Re BLK

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

MENTAL HEALTH COURT

CITATION:

Re BLK [2016] QMHC 7

PARTIES:

REFERENCE BY THE DEFENDANT’S LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE IN RESPECT OF BLK

FILE NO/S:

No 237 of 2014

DELIVERED ON:

22 August 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

18 July 2016

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ASSISTING PSYCHIATRISTS:

Dr S Harden
Dr R Phillipson

ORDER:

1. At the time of each of the alleged offences the subject of the reference, the defendant was not of unsound mind as defined in the schedule to the Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld).

2.   In respect of each of the alleged offences, the defendant is unfit for trial, and that unfitness is of a permanent nature.

3.   The defendant be detained, pursuant to a forensic order Mental Health Court – Disability to the Mackay Authorised Mental Health Service.

4.   Limited community treatment be approved, at the discretion of the authorised psychiatrist, on the terms and conditions set out in the draft proffered by the Director of Mental Health.

5.   Copies of the reports and of the transcript be provided to the parties, to the treating team, to the Mental Health Review Tribunal and to the Attorney-General.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – PROCEDURE – FITNESS TO PLEAD OR BE TRIED – DETERMINATION OF ISSUES – where the defendant suffers from significant intellectual impairments – where, as a consequence of those impairments, the defendant has significant cognitive deficits, including in memory retention and information processing – where those particular deficits rendered it difficult for the defendant to be able to retain the necessary information as the evidence unfolded in order to instruct counsel – where there was a significant risk the defendant would confabulate any account given by her, both in evidence and in giving instruction to her legal representatives – whether the defendant’s intellectual impairments render her permanently unfit for trial

Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld), Schedule

Berg v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) [2015] QCA 196, cited
Kesavarajah v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 230; [1994] HCA 41, cited
R v Presser (1958) VR 45, applied

COUNSEL:

JD Briggs for the defendant

MB Lehane for the Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)
SJ Hamlyn-Harris for the Director of Mental Health

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for the defendant

Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)
Crown Law for the Director of Mental Health

  1. BODDICE J:  By reference, filed 4 September 2014, Legal Aid Queensland referred to this Court the mental condition of BLK at the time of alleged offences of indecent treatment of a child under 16 years of age (with circumstances of aggravation, namely that the child was under 12 years and a lineal descendent of the defendant), between 6 June 2013 and 29 July 2013, and distributing child exploitation material, between 6 June 2013 and 17 August 2013. 

  2. There is no dispute the defendant was not of unsound mind at the time of the alleged offences.  At issue is whether as a consequence of the defendant’s intellectual impairment she is permanently unfit for trial. 

    Background

  3. The defendant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re BLK and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QMHC 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties involved in the case of Re BLK were the defendant, born on 10 March 1985, and the state. The defendant was charged with offences related to taking a photograph of her 8-year-old daughter's vagina and forwarding it to her ex-partner. The central issue before the court was whether the defendant's intellectual impairments rendered her permanently unfit for trial. The defendant had a history of significant intellectual impairment, which resulted in cognitive deficits affecting memory retention and information processing. These impairments made it difficult for her to follow the evidence and provide instructions to her legal counsel. There was also a risk that she would confabulate any account given by her, both in evidence and in instructing her legal representatives.

The court needed to determine whether the defendant's intellectual impairments rendered her permanently unfit for trial. The psychiatrist who examined the defendant, Dr Schramm, opined that the defendant's intellectual impairment was of such a degree that she should be seen as permanently unfit for trial. Although she could convey her version of events with difficulty, she did not have the intellectual capacity to adequately follow and provide sensible instructions. Furthermore, she would not be able to understand what was going on in the courtroom beyond a simple appreciation and did not have sufficient intellectual ability to understand the weight of the evidence against her, even though she may understand the allegations. Based on these findings, the court determined that the defendant was unfit for trial and that this unfitness was of a permanent nature.

In light of the court's determination that the defendant was permanently unfit for trial, the court ordered her detention pursuant to a forensic order to the Mackay Authorised Mental Health Service. Limited community treatment was also approved, at the discretion of the authorised psychiatrist, on the terms and conditions set out in the draft proffered by the Director of Mental Health. Additionally, copies of the reports and of the transcript were to be provided to the parties, to the treating team, to the Mental Health Review Tribunal, and to the Attorney-General.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. At the time of each of the alleged offences the subject of the reference, the defendant was not of unsound mind as defined in the schedule to the Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld).

2. In respect of each of the alleged offences, the defendant is unfit for trial, and that unfitness is of a permanent nature.

3. The defendant be detained, pursuant to a forensic order Mental Health Court – Disability to the Mackay Authorised Mental Health Service.

4. Limited community treatment be approved, at the discretion of the authorised psychiatrist, on the terms and conditions set out in the draft proffered by the Director of Mental Health.

5. Copies of the reports and of the transcript be provided to the parties, to the treating team, to the Mental Health Review Tribunal and to the Attorney-General.

Background

Background to the litigation

There is no dispute the defendant was not of unsound mind at the time of the alleged offences. At issue is whether as a consequence of the defendant’s intellectual impairment she is permanently unfit for trial. Background The defendant was born on 10 March 1985. She is a single woman. She has received a disability support pension since her teenage years. She suffers from a marked intellectual impairment with significant cognitive deficits. The defendant does not have a past psychiatric history of any significance. She has previously been prescribed anti-depressants and had on one occasion been admitted to a mental health unit, apparently as a consequence of suicidal thoughts. She has previously been diagnosed with cerebral palsy and epilepsy, as well as depression and anxiety. Alleged offences The victim in the alleged offences is the defendant’s 8 year old daughter. It is alleged the defendant, at the request of her ex-partner, pulled down her daughter’s underpants and took a photo of her child’s vagina on her mobile phone. She then allegedly forwarded that photograph to her ex-partner. The defendant gave an account to police about her actions. Relevantly, she said she complied with the request of her ex-partner because of fear she would be assaulted by him. There is no previous record of reported domestic violence incidents involving the defendant and her ex-partner. Reporting psychiatrists Dr Schramm interviewed the defendant on 7 July 2014. He opined that the defendant suffers from a mild to moderate intellectual disability with significant deficits in reasoning, judgment, problem solving and abstract thinking. He noted she had a past dysfunctional life with a history of physical and sexual abuse at the hands of others who had taken advantage of her disabilities. Dr Schramm opined that having regard to what was alleged to be a highly abusive relationship with her ex-partner, it is likely the defendant at the time of the alleged offences was suffering marked problems in her mood consistent with a diagnosis of “adjustment disorder with depressed and anxious mood”. However, there was no evidence of any deprivation of capacity by reason of her natural mental infirmity or any mental illness. Dr Schramm accepted the defendant’s intellectual impairment would have impaired her capacity to fully appreciate the impact of her alleged behaviour. However, she retained a reasonable appreciation that the alleged offences were not only illegal but wrong. Similarly, whilst her intellectual and emotional immaturity would have impaired the defendant’s capacity to control, it would not have deprived her of that capacity. Accordingly, Dr Schramm did not support a finding of unsound mind. Dr Schramm opined that the defendant’s intellectual impairment was of such a degree that she should be seen as permanently unfit for trial. Whilst she may be able to convey her version of events, with difficulty, she did not have the intellectual capacity to adequately follow and provide sensible instructions. She would not be able to understand what was going on in the courtroom, beyond a simple appreciation. She also did not have sufficient intellectual ability to understand the weight of the evidence against her, even though she may understand the allegations.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established