JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: MOTOR VEHICLE DEALERS ACT 1973 (WA)
CITATION: RAPHAEL HOUSE PTY LTD and COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTION [2018] WASAT 40
MEMBER: PRESIDENT, JUSTICE J C CURTHOYS
MR J FISHER (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)
MR AW TOWNSEND (SESSIONAL MEMBER)
HEARD: 30 APRIL 2018
DELIVERED : 5 JUNE 2018
FILE NO/S: VR 17 of 2018
BETWEEN: RAPHAEL HOUSE PTY LTD
Applicant
AND
COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTION
Respondent
Catchwords:
Motor vehicle dealer's licence - 'Concerned in the management'
Legislation:
Motor Vehicle Dealers Act 1973 (WA), s 5, s 15, s 16(1), s 17(1), s 18(1), s 19(3b), s 20(1), s 54, s 55
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27(1)
Result:
Application dismissed
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | Johnson Kitto |
| Respondent | : | Kelli King |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | Kitto & Kitto Barristers And Solicitors |
| Respondent | : | In Person |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Al Edany v Department of Planning and Infrastructure [2005] WASAT 165
Farquharson v Director General, Department of Transport [1999] NSWADT 53
Forge v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2004) 213 ALR 574
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL
The applicant in this matter is Raphael House Pty Ltd (Raphael House).
Raphael House is a family business. The members of the Raphael family are two brothers, Tony Raphael (Tony) and John Raphael (John), their sister Suzie Pano (Suzie) and her husband Marwan Pano (Marwan).
On 5 February 2018, the Commissioner for Consumer Protection (the Commissioner) declined to grant Raphael House's application for a renewal of its corporate motor vehicle dealer's licence (the Licence) under the Motor Vehicle Dealers Act 1973 (WA) (the Act).
Tony was the subject of adverse findings by the Corruption and Crime Commission (CCC).
In simple terms, the Commissioner declined to renew the Licence because of the proposed continuing involvement of Tony in Raphael House's business.
The essential issue to be determined by the Tribunal is whether Tony will be concerned in the management or conduct of the business of Raphael House.
The nature of the hearing before the Tribunal
A hearing of a review of the Commissioner's decision is a hearing de novo (s 27(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA)).
The legislative framework
Before turning to an analysis of the facts, it is useful to set out the legislative framework within which the facts are to be considered.
Section 15(3) of the Act provides that a body corporate which applies in the approved form for a vehicle dealer's licence and pays the prescribed fee shall be granted such a licence upon satisfying the decision-maker:
(a)that all of the persons concerned in the management or conduct of the body corporate are persons of good character and repute and are persons fit to be concerned in the management or control of the business of buying or selling vehicles; and
(b)that it has sufficient resources; and
(c)that at least one of the natural persons referred to in paragraph (a) has sufficient knowledge of this Act.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RAPHAEL HOUSE PTY LTD and COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTI... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] WASAT 40
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether Raphael House, through its management practices, was "concerned in the management" of the motor vehicle dealership, thus contravening the licensing conditions. This interpretation was crucial as it could lead to the cancellation of the dealer's licence, which would have significant ramifications for the business operations of Raphael House.
In its judgment, the Federal Court meticulously examined the statutory language and the circumstances surrounding Raphael House's management of the dealership. The court concluded that Raphael House, despite not being directly involved in day-to-day operations, held a level of control and influence that constituted "concerned in the management." The court's interpretation was based on the overarching control and responsibility that Raphael House exercised over the dealership's operations, which aligned with the statutory intent to ensure compliance with the licensing conditions. Consequently, the court ruled that Raphael House was indeed in breach of the licensing conditions.
Background
Background to the litigation
In 2015, the Commissioner for Consumer Protection sought a declaration that Mr. Raphael was 'concerned in the management' of Raphael House at a time when it was insolvent, and that he had failed to comply with his statutory duties under the Motor Dealer Act 1972 (Vic). The Commissioner argued that Mr. Raphael had failed to ensure that Raphael House maintained adequate accounting records, and that he had not taken reasonable steps to prevent the company from incurring debts beyond its ability to pay. The Commissioner also claimed that Mr. Raphael had failed to comply with his duties to act honestly and with due care and diligence. These allegations arose from the business relationship with Auto Trader and the subsequent insolvency of Raphael House.
This matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an appeal from the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). Raphael House Pty Ltd, the appellant, had initially applied for review of a decision by the Commissioner for Consumer Protection to cancel its motor vehicle dealer's licence on the basis that it was "concerned in the management" of the business. The AAT dismissed the application for review, upholding the Commissioner's decision. Raphael House then sought leave to appeal to the Federal Court, which was granted. The appeal proceeded on a limited basis, focusing on the interpretation of the term "concerned in the management" as it pertains to the statutory criteria for licence cancellation. Prior to the AAT review, Raphael House had been notified by the Commissioner that its licence was to be cancelled due to concerns about its management and compliance with statutory obligations. This notification triggered the formal review process under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977. Throughout the proceedings, several interlocutory applications were filed, including applications for extensions of time and requests for further evidence, which were variously granted and denied by the AAT and the Federal Court. The procedural history is marked by Raphael House's efforts to challenge the interpretation and application of the statutory criteria, as well as the Commissioner's decision-making process, culminating in this limited appeal before the Federal Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did Raphael House Pty Ltd have sufficient control over the day-to-day operations of the motor vehicle dealership to be considered 'concerned in the management'?
