Raphael & Ors & Act Planning & Land Authority (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

RAPHAEL AND ORS & ACT PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY (Administrative Review) [2010] ACAT 89

AT 75, 76, 77, 78, 79 & 80 of 2010

Catchwords:             Land and Planning- multi unit development in RZ2 zone- reconsideration decision- amendments to plans- density- form, scale and site development- loss of views - traffic

Legislation:               Planning and Development Act 2007

Subordinate
Legislation:               The Territory Plan 2008

Case Law:Downer Community Association and ACT Planning and Land Authority & Anor [2007] ACTAAT 20

Walkington & Ors and ACT Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Review) [2010] ACAT 81

BDH Projects v ACT Planning and Land Authority & Ors (Administrative Review)[2010] ACAT 37

Hutchens and Anor v City of Holdfast Bay (2007) SASC 238

Edgar& Department of Environment, Land and Planning [1993] ACTAAT 59

Tribunal:                  Dr Don McMichael     Presiding Member

Mr Rod Nichols          Senior Member

Date of Orders:  21 December 2010
Date of Reasons for Decision:         21 December 2010

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL      )

AT 75, 76, 77, 78, 79 & 80 of 2010

RE:BONIFACE & FELICITAS RAPHAEL

Applicants AT10/75

RE:AL & J MASTERS

Applicants AT10/76

RE:SANDRA & CORNELUS

DEVRIES

Applicants AT10/77

RE:MARK EDWARD TAYLOR

Applicant AT10/78

RE:OLGA SWEENEY

Applicant AT10/80

AND:ACT PLANNING AND LAND

AUTHORITY

Respondent

AND:HUGH GORDON ARCHITECT PTY LTD

Party Joined AT10/75, 76, 77, 78 & 80

TRIBUNAL:            Dr D. McMichael, Presiding Member
  Mr R. Nichols, Senior Member

DATE:  21 December 2010

ORDER

1.The decision under review  is varied by approving Development Application No 200916161 in accordance with the plans constituting exhibit 3 in ACAT proceedings AT10/75,76,77,78 and 80 and subject to the conditions in Attachment A of the decision being amended as follows:

(a)Conditions A1(a) and (b) are deleted.

(b)

New Conditions A1 (a) (i)-(iv) are added as follows:



(i)Revised site plan, landscape plan and architectural drawings based on the drawings constituting exhibit 3 in ACAT proceedings AT10/75,76,77,77 and 80, showing modifications to the development to-

·Remove the steps and construct a ramp on the continuous pathway between units 9 and 10; and

·Cause, by construction of retaining walls, the private open space for units 1 and 2 to be level ground.

(ii)

A revised exterior lighting plan showing requirements for compliance with the relevant Australian Standards.



(iii)

A pre and post adaptable dwellings plan showing requirements for compliance with the relevant Australian Standards.



(iv)A noise management plan approved by the Department of Territory and Municipal Services.

………………………………..
Dr D. McMichael

Presiding Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The applicants have sought review of a decision made pursuant to Section 193 of the Planning and Development Act 2007 (“the Act”) by the ACT Planning and Land Authority (“the respondent”) on 6 August 2010, in reconsideration of its decision on Development Application (“DA”)  No 200916161.  The applicants were all objectors to the proposal when it was advertised for public comment on 5 January 2010.  The DA was initially refused on 7 May 2010.  

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Raphael & Ors & Act Planning & Land Authority (Administrativ... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ACAT 89
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the tribunal involved a dispute between residents of McWhae Circuit and Sternberg Crescent and the Act Planning and Land Authority (ACTPLA) regarding a proposed development. The residents argued that the proposal did not meet the requirements of Criterion C94 in the Territory Plan, which relates to the residential amenity of dwellings. The residents claimed that the development, if approved, would negatively impact their neighbourhood, which was predominantly made up of single-story separate dwellings. ACTPLA argued that the proposal met the requirements of the Territory Plan and should be approved. The tribunal was tasked with deciding whether the proposal met the requirements of the Territory Plan and, if not, whether any changes could be made to ensure compliance.

The tribunal noted that the Executive Policy Committee of ACTPLA had approved the proposal, albeit with some reservations, and that the Committee's comments seemed to be about the development as a whole, rather than specifically related to Criterion C94. The tribunal concluded that the proposal, as modified by the party joined, met the requirements of either the Rules or the Criteria under the Code and that approval of the development, subject to certain conditions, would not be inconsistent with the Territory Plan. The tribunal was satisfied that the changes made to the proposal had significantly reduced the potential impact on the residents' amenity and that the proposal now met the requirements of the Territory Plan.

The tribunal approved the development, subject to certain conditions, including the removal of steps and the construction of a ramp on the continuous pathway between units 9 and 10, the levelling of the private open space for units 1 and 2 by the construction of retaining walls, the submission of a revised exterior lighting plan, a pre and post adaptable dwellings plan, and a noise management plan approved by the Department of Territory and Municipal Services. The tribunal's decision was that the development application should be approved, subject to the conditions outlined in the decision.

In summary, the tribunal found that the proposed development met the requirements of the Territory Plan and approved the development, subject to certain conditions. The tribunal acknowledged the concerns of the residents but concluded that the changes made to the proposal had significantly reduced the potential impact on their amenity and that the proposal now met the requirements of the Territory Plan. The tribunal's decision was that the development application should be approved, subject to the conditions outlined in the decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision under review is varied by approving Development Application No 200916161 in accordance with the plans constituting exhibit 3 in ACAT proceedings AT10/75,76,77,78 and 80 and subject to the conditions in Attachment A of the decision being amended as follows:

(a) Conditions A1(a) and (b) are deleted.

(b)

New Conditions A1 (a) (i)-(iv) are added as follows:

(i) Revised site plan, landscape plan and architectural drawings based on the drawings constituting exhibit 3 in ACAT proceedings AT10/75,76,77,77 and 80, showing modifications to the development to-

· Remove the steps and construct a ramp on the continuous pathway between units 9 and 10; and

· Cause, by construction of retaining walls, the private open space for units 1 and 2 to be level ground.

(ii)

A revised exterior lighting plan showing requirements for compliance with the relevant Australian Standards.

(iii)

A pre and post adaptable dwellings plan showing requirements for compliance with the relevant Australian Standards.

(iv) A noise management plan approved by the Department of Territory and Municipal Services.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a development proposal submitted by Mr Masters for a redevelopment in the RZ2 Zones, an area that has traditionally been home to single-story separate dwellings. The proposal was met with objections from residents of McWhae Circuit and Sternberg Crescent who were concerned about the potential impacts on their residential amenity. In response to these objections, several changes were made to the proposal. The Australian Capital Territory Planning and Land Authority (ACTPLA) initially did not approve the proposal, describing it as a "poor case in design," but later agreed that it met the requirements of the Territory Plan. The Tribunal was tasked with reviewing this decision and determining whether the development met the necessary criteria under the Code and if approval would be inconsistent with the Territory Plan.

The matter came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) as a result of an application for internal review by the party joined. This review was initiated after the initial decision by the ACTPLA to not approve the development proposal. The AAT examined the proposal, the objections from local residents, and the modifications made to the proposal in light of those objections. The Tribunal also considered the comments of the ACTPLA’s Executive Policy Committee regarding the proposal. Ultimately, the Tribunal was required to determine whether the proposal, as modified, met the relevant criteria and whether the approval of the development would be inconsistent with the Territory Plan.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Masters submitted the proposal did not meet the requirement of Criterion C94 because it had been described by ACTPLA’s Executive Policy Committee as a “poor case in design” and especially because it cannot and does not ensure high levels of residential amenity of all dwellings. Mr Walker noted that while the Committee’s approval might have been grudging it did in fact agree that it met the Territory Plan requirements. The Tribunal notes that the comment of the Committee seems to have been about the development in its totality. C94 is a specific criterion addressing the common areas within the site and there is no evidence that the Committee’s comments related to this criterion.Conclusion The Tribunal recognises that re-development in RZ2 Zones of what has till then been predominantly a single-story separate dwelling neighbourhood causes many residents concern about the potential impacts on their amenity. In this case, the residents of McWhae Circuit and Sternberg Crescent who made representations about the original proposal were justified in doing so. As a consequence of their objections, numerous changes to the proposal have been made by the party joined that have significantly improved it and will reduce the impact that it otherwise might have had. The Tribunal concludes that as a result of these changes, either the Rules or the Criteria are met for all matters under the Code and consequently approval of the development, subject to some conditions, will not be inconsistent with the Territory Plan. The Tribunal therefore will make the following Order:The decision under review is varied by approving Development Application No 200916161 in accordance with the plans constituting exhibit 3 in ACAT proceedings AT10/75,76,77,78 and 80 and subject to the conditions in Attachment A of the decision being amended as follows:(a)Conditions A1(a) and (b) are deleted.(b)New Conditions A1 (a) (i)-(iv) are added as follows:(i)Revised site plan, landscape plan and architectural drawings based on the drawings constituting exhibit 3 in ACAT proceedings AT10/75,76,77,77 and 80, showing modifications to the development to-·Remove the steps and construct a ramp on the continuous pathway between units 9 and 10; and ·Cause, by construction of retaining walls, the private open space for units 1 and 2 to be level ground.(ii)A revised exterior lighting plan showing requirements for compliance with the relevant Australian Standards. (iii)A pre and post adaptable dwellings plan showing requirements for compliance with the relevant Australian Standards.(iv)A noise management plan approved by the Department of Territory and Municipal Services.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal began by addressing the argument that the proposal did not meet the requirement of Criterion C94 and the Territory Plan requirements. The Tribunal acknowledged that the Executive Policy Committee had described the proposal as a "poor case in design" but noted that the Committee had agreed that it met the Territory Plan requirements. The Tribunal reasoned that the Committee's comments seemed to be about the development in its totality and did not relate to Criterion C94 specifically addressing the common areas within the site. Therefore, the Tribunal concluded that the proposal met the requirement of Criterion C94 and the Territory Plan requirements.

Next, the Tribunal considered whether the changes made to the proposal sufficiently addressed the concerns of the local residents and met the relevant criteria under the Code. The Tribunal recognised that re-development in RZ2 Zones of what had been predominantly a single-story separate dwelling neighbourhood caused many residents concern about the potential impacts on their amenity. The Tribunal noted that the residents of McWhae Circuit and Sternberg Crescent who made representations about the original proposal were justified in doing so. The Tribunal concluded that the changes made to the proposal had significantly improved it and would reduce the impact that it otherwise might have had. Therefore, the Tribunal found that the changes made to the proposal sufficiently addressed the concerns of the local residents and met the relevant criteria under the Code.

Finally, the Tribunal considered whether the approval of the development, subject to certain conditions, would be inconsistent with the Territory Plan. The Tribunal concluded that the approval of the development, subject to some conditions, would not be inconsistent with the Territory Plan. The Tribunal noted that the changes made to the proposal had significantly improved it and would reduce the impact that it otherwise might have had. Therefore, the Tribunal held that the approval of the development, subject to certain conditions, would not be inconsistent with the Territory Plan.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that changes made to a proposal in response to concerns raised by local residents can sufficiently address those concerns and meet the relevant criteria under the Code, even if the original proposal did not meet those criteria. The Tribunal also held that the approval of a development, subject to certain conditions, may not be inconsistent with the Territory Plan if the changes made to the proposal have significantly improved it and will reduce the impact that it otherwise might have had.