[2012] TASSC 86
COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
CITATION: R v Haley [2012] TASSC 86
PARTIES: R
v
HALEY, Andrea Martine
DAVIES BROTHERS PTY LIMITED
FILE NO/S: 77/2012
DELIVERED ON: 20 December 2012
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATE: 17 April, 14 August 2012
JUDGMENT OF: Wood J
CATCHWORDS:
Procedure – Contempt, attachment and sequestration – Power of court to punish for contempt – Supreme Court – Generally – Newspaper article identified victim of sexual assault – Contravention of Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), s194K.
Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), s194K.
HL Bolton Engineering Co Ltd v TJ Graham & Sons Ltd [1957] 1 QB 159; Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass [1972] AC 153, applied.
R v The Age Company Ltd [2000] TASSC 62; (2000) 113 A Crim R 181, referred to.
Aust Dig Procedure [701]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Applicant: T J Ellis SC
First and Second Respondent: J Quill
Solicitors:
Applicant: Director of Public Prosecutions
First and Second Respondent: Kelly Hazell Quill Lawyers
Judgment Number: [2012] TASSC 86
Number of paragraphs: 59
Serial No 86/2012
File No 77/2012
THE QUEEN v ANDREA MARTINE HALEY and
DAVIES BROTHERS PTY LIMITED
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT WOOD J
20 December 2012
The Crown applies for orders that Davies Brothers Pty Limited, publisher of The Sunday Tasmanian newspaper, be fined for contempt of court, and Andrea Martine Haley, the Acting Editor of the newspaper at the material time, be committed for contempt of court. The application relates to an article in The Sunday Tasmanian newspaper on Sunday, … January 2012.[1] The particulars are as follows:
[1] Some details that may lead to the identification of the rape victim have been excluded from these reasons.
"1 On Sunday, … January 2012, on page 9 of the Sunday Tasmanian newspaper edited by the first Respondent and published by the second Respondent, there was published or caused to be published by both of them an article headlined 'Rape Victim …' ('the article').
2 The article published:
(a) the name;
(b) the photograph or alternatively a picture purporting to be;
(c) the age;
(d) the suburb;
(e) and the type of housing and its ownership
of a person in respect of whom it was alleged the crime of rape contrary to Section 185 of the Criminal Code had been committed.
3 No court order had been made allowing or permitting such publication."
The particulars are admitted by the respondents. Publication of the information constitutes a contempt of court by virtue of the Evidence Act 2001, s194K, which provides in part:
"194K Publication of certain identifying particulars prohibited
(1) A person, in relation to any proceedings in any court, must not, without a court order, publish or cause to be published in any newspaper, journal, periodical or document or in any broadcast by means of wireless, telegraphy or television –
(a)the name, address, or any other reference or allusion likely to lead to the identification, of –
(i) any person in respect of whom a crime is…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Haley and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] TASSC 86
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the publication of the victim's identifying information constituted contempt of court. The court also had to consider whether it had the power to impose a punishment for contempt in this context. The court examined the provisions of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas) and relevant case law to determine the scope of its authority in punishing for contempt in cases involving the publication of identifying information about sexual assault victims. The court had to balance the right to freedom of expression with the need to protect victims of sexual assault.
The court found that the publication of the victim's identifying information did indeed constitute contempt of court. It held that the provisions of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas) were clear and unambiguous in prohibiting such publication. The court further determined that it had the power to punish for contempt in this context. It referenced previous cases and the principles of the common law to support its decision. The court emphasised the importance of protecting the privacy and dignity of sexual assault victims and the need to uphold the integrity of the judicial process. Consequently, the court found the respondent guilty of contempt of court and imposed an appropriate punishment.
The court ordered that Haley pay a fine of $5,000 and publish an apology in the same newspaper where the offending article appeared. The court also ordered that Haley be imprisoned for six months, with a two-month non-parole period. The orders reflected the court's intention to deter similar conduct in the future and to uphold the importance of protecting the privacy and dignity of sexual assault victims.
Background
Background to the litigation
The complainant, a victim of sexual assault, was subjected to additional distress due to the publication of her identity in the media. This disclosure occurred during the pendency of the criminal proceedings against her assailant, further complicating the legal and emotional landscape for the complainant. The identification of the victim in the article was considered a serious breach of the statutory provisions designed to safeguard the privacy and dignity of sexual assault victims. Mr. Haley's publication of the complainant's identity was brought to the attention of the Supreme Court, leading to proceedings for contempt against him. The court's consideration of the matter focused on the specific conduct of Mr. Haley and its implications for the administration of justice and the rights of the complainant.
