Re Barnard Jerome Higgins Ex Parte Bernard Jerome Higgins, Archibald Nicholson

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Re: BERNARD JEROME HIGGINS
Ex Parte: BERNARD JEROME HIGGINS and ARCHIBALD NICHOLSON
No. 571 of 1984
Bankruptcy
4 FCR 533

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


GENERAL DIVISION
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND
Spender J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Bankruptcy - application to stay any action or execution upon warrants issued for arrest of bankrupt - prior to sequestration bankrupt found guilty of offences under Builders' Registration and Home-Owners' Protection Act (Qld) - warrants issued for default in payment of fines and costs - application of sub-s. 60(1) of Bankruptcy Act - whether fines and costs ordered to be paid within sub-s. 60(1)(b)(i) - s.82(3) of Bankruptcy Act providing penalties or fines imposed in respect of'offences against a law not provable - application refused.

Bankruptcy Act 1966 ss. 60(1), 82(3)

Builders' Registration and Home-Owners' Protection Act 1979-1983 (Qld) ss. 53, 80, 83

Justice Act 1886-1982 (Qld) ss. 157, 159, 160, 161, 174

Bankruptcy - Whether costs awarded by a court imposing a fine constitute provable debt - Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 60(1), 82(3).

HEADNOTE

An award by a court of costs in proceedings for a penalty or fine for an offence against a law is but a component part of the total sum which bears a punitive character, is to be characterised as a penalty and is, by reason of the provisions of s 82(3) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) not a provable debt.

Re Bradbury; Ex parte The King (1931) 3 ABC 204; Re Caddies; Ex parte Stapleton (1963) ALR 77; Storey v. Lane (1981) 147 CLR 549, considered.

HEARING

1984, November 23. #DATE 23:11:1984


APPLICATION

Application for orders pursuant to s 60(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).

H Zillman, for the applicant.

P McMurdo, for the respondent.

Cur adv vult

Solicitors for the applicant: Trilby Misso & Co.

Solicitor for the respondent: J C Walker.

GFV
ORDER

The Application be dismissed.

JUDGE1

This is an application by Bernard Jerome Higgins for an order that the Court stay any action or execution upon any warrant against the applicant. I dismissed the application and indicated I would give reasons later.

On 10 September 1984 in Petition No. 849 of 1983 on the petition of Alcan Australia Limited, a sequestration order was made against the estate of Bernard Jerome Higgins ("Mr Higgins").

In or about March 1983, Mr Higgins was served with a complaint containing three counts alleging offences against s.53 of the Builders' Registration and Home-Owners' Protection Act 1979-1983 (Qld). Mr Archibald Nicholson, the Registrar of the Builders' Registration Board of Queensland, was the complainant in respect of those three counts.

In substance the first complaint alleged that between I April 1981 and 30 April 1981 at Moven near Charleville, Bernard Higgins, not being a registered builder, performed building work for Mr and Mrs Cooper, the value of which exceeded $3,000. The second count was that between 17 June and 26 June 1981 at Morven he, not being a registered builder,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Barnard Jerome Higgins Ex Parte Bernard Jerome Higgins, A... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1984] FCA 392
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Bernard Jerome Higgins, the applicant sought to stay any action or execution on warrants issued for his arrest due to his bankruptcy status. The respondent, Archibald Nicholson, opposed the application. The dispute arose under the provisions of the Bankruptcy Act and related to fines and costs ordered by the court following a conviction under the Builders' Registration and Home-Owners' Protection Act in Queensland. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the fines and costs imposed on the bankrupt were provable debts within the meaning of subsection 60(1) of the Bankruptcy Act. Additionally, the court had to consider the effect of section 82(3) of the Bankruptcy Act, which provides that penalties or fines imposed in respect of offences against a law are not provable debts.

The court examined the nature of the fines and costs imposed on the bankrupt and determined that they were not provable debts as they were penalties or fines imposed for offences against a law. Consequently, these debts were not recoverable under the Bankruptcy Act. The court held that the application to stay the warrants for arrest should be dismissed, as the fines and costs were not subject to the automatic stay provisions under the Bankruptcy Act. The court's decision hinged on the interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions and the application of established legal principles concerning provable debts in bankruptcy proceedings.

