R v The Age Company Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

[2000] TASSC 62

CITATION:              R v The Age Company Ltd & Ors [2000] TASSC 62

PARTIES:  R
  v
  THE AGE COMPANY LTD
  HARRIS, Steven
  GAWENDA, Michael

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

JURISDICTION:  ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S:  M297/1999
DELIVERED ON:  9 June 2000
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATES:  24 February, 2 March 2000
JUDGMENT OF:  Evans J

CATCHWORDS:

Procedure - Contempt, attachment and sequestration - Power of court to punish for contempt - Supreme Court - Generally - Newspaper article identifying victim of sexual assaults - Contravention of the Evidence Act 1910 (Tas), s103AB

Evidence Act 1910, (Tas) s103AB.

Criminal Code 1924, (Tas) s127.

Director of Public Prosecutions v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1987) 8 NSWLR 732, followed.

Aust Dig Procedure [701].

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Applicant:  T J Ellis
             Respondent:  T G Bugg
Solicitors:
             Applicant:  Director of Public Prosecutions
             Respondent:  Dobson Mitchell & Allport

Judgment Number:  [2000] TASSC 62
Number of Paragraphs:  20

Serial No 62/2000
File No M297/1999

THE QUEEN v THE AGE COMPANY LTD
and STEVEN HARRIS and MICHAEL GAWENDA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  EVANS J

9 June 2000

  1. The Crown applies for orders that Steven Harris and Michael Gawenda, the editor-in-chief and the editor of The Age newspaper respectively, be committed for contempt of court and that The Age Company Ltd, the publisher of the newspaper, be fined for contempt of court.  The particulars provided in support of the application are:

"1On Saturday the 14th day of August 1999 following the conviction in the Supreme Court of Tasmania of Steven Grant Randell of charges inter alia of indecently assaulting (a named complainant whom I shall refer to as 'Z') contrary to section 127 of the Criminal Code they did publish or cause to be published in The Age newspaper distributed and sold in Tasmania the following material:-

On page 1 a photograph of Z and an accompanying report identifying Z as one of International cricket identity Steve Randell's nine victims.

2The above matter contravened Section 103AB(1)(a)(i) and (b) of the Evidence Act 1910 and pursuant to Section 103AB(4) constituted a contempt of the Supreme Court of Tasmania."

  1. The Evidence Act 1910 ("the Act"), s103AB, relevantly provides:

    "(1)     A person shall not, in relation to any proceedings in any court in respect of any offence, publish or cause to be published in any newspaper, …-

    (a)the name, address, or any other reference or allusion likely to lead to the identification of -

    (i)any person in respect of whom a crime is alleged to have been committed under section 127 … of the Criminal Code; or

    …

    (b)any picture purporting to be a picture of any such person -

    …

    (4)       A person who publishes or causes to be published anything in contravention of this section commits a contempt of court and is liable to punishment for that contempt as if it had been committed in the face of the court against which the contempt is committed and on similar proceedings as in that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v The Age Company Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] TASSC 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v The Age Company Ltd [2000] TASSC 62 involved a legal dispute between the Crown and The Age Company Ltd, the publisher of The Age newspaper, along with its editor-in-chief, Steven Harris, and editor, Michael Gawenda. The Crown sought orders for Harris and Gawenda to be committed for contempt of court and for The Age Company Ltd to be fined for contempt of court, due to the publication of an article and photograph identifying a victim of sexual assault in contravention of the Evidence Act 1910 (Tas), s103AB. The legal issues before the court included whether the publication of the article and photograph breached the provisions of the Act and, if so, what appropriate penalties should be imposed.

The court found that the publication of the article and photograph identifying the victim of sexual assault did indeed breach the Act, s103AB(1)(a) and (b). The respondents' counsel acknowledged the breach of the Act, and it was not disputed that The Age Company Ltd published the contemptuous material and that Harris and Gawenda caused the material to be published. Gawenda's decision to proceed with the publication was driven primarily by the potential for increased reader interest if the victim was identified and the publication was accompanied by her photograph. The court found that Gawenda's decision to publish the material was knowing and deliberate, and as such, he was liable to punishment for his contempt.

In determining the appropriate penalties, the court considered the need to deter the respondents and others from engaging in similar conduct in the future. The court imposed a fine of $20,000 on both Gawenda and The Age Company Ltd, while no penalty was imposed on Harris as he was not involved in the offending publication. The court emphasised the importance of consistency in the approach of courts when punishing contempt, and sought to balance the need for deterrence with the unique circumstances of each case.

In conclusion, the court found that the publication of the article and photograph identifying the victim of sexual assault breached the provisions of the Evidence Act 1910 (Tas), s103AB, and imposed a fine of $20,000 on Michael Gawenda and The Age Company Ltd for their contempt of court. The editor-in-chief, Steven Harris, was not subject to any penalty as he was not involved in the offending publication. The court's decision sought to balance the need for deterrence with the unique circumstances of the case, while also considering the importance of consistency in the approach of courts when punishing contempt.

Background

Background to the litigation

In August 1999, Steven Grant Randell was convicted in the Supreme Court of Tasmania on 15 counts of indecent assault against nine girls, including one named Z, who was a student at a school where Randell was teaching. Randell, an international cricket umpire, was sentenced to four years' imprisonment. Following the sentencing, Z, who had previously not been identified in reports on Randell's prosecution, consented to being named and interviewed by journalists. The Age newspaper, published by The Age Company Ltd, subsequently published an article identifying Z as one of Randell's victims, accompanied by a photograph of her and her mother. This publication was in breach of the Evidence Act 1910, s103AB, which prohibits the identification of victims of certain sexual offences in relation to ongoing proceedings. The article and photograph were prepared and published despite legal advice that doing so would breach the Act.