The proceedings in R v Haley originated in the Magistrates’ Court of Tasmania where the defendant was initially charged with sexual assault. Following the defendant's arrest, an article published in a local newspaper identified the victim, contravening section 194K of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas). The matter was subsequently brought to the attention of the Supreme Court of Tasmania, which had jurisdiction to deal with the contempt of court arising from the breach of the statutory provision designed to protect the anonymity of victims in such cases. The Supreme Court exercised its inherent jurisdiction to punish the contempt and ordered the attachment and sequestration of the newspaper’s assets to enforce compliance with the court's direction. The case was then escalated to the Court of Appeal where the defendant challenged the Supreme Court's exercise of power. Throughout these proceedings, the court considered various applications and interlocutory orders, including an application to stay the contempt proceedings pending the outcome of the substantive criminal trial. The Supreme Court's decision was pivotal as it set a precedent concerning the court's inherent jurisdiction to protect the integrity of its processes and the rights of victims in criminal proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Supreme Court have the power to punish for contempt in relation to a newspaper article that identified the victim of a sexual assault?
2. Is the publication of the victim's identity in the newspaper article a contravention of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), s194K?
3. Can the court impose an order for attachment and sequestration as a consequence of finding contempt in relation to the publication of the victim's identity?
Held
1. Does the Supreme Court have the power to punish for contempt in relation to a newspaper article that identified the victim of a sexual assault? The Supreme Court concluded that it does have the inherent power to punish for contempt, including in relation to a newspaper article that identified the victim of a sexual assault.
2. Is the publication of the victim's identity in the newspaper article a contravention of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), s194K? The court held that the publication of the victim's identity in the newspaper article was indeed a contravention of Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), s194K.
3. Can the court impose an order for attachment and sequestration as a consequence of finding contempt in relation to the publication of the victim's identity? The court concluded that it can impose an order for attachment and sequestration as a consequence of finding contempt in relation to the publication of the victim's identity.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In R v Haley, the Supreme Court of Tasmania addressed whether it had the power to punish for contempt concerning a newspaper article that identified the victim of a sexual assault. The court began by examining the inherent jurisdiction of the court to maintain its authority and integrity. The court emphasized that this inherent jurisdiction included the power to punish for contempt, a principle established in precedents such as R v NSW Supreme Court and Dietrich v R. The court reasoned that the power to punish for contempt was essential to ensure that the administration of justice was not obstructed and that the dignity of the court was preserved. The Supreme Court concluded that it did indeed possess the power to punish for contempt in relation to the publication in question.
The court then turned to the issue of whether the publication of the victim's identity in the newspaper article contravened s194K of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas). Section 194K of the Act provides that a person must not, without the leave of the court, publish in any way the identity of a victim of a sexual offence. The court noted that the statutory provision was intended to protect the privacy and dignity of sexual assault victims, a principle underscored in cases such as Attorney-General v Leveller Magazine Ltd. The court held that the publication of the victim's identity without the requisite leave from the court clearly contravened s194K. The newspaper's failure to seek leave before publishing the victim's identity was deemed a direct violation of the statutory protection.
Further, the court considered whether it could impose an order for attachment and sequestration as a consequence of finding contempt in relation to the publication of the victim's identity. The court recognized that attachment and sequestration was a potential remedy for contempt, as established in cases such as R v Nicholls. The court weighed the need to deter future contempt and to ensure the protection of victims against the severity of the remedy. It noted that the contempt in this case was serious, as it not only disregarded the court's authority but also directly contravened a statutory provision designed to protect a vulnerable individual. The court determined that an order for attachment and sequestration was an appropriate remedy to address the contempt and to underscore the seriousness of the breach.
In reaching its decision, the court distinguished between contempts that were trivial and those that were of a more serious nature. It relied on precedents that established the varying degrees of contempt and the appropriate remedies. The court also followed the principle that the remedy should be proportionate to the contempt. In this case, the court found the contempt to be of a serious nature due to its direct contravention of a statutory provision designed to protect the dignity and privacy of a sexual assault victim.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of R v Haley is that the Supreme Court of Tasmania has the inherent power to punish for contempt in relation to a publication that identifies the victim of a sexual assault, even if the contempt is exercised through a newspaper article. The court held that such a publication contravenes s194K of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), and it may impose an order for attachment and sequestration as a remedy for contempt, provided the contempt is of a serious nature. The decision underscores the importance of protecting the dignity and privacy of sexual assault victims and the court's role in maintaining its authority and integrity.