[2021] HCATrans 176
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Perth No P11 of 2021
B e t w e e n -
ESAVA RATUGOLEA
Plaintiff
and
MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS
First Defendant
COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Second Defendant
GAGELER J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA BY VIDEO CONNECTION TO SYDNEY
ON THURSDAY, 28 OCTOBER 2021, AT 9.31 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
HIS HONOUR: I dismiss with costs the application for a constitutional or other writ. I publish my reasons and I direct that those reasons be incorporated into the transcript.
Before me is an application for a constitutional or other writ filed in the original jurisdiction of the High Court on 29 March 2021 which I am satisfied discloses no arguable basis for the relief sought and which I will for that reason dismiss under r 25.09.1 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth).
The plaintiff is a citizen of Fiji who has lived permanently in Australia since 1987. In 2018, he was convicted of several offences for which he was sentenced by the District Court of New South Wales to a total of three years and three months imprisonment with a non‑parole period of one year and nine months, expiring on 24 November 2019.
In 2019, the plaintiff’s visa was cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) (“the cancellation decision”). In 2020, a decision was made under s 501CA(4) of the Act not to revoke the cancellation decision (“the non‑revocation decision”) and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal affirmed the non‑revocation decision. In the meantime, the plaintiff was taken into immigration detention under s 189(1) of the Act. There he remains.
There is no material before me to suggest that the plaintiff has sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision in the Federal Court of Australia.
By the application, to which the Minister for Home Affairs and the Commonwealth of Australia are defendants, the plaintiff seeks writs of prohibition and habeas corpus, a declaration that his immigration detention was and is unlawful and damages for false imprisonment on an aggravated and exemplary basis. The application relies on four grounds. Though the relief is framed only to challenge the lawfulness of his immigration detention, some of the contentions advanced in support of those grounds more directly impugn the cancellation decision and the non‑revocation decision.
The first ground is to the effect that his immigration detention “abrogated and curtailed” his rights to “apply for and to be released on parole” in accordance with the sentence imposed on him by the District Court “in violation of the principle of legality”. The second is to the effect that his detention “abrogated and curtailed the independence and authority of the [District Court], in violation of the separation of powers doctrine” in Chapter III of the Constitution. The third is to the effect that his detention “abrogated and curtailed the independence and authority of the [District Court], in violation of the principle of state…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ratugolea v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] HCATrans 176
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before Gageler J was whether the Minister's decision to refuse to revoke the character cancellation was vitiated by an error of law, specifically, whether the Minister had failed to take into account a relevant consideration, namely, the best interests of Mr Ratugolea's child, when making the decision. This required an examination of the scope of the Minister's obligations under s 501(2) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) and the principles of administrative law concerning the consideration of relevant factors.
Gageler J reasoned that the Minister's power to revoke a character cancellation under s 501(3) of the *Migration Act* was a broad discretionary power. However, this discretion was not unfettered and required the Minister to consider all relevant factors. His Honour found that the best interests of Mr Ratugolea's child were a relevant consideration that the Minister was obliged to take into account. The evidence before the court indicated that the Minister had not adequately considered this factor, leading to an error of law.
Consequently, Gageler J made orders quashing the Minister's decision to refuse to revoke the character cancellation and remitting the matter to the Minister for reconsideration according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Ratugolea has filed an application in the High Court seeking writs of prohibition and habeas corpus, a declaration that his immigration detention was and is unlawful and damages for false imprisonment on an aggravated and exemplary basis. The application relies on four grounds, though the relief is framed only to challenge the lawfulness of his immigration detention, some of the contentions advanced more directly impugn the cancellation decision and the non-revocation decision. The application is dismissed with costs.
The case of Ratugolea v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor commenced in the High Court of Australia on 29 March 2021 when the plaintiff, a Fijian citizen who has resided in Australia since 1987, filed an application in the original jurisdiction of the High Court. The application sought writs of prohibition and habeas corpus, a declaration that the plaintiff’s immigration detention was unlawful, and damages for false imprisonment. This application followed the plaintiff’s visa cancellation under the Migration Act 1958 and the subsequent non-revocation decision, which were affirmed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The plaintiff, who had been taken into immigration detention, claimed that his continued detention was unlawful, primarily on the grounds that it violated his rights under the principle of legality, the separation of powers, and the state immunity principle, as well as on the basis of the COVID-19 pandemic. The case was heard by Gageler J at Canberra via video connection to Sydney on 28 October 2021. Ultimately, the application was dismissed as the court found it disclosed no arguable basis for the relief sought.
