[2016] QCA 185
COURT OF APPEAL
MORRISON JA
Appeal No 9125 of 2015
SC No 5173 of 2014
RCR O’DONNELL GRIFFIN PTY LTD Appellant
ACN 003 905 093
v
FORGE GROUP POWER PTY LTD
ACN 103 678 324
MARK FRANCIS XAVIER MENTHA
SCOTT DAVID HARRY LANGDON Respondents
BRISBANE
FRIDAY, 15 JULY 2016
JUDGMENT
MORRISON JA: The appeal in this case was on a number of separate questions ordered to be determined ahead of any trial. Those questions concerned the ability of the respondent, Forge, to call on two guarantees which had been given by RCR under a construction contract.
The issue arose because Forge, which had gone into liquidation, announced it intended to call on the guarantees and the appellant, RCR, denied it had any entitlement to do so. Specific issues were excluded from those questions. Among those were the proper assessment of RCR’s claim to extensions of time under the contract, the proper assessment of Forge’s entitlement to be paid liquidated damages and the proper assessment of RCRs claim lodged previously and deemed to be certified under the contract in the sum of about $4.2 million.
The appeal was heard on 10 May 2016. On 24 June 2016, the Court pronounced its orders ahead of giving reasons because the undertaking not to call the guarantees was due to expire on 10 July 2016. In summary, the orders allowed the appeal and declared that Forge was not entitled to call on the guarantees.
The guarantees are due to expire tomorrow, Saturday, 16 July 2016. Forge has now applied for two forms of relief. The first is a stay of this court’s orders until the later of 28 business days after delivery of the court’s reasons; secondly, the determination of an application for special leave in the High Court; or, if that leave is granted, the determination of the appeal to the High Court.
The second form of relief is for a mandatory injunction compelling RCR before the guarantees expire tomorrow to extend the guarantees until 24 June 2017. That date was selected, no doubt, to accommodate the prospect of special leave being granted and the time for an appeal to the High Court.
In support of the application for an injunction Forge proffers the usual undertaking as to damages from itself and from the individuals who are liquidators. Because of the urgency attaching to this application these reasons will be brief.
As to the stay, I can see no benefit to Forge to a grant of a stay as the guarantees will still expire tomorrow unless the injunction is granted. Mr Dunning QC, appearing for Forge, accepted as much.
In relation to the injunction, some little history is needed to assess this issue. RCR has agreed from time to time to extend the expiry dates of the guarantees. For its part, Forge has agreed not to call on the guarantees pending determination of the separate questions and this appeal. Those agreements are reflected in consent orders, including orders made on…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RCR O'Donnell Griffin Pty Ltd v Forge Group Power Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] QCA 185
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court considered the issues surrounding the grant of the relief and concluded that relief should be refused. Firstly, the jurisdiction to grant mandatory relief was not doubted, but special caution was needed once a party’s appeal had been determined by the Court. Exceptional circumstances must be demonstrated in order to obtain a stay. Secondly, the prospects of special leave being granted were not substantial, as the issues turned upon the construction of a particular private contract. Thirdly, it was not clear that Forge would suffer irreparable harm if relief was denied, as RCR was financially sound and could meet any eventual claim by Forge after the trial. Fourthly, the injunction sought would force an alteration in the contractual relations between the parties and between RCR and its bank. Lastly, it was difficult to see that Forge had any contractual or other right in aid of which an injunction might be obtained.
The Court refused the application for an injunction and for a stay, and ordered that Forge pay the respondent’s costs of this application, to be assessed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Court of Appeal as an appeal from a decision in the Supreme Court. The appeal was heard on 10 May 2016, and on 24 June 2016, the Court pronounced its orders ahead of giving reasons because the undertaking not to call the guarantees was due to expire on 10 July 2016. The orders allowed the appeal and declared that Forge was not entitled to call on the guarantees. Forge subsequently applied for a stay of the court's orders and a mandatory injunction to extend the guarantees until 24 June 2017. The application was heard on an urgent basis.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court of Appeal's orders should be stayed pending the delivery of the court's reasons, the determination of an application for special leave in the High Court, or the determination of the appeal to the High Court if special leave is granted.
2. Whether a mandatory injunction should be granted to compel RCR to extend the guarantees until 24 June 2017.
Held
1. The court refused to stay its orders pending the delivery of the court's reasons, the determination of an application for special leave in the High Court, or the determination of the appeal to the High Court if special leave is granted.
2. The court refused to grant a mandatory injunction to compel RCR to extend the guarantees until 24 June 2017.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appeal in this case was heard on 10 May 2016, and the Court pronounced its orders on 24 June 2016. The guarantees were set to expire on 16 July 2016. The Court of Appeal considered Forge's application for a stay of the Court's orders and a mandatory injunction to compel RCR to extend the guarantees until 24 June 2017. The Court held that there was no benefit in granting a stay as the guarantees would still expire unless the injunction was granted. The Court of Appeal was cautious in granting mandatory relief as the appeal had already been determined by the Court. The Court referred to Advance Building Systems Pty Ltd v Ramset Fasteners (Aust) Pty Ltd and Gerah Imports Pty Ltd v Duke Group Ltd (in liq) to emphasise the need for exceptional circumstances to obtain a stay when special leave had not yet been obtained. The Court also considered the prospects of special leave, which seemed to be not substantial, as the issues turned upon the construction of a private contract. Additionally, the Court did not consider that Forge would suffer irreparable harm if relief was denied, as RCR was financially sound and could meet any eventual claim by Forge. The Court also noted that the injunction sought would force an alteration in the contractual relations between the parties, and Forge had not demonstrated any contractual or other right in aid of which an injunction might be obtained. Therefore, the Court refused the application for an injunction and for a stay, and the applicant, Forge, was to pay the respondent's costs of this application, to be assessed.