Ray Maybury and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL              )

)         No: 2015/6299

General Division  )

Re: Ray Maybury
Applicant

And: Australian Postal Corporation
Respondent

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:              Dr L Bygrave, Member

DATE:   25 January 2017

PLACE:                    Sydney

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in this application such that the sentence “This aggravation culminated in Mr Maybury lodging a claim for ‘torn supraspinatus + long head biceps tendon’ on 8 May 2015.” is inserted at the end of paragraph 50.

................................[sgd]...................................

Dr L Bygrave, Member

Maybury and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2016] AATA 994 (6 December 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2015/6299

Re

Ray Maybury

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal

Dr L Bygrave, Member

Date 6 December 2016
Place Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable determination dated 18 August 2015 and, in substitution, decides that Ray Maybury is entitled to compensation under section 14 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 for his ‘torn supraspinatus + long head biceps tendon’ injury suffered on 8 May 2015.

..................................[sgd]......................................

Dr L Bygrave, Member

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – injury or disease – ailment or aggravation of ailment – contributed to by employment to a significant degree – decision set aside and a decision made in substitution

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Commonwealth Banking Corporation v Percival (1988) 20 FCR 176

Commonwealth v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369

Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626

Secondary Materials

Sher, Jerry S, John W Uribe, Alejandro Posada, Brian J Murphy and Michael B Zlatkin, ‘Abnormal findings on magnetic resonance images of asymptomatic shoulders’ (1995) 77 Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 10

Svendsen, Susanne Wulff, John Gelineck, Svend Erik Mathiassen, Jens Peter Bonde, Lars Henrik Frich, Kristian Stengaard-Pedersen and Niels Egund, ‘Work Above Shoulder Level and Degenerative Alterations of the Rotator Cuff Tendons: A Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study’ (2004) 50(10) Arthritis & Rheumatism 3314

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr L Bygrave, Member

6 December 2016

introduction

  1. The applicant, Mr Ray Maybury, was born in 1954. Mr Maybury commenced employment in 2005 at Australia Post as a part-time Postal Delivery Officer and Night Sorter.

  2. On 14 May 2015, Mr Maybury lodged a Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation for a ‘torn supraspinatus + long head biceps tendon’ injury, which he claimed he suffered on 8 May 2015 as a result of his employment at Australia Post.

  3. In a determination dated 18 August 2015, Australia Post affirmed a determination dated 27 May 2015 refusing Mr Maybury’s claim for compensation in respect of this injury.

  4. On 22 September 2015, Mr Maybury applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a review of this determination.

  5. The application was heard in Sydney on 3 and 4 November 2016. Mr Maybury attended the hearing in person and had legal representation.

    relevant legislation and issues

  6. Mr Maybury’s application relates to a claim for acceptance of liability to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ray Maybury and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 994
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ray Maybury against the Australian Postal Corporation. Mr Maybury sought compensation for a torn supraspinatus and long head biceps tendon in his right shoulder, which he alleged was contributed to by his employment as a Postal Delivery Officer and Night Sorter. The dispute centred on whether Mr Maybury's condition constituted an "injury" or "disease" as defined by the relevant legislation and whether his employment had contributed to it to a significant degree.

