[2004] FamCA 297
FAMILY LAW ACT 1975
IN THE FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(By Court Order
the File Number is Suppressed)
RE ALEX : Hormonal Treatment For
Gender Identity Dysphoria
BEFORE: Nicholson CJ
DATES OF HEARING: 15 December 2003, 8 and 15 January 2004 and 22 and 23 February 2004, 8 April 2004
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 13 April 2004
APPEARANCES:
(By Court Order the Names of Counsel and Solicitors has been Suppressed)
INDEX
HEADING PARAGRAPH NUMBER
Introduction.................................................................................... [1]
The Application ............................................................................ [6]
Additional Parties........................................................................ [12]
Terminology................................................................................. [16]
The Final Orders Sought in the Initiating Application......... [19]
Sources of Evidence.................................................................. [28]
The Applicant............................................................................. [29]
The Child Representative......................................................... [39]
The Hearing Process.................................................................. [41]
Interim Substantive Orders....................................................... [44]
Background History................................................................... [50]
Family Circumstances............................................................... [51]
Protective Intervention by the Applicant.................................. [62]
Alex’s Gender Identity................................................................ [79]
Gender Identity Dysphoria...................................................... [100]
Alex’s Sexual Identity............................................................... [103]
The Treatment Proposed for Alex......................................... [109]
The Future Arrangements in Which The Proposed Treatment Would Occur...................................................................................................... [124]
Residence and Guardianship................................................ [124]
Educational.............................................................................. [136]
Jurisdiction................................................................................ [143]
Whether the Child or Young Person is Currently under a Care Order [151]
Whether the Child or Young Person Himself Can Consent to the Procedure [154]
The Subject Matter of the Application................................... [174]
Specific Additional Findings.................................................. [201]
The Re Marion (No. 2) Matters............................................... [202]
(i) The particular condition of the child or young person which requires the procedure or treatment.......................................................................... [202]
(ii) The nature of the procedure or treatment proposed... [203]
(iii) The reasons for which it is proposed that the procedure or treatment be carried out.......................................................................................... [205]
(iv) The alternative courses of treatment that are available in relation to that condition............................................................................................... [206]
(v) The desirability of and effect of authorising the procedure for treatment proposed rather than available alternatives....................................... [207]
(vi) The physical effects on the child or young person and the psychological and social implications for the child or young person of authorising the proposed procedure or treatment or not authorising the proposed procedure or treatment............................................................................................... [208]
(vii) The nature and degree of any risk to the child or young person of authorising the proposed procedure or treatment or not authorising the proposed procedure or treatment............................................................................... [210]
(viii) The views (if any) expressed by the guardian(s) of the child or young person, a person who is entitled to the custody of the child or young person , a person who is responsible for the daily care and control of the child or young person, and the child or young person himself, to the proposed procedure or treatment and to any alternative procedure or treatment.
Section 68F(2) Factors........................................................... [214]
Birth Certificates – The Recorded Sex................................. [225]
Authorisation and Other Orders............................................ [242]
Introduction
I have before me an application concerning a 13 year old who I will refer to as “Alex” in this judgment in order to preserve anonymity. At the commencement of the proceedings, I made an order pursuant to s 97(2) of the Family Law Act 1975 (“the Act”) closing the proceedings from the public and prohibiting any identifying disclosure of Alex. It was…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Alex: Hormonal Treatment for Gender Identity Dysphoria and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] FamCA 297
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether it had the jurisdiction to authorise or consent to hormonal treatment for gender identity dysphoria for a minor. This involved considering the capacity of a minor to consent to such medical treatment and the role of the court in making decisions concerning the welfare of children, particularly in the context of complex and potentially irreversible medical interventions.
Nicholson CJ reasoned that the court possessed inherent jurisdiction to make orders for the welfare of children. His Honour considered the medical evidence presented, which indicated that hormonal treatment was a recognised and appropriate intervention for gender identity dysphoria. The court applied the principle that decisions regarding a child's welfare should be made in the child's best interests. After careful consideration of the evidence and the potential benefits and risks of the treatment, the Chief Justice concluded that it was in Alex's best interests to undergo hormonal treatment.
The court made orders authorising the commencement of hormonal treatment for Alex, subject to ongoing medical supervision and review.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi