BDH Projects and Ors & Act Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

BDH PROJECTS and ORS & ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY (Administrative Review) [2011] ACAT 79

AT 8 of 2011

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW- multi unit housing development in RZ2- zone objectives- scale form and site development - suitability of the land; s.120(b), Planning and Development
Act 2007
- private open space- clothes drying- basement carpark access for vehicles and disabled- density- dwellings per hectare

List of legislation:     Planning and Development Act 2007, s. 120

List of Regulations:  The Territory Plan, Multi Unit Housing Development Code

List of cases:        Edquist & Price v ACT Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Review) [2011] ACAT 64

Lourandos and Yiannokopoulos & ACT Planning and Land Authority and ORS (Administrative Review) [2011] ACAT 25

Raphael and ORS & ACT Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Review) [2010] ACAT 89

BDH Projects v ACT Planning and Land Authority


(Administrative Review)

[2010] ACAT 37

Tribunal:                   Mr Brian Hatch. Senior Member

Date of Orders:  25 November 2011
Date of Reasons for Decision:         25 November 2011

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL& ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL        )          AT 8 of 2011

RE:BDH PROJECTS

Applicant

AND:ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY

Respondent

AND:  ALLAN & MARION
           BURNS

  Party Joined (1)

AND:  IAN & JADE BARGES
  Party Joined (2)

AND:  RITA & ROD COLES
  Party Joined (3)

AND:  MAUREEN SHOLLY
  Party Joined (4)

AND:  KERRIE BYRNE
  Party Joined (5)

AND:  MATTHEW &
            MELISSA GEYSEN

  Party Joined (6)

AND:  STEVE MOUTAFIS
  Party Joined (7)

TRIBUNAL:            Mr B. Hatch, Senior Member

DATE:  25 November 2011

ORDER

1.The decision under review is confirmed.

………………………………..
Mr B. Hatch

Senior Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This is a review of a decision of the Respondent to disallow, subject to conditions,
    a proposal for:

    ·the consolidation of Blocks 15 and 16 Section 50 Division of Duffy;

    ·the variation of the lease to permit 14 residential units;

    ·the demolition of the 3 existing dwellings and outbuildings on Blocks 15 and 16 of Section 50 in the Division of Duffy;

    ·the construction of 1 and 2 storey buildings comprising 14 residential units;

    ·the construction of a basement car parks; and

    ·associated landscaping, paving and other site works.

  1. The proposed development is at 8 and 10 Mokoan Place in Duffy. It is at the end of Mokoan Place, which is a cul-de-sac. The end of Mokoan Place widens into a turning circle for vehicles and the proposed development is on this turning circle.

  1. The 2 blocks were first developed in the early 1970s. The remainder of Mokoan Place is single dwellings of a similar age and type.

THE ISSUES

  1. The proposed development is in the RZ2 Suburban Core Zone.

  1. The original decision by the Respondent noted problems with the building envelope and setbacks. Those issues had been resolved to the satisfaction of the Respondent in the reconsideration phase. The parties barely touched on these issues during the hearing over 4 days. I find that setbacks and building envelope are consistent with the Territory Plan (the TP).

  1. The first issue…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BDH Projects and Ors & Act Planning and Land Authority (Admi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] ACAT 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case BDH Projects and Ors & Act Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Review) involved a dispute over a development application for Mokoan Place in Melbourne. The applicants, BDH Projects and others, sought to develop the property under the Planning and Development Act 2007. The respondents, the Act Planning and Land Authority, reviewed and subsequently refused the application. The applicants appealed this decision, prompting the need for administrative review. The court was required to determine whether the respondents' decision to refuse the development application was lawful and whether all relevant considerations under section 120 of the Planning and Development Act were properly applied.

The court's analysis focused on whether the respondents adequately considered the objectives of the zone, the suitability of the land for the proposed development, and all relevant representations. The court also examined if the respondents appropriately considered the probable impact of the proposed development, including environmental impacts, and other pertinent factors such as traffic, vehicle access, private open space, and site facilities. The court found that the respondents' decision-making process was comprehensive and adhered to the statutory requirements. The court concluded that the respondents appropriately considered all relevant factors and the decision to refuse the application was lawful.

Given the court's findings, the decision under review was confirmed. The applicants' appeal was dismissed, and the original decision by the Act Planning and Land Authority to refuse the development application was upheld. This outcome underscores the importance of ensuring that all statutory considerations are meticulously evaluated in development applications, particularly in urban settings where multiple factors can influence the outcome.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision under review is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first issue is in relation to section 120 of the Planning and Development Act 2007 (the Land Act) which states:120 Merit track—considerations when deciding developmentapprovalIn deciding a development application for a development proposalin the merit track, the decision-maker must consider the following:(a)the objectives for the zone in which the development isproposed to take place;(b)the suitability of the land where the development is proposed totake place for a development of the kind proposed;(c)each representation received by the authority in relation to theapplication that has not been withdrawn;(d)if an entity gave advice on the application in accordance withsection 149 (Requirement to give advice in relation todevelopment applications)—the entity’s advice;Note Advice on an application is given in accordance with section 149if the advice is given by an entity not later than 15 working days(or shorter prescribed period) after the day the application isgiven to the entity. If the entity gives no response, the entity istaken to have given advice that supported the application (sees 150).(e)if the proposed development relates to land that is publicland—the plan of management for the land;(f)the probable impact of the proposed development, includingthe nature, extent and significance of probable environmentalimpacts. Paragraphs (e) and (f) are not relevant to this proposal, but the remainder of section 120 is, to varying degrees. Paragraphs (c) and (d) are also relevant but not in contention in so far as each representation was taken into consideration. Traffic and vehicle access was also an issue. In many similar cases this issue is raised, but rarely has any impact on the final decision. This matter is different to many such other matters due to the nature of Mokoan Place. Private Open Space (POS) was also raised as an issue together with site facilities. See Rules 89, 90 and 97 of the Multi Unit Housing Development Code in the TP.