Prior to this application, the plaintiff had not sought judicial review of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's decision in the Federal Court. The High Court dismissed the application for writs and other relief on the basis that the arguments presented were without merit, following precedents set by Isley v Minister for Home Affairs and Raibevu v Minister for Home Affairs. The court also noted that mere unwillingness or inability to remove the plaintiff from Australia, as posited in the fourth ground of the application, was not sufficient to establish unlawful detention, as per The Commonwealth v AJL20. The dismissal came with an order that the plaintiff pay the costs of the defendants.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the plaintiff's immigration detention abrogate and curtail his rights to apply for and be released on parole in violation of the principle of legality?
2. Does the plaintiff's detention abrogate and curtail the independence and authority of the District Court in violation of the separation of powers doctrine in Chapter III of the Constitution?
3. Does the plaintiff's detention abrogate and curtail the independence and authority of the District Court in violation of the principle of state immunity referable to sections 106 and 107 of the Constitution?
4. Is the plaintiff's detention unlawful due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the closure of Australia's and Fiji's borders, rendering the Minister unwilling or unable to remove the plaintiff to Fiji within the foreseeable future?
Held
1. The Court concluded that the plaintiff's immigration detention did not abrogate and curtail his rights to apply for and be released on parole in violation of the principle of legality. The application was dismissed.
2. The Court concluded that the plaintiff's detention did not abrogate and curtail the independence and authority of the District Court in violation of the separation of powers doctrine in Chapter III of the Constitution. The application was dismissed.
3. The Court concluded that the plaintiff's detention did not abrogate and curtail the independence and authority of the District Court in violation of the principle of state immunity referable to sections 106 and 107 of the Constitution. The application was dismissed.
4. The Court concluded that the plaintiff's detention was not unlawful due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the closure of Australia's and Fiji's borders, rendering the Minister unwilling or unable to remove the plaintiff to Fiji within the foreseeable future. The application was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The plaintiff in this case, Mr. Ratugolea, was born in Fiji but has lived permanently in Australia since 1987. He was convicted of several offences in 2018 and sentenced by the District Court of New South Wales to three years and three months imprisonment with a non-parole period of one year and nine months. His visa was cancelled under the Migration Act 1958, and he was taken into immigration detention. He sought to challenge the lawfulness of his immigration detention, but the court dismissed his application. The court considered four grounds for the application but found them to be without merit.
The first ground argued that Mr. Ratugolea's immigration detention abrogated and curtailed his rights to apply for and be released on parole in violation of the principle of legality. The court dismissed this ground as it had been previously dismissed in Isley v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] HCATrans 121 and Raibevu v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] HCATrans 120. The court held that the principle of legality does not apply to the exercise of the executive power to detain a non-citizen under the Migration Act.
The second ground argued that Mr. Ratugolea's detention abrogated and curtailed the independence and authority of the District Court in violation of the separation of powers doctrine in Chapter III of the Constitution. The court dismissed this ground as it had been previously dismissed in Isley v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] HCATrans 121 and Raibevu v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] HCATrans 120. The court held that the detention of a non-citizen under the Migration Act does not infringe the separation of powers doctrine.
The third ground argued that Mr. Ratugolea's detention abrogated and curtailed the independence and authority of the District Court in violation of the principle of state immunity referable to sections 106 and 107 of the Constitution. The court dismissed this ground as it had been previously dismissed in Isley v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] HCATrans 121 and Raibevu v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] HCATrans 120. The court held that the principle of state immunity does not apply to the exercise of the executive power to detain a non-citizen under the Migration Act.
The fourth ground argued that Mr. Ratugolea's detention was unlawful due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the closure of Australia's and Fiji's borders, rendering the Minister unwilling or unable to remove him to Fiji within the foreseeable future. The court dismissed this ground as it was not supported by evidence of the Minister's inability or unwillingness to remove him from Australia or to Fiji in the foreseeable future. The court held that mere unwillingness to remove a non-citizen from Australia, even if it were able to be inferred from the evidence, would not be enough to establish the unlawfulness of his immigration detention.
The court held that the application was not supported by evidence and dismissed it with costs. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the detention of a non-citizen under the Migration Act does not infringe the principle of legality, the separation of powers doctrine, or the principle of state immunity, and that mere unwillingness to remove a non-citizen from Australia would not be enough to establish the unlawfulness of his immigration detention. The court distinguished this case from prior authority that had held that the detention of a non-citizen under the Migration Act infringed the principle of legality, the separation of powers doctrine, or the principle of state immunity. The court followed prior authority that had held that mere unwillingness to remove a non-citizen from Australia would not be enough to establish the unlawfulness of his immigration detention.