The editor of The Age, Michael Gawenda, authorised the publication despite the legal advice, believing the risk to be minimal as Z had consented to the publicity. Gawenda did not consider the impact on other potential victims and proceeded with the publication and distribution of the newspaper in Tasmania, where such identification is prohibited. The Crown sought orders for Gawenda and the editor-in-chief, Steven Harris, to be committed for contempt and for The Age Company Ltd to be fined. The respondents acknowledged the breach of the Act but argued that Z's consent and the minimal impact on her justified the publication. The court considered the need for deterrence and consistency in punishing contempt, ultimately imposing a fine of $20,000 on Gawenda and The Age Company Ltd, while Harris, who was not involved in the decision to publish, was not penalised.

This case came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania as a result of an application by the Crown for orders of contempt against Steven Harris, Michael Gawenda, and The Age Company Ltd. The respondents were the editor-in-chief, the editor, and the publisher, respectively, of The Age newspaper. The application was made following the publication of an article that identified a victim of sexual assault, in contravention of the Evidence Act 1910 (Tas). The Crown sought orders committing Harris and Gawenda for contempt and fining The Age Company Ltd for contempt. The matter proceeded as a first-instance hearing on the merits of the Crown's application. Prior to the hearing, the respondents acknowledged that the publication of the article and photograph in question breached the Evidence Act 1910 (Tas) s103AB(1)(a) and (b). The court had to determine the appropriate penalties to be imposed in light of the contemptuous conduct. The procedural steps included the Crown filing particulars of the contempt and the respondents providing their admissions. The court considered relevant prior decisions and the need for consistency in punishing contempts. After the hearing, the court delivered its judgment imposing fines on Michael Gawenda and The Age Company Ltd to achieve the objectives of chastising the contemptuous conduct and deterring future breaches.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the publication of a victim's identity in a newspaper article, in contravention of s103AB of the Evidence Act 1910 (Tas), constitute contempt of court?
2. What is the appropriate penalty for the contempt committed by the editor and the publisher of the newspaper?
3. Can the editor-in-chief be held liable for the contempt if they were not involved in the decision to publish the material?
4. How should the court balance the need for deterrence with the potential harm caused to the victim by the publication?
5. To what extent does the victim's consent to being identified mitigate the contempt committed by the newspaper?
6. How does the seriousness of the contempt, judged by the culpability of the editor, affect the determination of the penalty?
7. What considerations should be taken into account to ensure consistency in the punishment of contempt in similar cases?

Held
1. The publication of a victim's identity in a newspaper article, in contravention of s103AB of the Evidence Act 1910 (Tas), constitutes contempt of court.
2. The appropriate penalty for the contempt committed by the editor and the publisher of the newspaper is a fine of $20,000 each.
3. The editor-in-chief cannot be held liable for the contempt as they were not involved in the decision to publish the material.
4. The court balances the need for deterrence with the potential harm caused to the victim by the publication by considering the objectives of chastising the editor and deterring future similar conduct.
5. The victim's consent to being identified does not mitigate the contempt committed by the newspaper as the law does not allow for such consent to be a defence.
6. The seriousness of the contempt, judged by the culpability of the editor, affects the determination of the penalty as it was a knowing breach of the law.
7. Considerations to ensure consistency in the punishment of contempt in similar cases include the need for a principled and even-handed approach, coherence, and an attempt to ensure consistency between the approach to like cases.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of Tasmania, in R v The Age Company Ltd, addressed the issue of whether the publication of a victim's identity in a newspaper article, in contravention of s103AB of the Evidence Act 1910 (Tas), constitutes contempt of court. The court held that the publication of the victim's identity, despite her consent, did constitute contempt of court. This determination was based on the legal principle that the Evidence Act 103AB aims to protect victims of sexual offences from the consequences of media publicity, regardless of their consent.

The court also considered the appropriate penalty for the contempt committed by the editor and the publisher of the newspaper. In determining the penalty, the court balanced the need for deterrence against the potential harm caused to the victim by the publication. The court found that the contempt was serious due to the editor's knowledge of the breach of the law and the need to deter future similar conduct. Therefore, the court imposed a fine of $20,000 on both the editor and the publisher.

Regarding the liability of the editor-in-chief, the court held that he could not be held liable for the contempt if he was not involved in the decision to publish the material. In this case, the editor-in-chief was not involved in and had no knowledge of the offending publication prior to its distribution. Consequently, no penalty was imposed on the editor-in-chief.

The court also considered the extent to which the victim's consent to being identified mitigates the contempt committed by the newspaper. The court held that the consent of the victim did not mitigate the contempt, as the Evidence Act 103AB does not provide for such a defence. The court emphasized the importance of protecting victims of sexual offences from the pressure of consenting to media publicity, which could diminish the community's perception of their protection.

In assessing the seriousness of the contempt, the court took into account the culpability of the editor. The editor's knowing breach of the law was considered a significant factor in determining the seriousness of the contempt. The court also considered the need for consistency in punishing contempt in similar cases, as highlighted in Director of Public Prosecutions v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd. The court imposed penalties that aligned with previous cases, aiming to ensure a principled and consistent approach to punishing contempt.

Lastly, the court noted that the victim's consent and the comparatively small number of copies distributed in Tasmania were relevant to the impact of the publication on the victim. However, these factors did not mitigate the contempt, as the primary purpose of the Evidence Act 103AB is to protect victims from media publicity regardless of their consent. The court's decision in R v The Age Company Ltd establishes the binding legal principle that the publication of a victim's identity in contravention of s103AB of the Evidence Act constitutes contempt of court, and the appropriate penalty should be determined by considering deterrence, culpability, and consistency in punishing similar cases.