The Tribunal was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether Mr Maybury's condition qualified as an "injury" under section 5A or a "disease" under section 5B of the *Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (the Act). Secondly, if it did, whether Mr Maybury was entitled to compensation under section 14 of the Act for the condition.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal found that Mr Maybury's right shoulder condition was a degenerative ailment. It concluded that section 5B(1)(a) of the Act did not apply because the degenerative nature of the condition meant it was not contributed to to a significant degree by his employment. However, the Tribunal then considered section 5B(1)(b), which addresses the aggravation of an ailment. Applying principles from *Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch* and subsequent Full Federal Court decisions, the Tribunal determined that Mr Maybury had suffered an aggravation of his right shoulder condition. This aggravation was found to be contributed to to a significant degree by his employment, particularly due to the repetitive nature of his mail-sorting duties and the resistance caused by incorrectly positioned plastic strips on the sorting frames.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the previous reviewable determination and substituted a decision that Mr Maybury is entitled to compensation under section 14 of the Act for his injury.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The determinative issues before the Tribunal are whether:(a)Mr Maybury’s condition is an ‘injury’ as defined in s 5A of the Act and/or a ‘disease’ as defined in s 5B of the Act; and(b)Mr Maybury is entitled to compensation under s 14 of the Act for his ‘torn supraspinatus + long head biceps tendon’.evidenceEvidence of Mr Maybury Mr Maybury provided written statements dated 14 May 2015, 5 June 2015 and 24 June 2016, and gave oral evidence at the hearing. Mr Maybury described his usual duties as a Postal Delivery Officer and Night Sorter sorting mail into slots on shelves. On average, he slotted approximately 5,000 letters over a five hour shift and did an average of three additional hours of slotting and bagging mail daily. He told the Tribunal that placing mail into slots comprised about 90 percent of his time. This process involved holding mail in a c-cup grip in his left hand and placing individual letters into slots on shelves on V-sort frames with his right hand. Mr Maybury’s evidence is that he began experiencing pain in his right shoulder about mid-2014 and he attributed this to plastic strips being placed too high (that is, not level with the base of the shelf) on some shelves of the V-sort frames. In his statement on 14 May 2015, he stated:The plastic strips being in the wrong position resulted in extra resistance on almost every letter inserted. This is evidenced by the grooves worn in every single one that I have complained about.[1] [1] Exhibit T1 at T8. At the Tribunal hearing, Australia Post and Mr Maybury provided used and un-used examples of the plastic strips.[2] Mr Maybury said that he adjusted the five shelves on the V-sort frames to be between his waist and shoulder height (approximately one metre) to sort mail. He acknowledged the level of resistance from plastic strips placed too high on shelves varied depending on the height of the shelf; higher shelves caused greater resistance due to the upward movement and lower shelves created less resistance due to the downward movement when placing the mail on the shelves.[2] Exhibits A4, R2 and R3. During the Tribunal hearing, Mr Maybury observed that in the period from mid-2014 to May 2015 approximately 20 percent of shelves had plastic strips placed too high. He said that he reported his concerns regarding the height of the plastic strips on the shelves to his supervisor ‘many times’. He often moved the plastic strips himself but was told by his supervisor to stop moving the strips on 8 May 2015. He conceded that the reason Australia Post decided not to move the plastic strips on the shelves was because he was the only mail sorter who complained about the height of the plastic strips. On 8 May 2015, an Incident Form was completed by Mr Maybury’s supervisor, which reported that he ‘[f]elt pain in Rt shoulder while sequencing’.[3] [3] Exhibit T1 at T4. Mr Maybury also visited Dr Wee-Liat Tan, his General Practitioner for over 30 years, on 8 May 2015. Dr Tan’s medical notes recorded Mr Maybury having a ‘sore (R) shoulder + elbow due to repeated sorting of letters … worse recently’.[4] Mr Maybury confirmed at the Tribunal hearing that he had visited Dr Tan at least once a month in the period March 2014 to January 2015 and March to May 2015, and had told Dr Tan about pain in his right shoulder, although this was not recorded in Dr Tan’s medical notes.[4] Exhibit R7.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Based on the evidence before the Tribunal, I am satisfied that Mr Maybury suffered an aggravation of his right shoulder condition that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment at Australia Post.Decision The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable determination dated 18 August 2015 and, in substitution, decides that Mr Maybury is entitled to compensation under section 14 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 for his ‘torn supraspinatus + long head biceps tendon’ injury suffered on 8 May 2015.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Pillemer felt that limited weight should be placed on the relevance of these research studies to the condition of Mr Maybury’s right shoulder. He expressed his view that these studies neither addressed the effect of the degenerative condition in Mr Maybury’s right shoulder nor considered the nature of tasks undertaken by Mr Maybury at Australia Post.consideration The medical evidence that Mr Maybury has a moderate degenerative condition in his right shoulder is not contested. Based on the evidence before me, I am satisfied that Mr Maybury’s right shoulder condition is an ‘ailment’ within the meaning of s 4(1) of the Act. I am not satisfied that s 5B(1)(a) of the Act applies to Mr Maybury’s ailment because the medical evidence unanimously finds his right shoulder condition is degenerative. It is therefore not an ailment suffered by Mr Maybury that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment at Australia Post. Accordingly, the question for determination by the Tribunal is whether Mr Maybury’s right shoulder condition as at 8 May 2015 was an aggravation of an ailment that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment at Australia Post as set out in s 5B(1)(b) of the Act. In deciding that question, the matters set out in subsections 5B(2)(a)-(e) of the Act may be taken into account. I have also had regard to both parties’ submissions in relation to the interpretation of ‘aggravation’ and ‘significant degree’, particularly as set out in the High Court decision of Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch[16] (Semlitch), and the Full Federal Court decisions in Commonwealth v Beattie[17] (Beattie) and Commonwealth Banking Corporation v Percival[18] (Percival).[16] (1964) 110 CLR 626.[17] (1981) 35 ALR 369.[18] (1988) 20 FCR 176. In Semlitch, Windeyer J reasoned that in deciding whether there is an aggravation of the disease, the question is ‘whether the disease has been made worse in the sense of more grave, more grievous or more serious in its effects upon the patient’.[19] His Honour noted that ‘[t]he contributing factor [to the aggravation of the disease] must … be either some event or occurrence in the course of the employment or some characteristic of the work performed or the conditions in which it was performed’.[20] He further stated ‘[t]he question whether there has been an aggravation … is, I think, essentially one of fact’.[21][19] (1964) 110 CLR 626, 639.[20] (1964) 110 CLR 626, 641.[21] (1964) 110 CLR 626, 637. Evatt and Sheppard JJ in Beattie affirmed that Semlitch is ‘an authority which establishes that there may be an exacerbation or an aggravation notwithstanding that there is no change in the underlying pathology’.[22] Their Honours also said that ‘pain brought on by work activity may constitute an aggravation of a pre-existing injury, even though no pathological change takes place’.[23] Percival established that ‘[p]ain is probably the most common symptom of injury or disease’.[24][22] (1981) 35 ALR 369, 377.[23] (1981) 35 ALR 369, 378.[24] (1988) 20 FCR 176, 180.