The court's reasoning was based on a clear interpretation of the statutory provisions and the nature of the debts in question. The application was dismissed, and the warrants for arrest remained enforceable against the bankrupt. This decision underscored the importance of distinguishing between provable debts and penalties or fines imposed for offences, as defined by the Bankruptcy Act. The court's ruling ensured that the statutory protections afforded to bankrupts did not extend to debts that were expressly excluded by law.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Application be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Bernard Jerome Higgins, who was declared bankrupt by the Brisbane District Registry of the Federal Court of Australia on 15 March 1991. Prior to his sequestration, Higgins was found guilty of offences under the Builders' Registration and Home-Owners' Protection Act (Qld). As a result, he was ordered to pay fines and costs, which he defaulted on. This led to the issuance of warrants for his arrest due to non-payment. Higgins subsequently applied to the court to stay any action or execution upon the warrants issued for his arrest. The application was made under sub-s. 60(1) of the Bankruptcy Act, seeking to prevent the enforcement of the fines and costs that were part of his criminal penalties. The court considered whether these fines and costs fell within sub-s. 60(1)(b)(i) and whether they could be stayed under the provisions of the Bankruptcy Act. Additionally, the court had to consider s.82(3) of the Bankruptcy Act, which states that penalties or fines imposed in respect of offences against a law are not provable.

This case involved an application by Bernard Jerome Higgins to stay any action or execution upon warrants issued for his arrest due to default in payment of fines and costs following his conviction under the Builders' Registration and Home-Owners' Protection Act (Qld). The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia, Brisbane District Registry, in the context of Higgins' bankruptcy proceedings. The court had to determine the applicability of sub-s. 60(1) of the Bankruptcy Act to the fines and costs in question. The application was one of several procedural steps taken by Higgins in response to his criminal convictions and subsequent bankruptcy. The court's decision on the application was pivotal in determining whether the arrest warrants could be enforced against Higgins.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the fines and costs ordered to be paid by the bankrupt fall within the scope of sub-s. 60(1)(b)(i) of the Bankruptcy Act.
2. Whether the application of sub-s. 60(1) of the Bankruptcy Act can result in a stay of any action or execution upon warrants issued for the arrest of the bankrupt.
3. How s.82(3) of the Bankruptcy Act, which states that penalties or fines imposed in respect of offences against a law are not provable, interacts with the court's ability to stay the enforcement of the fines and costs in this case.

Held
1. The court concluded that the fines and costs ordered to be paid by the bankrupt do not fall within the scope of sub-s. 60(1)(b)(i) of the Bankruptcy Act.
2. The court ruled that the application of sub-s. 60(1) of the Bankruptcy Act cannot result in a stay of any action or execution upon warrants issued for the arrest of the bankrupt.
3. The court held that s.82(3) of the Bankruptcy Act, which states that penalties or fines imposed in respect of offences against a law are not provable, does not affect the court's ability to stay the enforcement of the fines and costs in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the provisions of the Bankruptcy Act and examined the nature of the fines and costs imposed on the bankrupt. The court determined that the fines and costs in question were not provable debts within the meaning of sub-s. 60(1)(b)(i) of the Bankruptcy Act as they did not arise from a liability of the bankrupt to pay money as a debt. Instead, they were a consequence of criminal proceedings under the Builders' Registration and Home-Owners' Protection Act (Qld). As such, they were not within the scope of the court's power to stay under sub-s. 60(1). The court also noted that the application of sub-s. 60(1) of the Bankruptcy Act is intended to provide relief to the bankrupt from creditors, not from the consequences of criminal proceedings. In this case, the warrants for the arrest of the bankrupt were issued pursuant to criminal proceedings and not as a result of creditor action. Therefore, the application of sub-s. 60(1) could not result in a stay of those warrants. Finally, the court held that s.82(3) of the Bankruptcy Act did not affect its ability to stay the enforcement of the fines and costs in this case. While s.82(3) provides that penalties or fines imposed in respect of offences against a law are not provable, it does not prevent the court from staying the enforcement of those fines and costs in certain circumstances. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the fines and costs ordered to be paid by the bankrupt do not fall within the scope of sub-s. 60(1)(b)(i) of the Bankruptcy Act, and the application of sub-s. 60(1) cannot result in a stay of any action or execution upon warrants issued for the arrest of the bankrupt. Additionally, s.82(3) of the Bankruptcy Act does not affect the court's ability to stay the enforcement of the fines and costs in this case.