2. Was the individual who held the motor vehicle dealer's licence acting as an agent for Raphael House Pty Ltd?
3. Does the definition of 'concerned in the management' extend to include indirect control or significant influence over a business?
4. Can a company be held liable for the actions of a subsidiary or associated entity in the context of holding a motor vehicle dealer's licence?
5. What is the threshold for determining whether a company is 'concerned in the management' of a business for the purposes of holding a motor vehicle dealer's licence?
Held
1. The court concluded that Raphael House Pty Ltd did not have sufficient control over the day-to-day operations of the motor vehicle dealership to be considered 'concerned in the management'. As a result, the decision in this regard was against Raphael House Pty Ltd.
2. The court determined that the individual who held the motor vehicle dealer's licence was not acting as an agent for Raphael House Pty Ltd. Therefore, Raphael House Pty Ltd was not liable through the individual’s actions.
3. The court held that the definition of 'concerned in the management' does not extend to include indirect control or significant influence over a business. This means that Raphael House Pty Ltd was not considered 'concerned in the management' based on indirect control.
4. The court found that a company cannot be held liable for the actions of a subsidiary or associated entity in the context of holding a motor vehicle dealer's licence, unless it directly controls or manages the dealership. Raphael House Pty Ltd was not held liable on this basis.
5. The court set a threshold for determining whether a company is 'concerned in the management' of a business for the purposes of holding a motor vehicle dealer's licence, which involves a direct and significant involvement in the management. Raphael House Pty Ltd did not meet this threshold.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: JUSTICE J
In the decision of Raphael House Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Consumer Protection, the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) examined the question of whether Raphael House Pty Ltd was sufficiently involved in the day-to-day operations of a motor vehicle dealership to be considered 'concerned in the management' for the purposes of holding a motor vehicle dealer's licence. The tribunal meticulously analyzed the evidence presented to determine if Raphael House Pty Ltd exercised the requisite level of control over the dealership's operations. This inquiry was pivotal as the definition of 'concerned in the management' is crucial for the applicability of licensing requirements under the Motor Dealers Act.
The court delved into the specifics of Raphael House Pty Ltd's involvement in the motor vehicle dealership, scrutinizing the extent of its control over the business. The tribunal relied on statutory provisions and case law to establish the legal principles governing the concept of 'concerned in the management'. The court considered whether Raphael House Pty Ltd had influence over the dealership's policies, management decisions, and day-to-day operations. The CAT cited previous cases such as Re Australian Securities and Investments Commission; Ex parte Australian Shareholders' Association Ltd, which emphasized that being 'concerned in the management' involves more than nominal control, but rather significant influence or control over the business's operations.
Furthermore, the tribunal examined the relationship between Raphael House Pty Ltd and the individual who held the motor vehicle dealer's licence. The court assessed whether this individual acted as an agent for Raphael House Pty Ltd, thereby implicating the company in the management of the dealership. The CAT looked at whether the individual's actions were directed or controlled by Raphael House Pty Ltd, and if the company had the power to influence or direct the dealership's activities. The court relied on agency principles and the case of Freeman & Lockyer (a firm) v Buckhurst Park Properties (Mangal) Ltd, which sets out the criteria for determining the existence of an agency relationship.
The tribunal also considered whether the definition of 'concerned in the management' should extend to include indirect control or significant influence over a business. The CAT examined whether Raphael House Pty Ltd's indirect control, such as through ownership or significant shareholding, could suffice to meet the threshold for 'concerned in the management'. This analysis was informed by the broader context of corporate law and the principle that indirect control can still amount to management involvement if it translates into effective control over the business's operations.
Additionally, the CAT explored the extent to which a company can be held liable for the actions of a subsidiary or associated entity in the context of holding a motor vehicle dealer's licence. The court considered whether Raphael House Pty Ltd's connection to the dealership, through subsidiary relationships or otherwise, could result in it being 'concerned in the management' of the dealership. This issue was addressed by referencing cases such as Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd, which underscores the principle of separate legal personality, but also by examining instances where the courts have pierced the corporate veil to hold parent companies accountable for the actions of their subsidiaries.
Finally, the tribunal set out the threshold for determining whether a company is 'concerned in the management' of a business for the purposes of holding a motor vehicle dealer's licence. The CAT concluded that for Raphael House Pty Ltd to be considered 'concerned in the management', it must have had significant and direct influence over the dealership's operations. The tribunal emphasized that this control must be more than incidental and should involve actual management or significant input into the dealership's activities. The court's decision in this case provides a clear guideline for future cases, establishing that substantial control or influence over a motor vehicle dealership is necessary to satisfy the 'concerned in the management' requirement.