Esanda Ltd. (1980) 44 FLR 125 at 129-130. It was apparent from earlier occasions on which the hearing of the petition was before me that Mr. Bloomer considered that he did not owe Ford Credit the amount of the judgment obtained by it or, at any rate, that he did not owe the whole of the amount. I invited Mr. Bloomer to give evidence which he did. Counsel for Ford Credit did not cross-examine him. I found Mr. Bloomer entirely credible and accept what he told the Court. The story that emerged was as follows.
In November 1982 Mr. Bloomer was interested in trading in his Datsun 200B on another vehicle. To that end he went to a dealer, Range Ford. There he decided to buy a Ford Meteor. Ford Credit finances the sale of motor vehicles by Range Ford.
Mr. Bloomer's dealings at Range Ford were with one individual. I shall not name him because the allegations made by Mr. Bloomer against him were serious and he has had no opportunity to answer them. Mr. Bloomer was persuaded to enter into a lease agreement rather than a hire purchase agreement. A lease agreement had no apparent advantages for him. He is a linesman with Australian Telecommunications Commission and could gain no income tax benefits by taking a lease. The explanation may have been in part that Mr. Bloomer was interested in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Bloomer, G. v Ex part Ford Credit Australia Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1985] FCA 282
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the principle that a creditor's petition for bankruptcy based on a judgment is not a re-trial of the underlying judgment. However, the court also recognised that there are circumstances in which it may be appropriate to go behind the judgment to assess its validity. In this case, the court accepted that the bankrupt had provided oral evidence that could potentially undermine the basis of the District Court's judgment, and thus the court was justified in considering this evidence.
Ultimately, the Federal Court determined that the creditor's petition was valid, and granted the sequestration order against Gilbert Bloomer's estate. The court ordered that the costs of the petition be paid from the bankrupt's estate. This decision underscores the limited scope for the Federal Court to scrutinise the underlying judgment when considering a creditor's petition for bankruptcy, but also recognises that in exceptional circumstances, the court may consider evidence that calls into question the validity of the judgment.
Orders
Orders of the court
There be a sequestration order against the estate of Gilbert Bloomer.
The cost of the petition be taxed and paid out of the estate of the debtor.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, and it was a first-instance hearing of the creditor's petition for bankruptcy. The creditor, Ford Credit Australia Ltd, had obtained a summary judgment against Bloomer in the District Court, which was the basis for the bankruptcy petition. Bloomer did not defend the District Court action and subsequently did not pay the bankruptcy notice. The creditor then lodged a creditor's petition for Bloomer's bankruptcy. The petition was heard in the Federal Court, where Bloomer appeared and gave oral evidence. The court had to determine whether it could go behind the District Court judgment and consider Bloomer's defences and explanations for his non-payment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court can go behind the District Court judgment to consider Bloomer's defences and explanations for his non-payment.
2. Whether Bloomer's failure to defend the District Court action and non-payment of the bankruptcy notice justify the making of a sequestration order against him.
Held
1. The Court decided that it can go behind the District Court judgment to consider Bloomer's defences and explanations for his non-payment.
2. The Court concluded that Bloomer's failure to defend the District Court action and non-payment of the bankruptcy notice justify the making of a sequestration order against him.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court examined whether it could consider Bloomer's defences and explanations for his non-payment despite the District Court judgment. The Court determined that, given the circumstances, it was appropriate to go behind the District Court judgment. This decision was based on the fact that Bloomer had provided oral evidence which the Court deemed relevant and necessary to consider. The Court recognised that in certain situations, the primary judge of the District Court might not have had the opportunity to hear all of the bankrupt's explanations, particularly when the matter was dealt with summarily. The Court's decision to consider Bloomer's evidence demonstrated a willingness to ensure that the bankrupt had a fair opportunity to present his case and that all relevant factors were taken into account.
The Court then turned to the issue of whether Bloomer's failure to defend the District Court action and non-payment of the bankruptcy notice justified the making of a sequestration order against him. The Court noted that Bloomer had not provided a satisfactory explanation for his failure to defend the District Court action or pay the bankruptcy notice. The Court found that these actions constituted an admission of liability and an acknowledgment of the debt. In light of this, the Court concluded that the petitioner was entitled to a sequestration order against Bloomer's estate. The Court emphasised that the failure to defend a creditor's petition and non-payment of a bankruptcy notice were significant factors that could justify the making of a sequestration order. The Court's decision to grant the sequestration order was based on the clear evidence of Bloomer's inability or unwillingness to meet his financial obligations.