R v Stakaj; R v N, H

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Criminal Appeal)

R v STAKAJ; R v N, H

[2016] SASCFC 9

Reasons for Decision of The Court of Criminal Appeal

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Gray and The Honourable Justice Sulan)

23 February 2016

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - POWERS OF COURT - OTHER MATTERS

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - NEW TRIAL - IN GENERAL AND PARTICULAR GROUNDS - PARTICULAR GROUNDS - IRREGULARITY AS REGARDS PROCEDURE - MATTERS RELATING TO JURIES

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - POWERS OF COURT ON APPEAL - POWER TO ORDER NEW TRIAL OR QUASH CONVICTION AND DIRECT ENTRY OF VERDICT OF ACQUITTAL - WHERE NEW TRIAL ORDERED

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - ADJOURNMENT, STAY OF PROCEEDINGS OR ORDER RESTRAINING PROCEEDINGS - STAY OF PROCEEDINGS - GENERALLY

Application to be heard on remaining appeal grounds.  The applicants were charged with murder.  Following a trial before Judge and jury, the trial Judge entered verdicts of not guilty to the charge of murder and verdicts of guilty to the charge of manslaughter in respect of both applicants.  Later that day, the foreperson returned to the Court to advise of a potential error with the jury verdicts.  The applicants lodged notices of appeal against the convictions of manslaughter.  The applicants appealed on the ground that the jury did not reach a proper verdict as to the charge of murder and, as such, the verdict as to manslaughter was void.  The applicants’ notices of appeal also contained common form appeal grounds, including that the conviction as to manslaughter was unreasonable against the weight of the evidence.  The respondent filed an application seeking that the Court exercise its inherent jurisdiction to expunge or quash all verdicts.  On appeal, the respondent’s application was allowed and an order was made for a new trial of both applicants on the charge of murder.  The verdicts of not guilty of murder and the convictions of manslaughter were quashed.

Whether the Court should have heard the applicants on the common form appeal grounds.  Whether, in the alternative, the Court should hear submissions as to whether the order on the respondent’s application should be for an acquittal or a permanent stay, instead of a retrial.

Held per the Court (dismissing the application):

1. The applicants’ right to appeal is governed by section 352(1)(a) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA), which provides that only a convicted person has a right to appeal that conviction. The recorded convictions were held to be invalid and thus there is no conviction from which the applicants can appeal.

Held per Gray J (Sulan J agreeing):

1.       The Court does not have inherent power to order an acquittal in these circumstances.  Inherent powers are concerned with giving the Court the power to enforce its rules of practice and to suppress any abuses of its process. The power to order an acquittal on appeal is statutory.

2.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Stakaj; R v N, H and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASCFC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned appeals by the defendants, R v Stakaj and R v N, H, to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central dispute revolved around the validity of jury verdicts returned in the defendants' trial. The Director of Public Prosecutions had also made an application to the Court seeking to expunge or quash all verdicts and order new trials.

The legal issues before the Court included whether the jury's verdict of manslaughter was void due to an alleged failure to reach a proper verdict on the charge of murder. The Court was also required to consider the Director's application for new trials and the defendants' grounds of appeal, including whether the manslaughter conviction was unreasonable against the weight of the evidence.

The majority of the Court, in a joint judgment, allowed the Director's application, ordering new trials for the defendants and co-offenders on the charge of murder. They quashed the verdicts of not guilty of murder and the convictions of manslaughter. The Chief Justice, in dissent, would have dismissed the Director's application and allowed the defendants' appeals, ordering retrials on the manslaughter charge only. Following the delivery of the majority's reasons, the defendants' counsel sought to be heard on the common form appeal grounds and to make submissions on whether an acquittal or permanent stay should be ordered instead of a retrial. The Court recalled its orders to amend its reasons to reflect that the defendants had not been heard on all grounds of appeal.

Ultimately, the Court amended its orders and reasons. The Chief Justice indicated he would have set aside the manslaughter convictions and listed the appeals on the unreasonable verdict ground. However, the majority's decision to order new trials on the murder charge stood.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The defendants appealed on the ground that the jury did not reach a proper verdict as to the charge of murder and, as such, the verdict as to manslaughter was void. The defendants’ notices of appeal also contained common form appeal grounds for which permission, where required, was granted. One of those grounds was that the conviction as to manslaughter was unreasonable against the weight of the evidence. These are my reasons for declining to hear submissions on that ground.Background On 16 January 2015, the Director of Public Prosecutions filed an application seeking that the Court exercise its inherent jurisdiction to expunge or quash all verdicts, including those against the co-offenders, and order new trials on the Information. The Director’s application and the defendants’ appeals were listed for two days, commencing 26 March 2015. During the hearing, with the consent of all parties, the Court determined to adjourn submissions on the defendants’ common form appeal grounds until the validity of the jury verdicts had been determined. On 18 September 2015, the matter was listed for delivery of judgment. In a joint judgment with Sulan J, I allowed the Director’s application for a new trial of both defendants and the co-offenders on the charge of murder and quashed the verdicts of not guilty of murder and the convictions of manslaughter in respect of both defendants and the co-offenders. Kourakis CJ, in dissent, held that the Director’s application should be dismissed and the appeals of Stakaj and HN allowed. The Chief Justice noted that he would have ordered retrials of Stakaj and HN on the charge of manslaughter only. Upon receiving the reasons for judgment, counsel for Stakaj and HN submitted that the Court had proceeded to deal with the appeals of Stakaj and HN without hearing submissions from the parties as to the common form appeal grounds. It was noted that the Court could, pursuant to the ground that the verdict was unreasonable against the weight of the evidence, substitute the verdict with an acquittal rather than ordering a retrial. The Chief Justice noted that, in light of the orders of the majority, there would be no utility in hearing the defendants as to that ground of appeal. However, the Court recalled its orders to allow the reasons to be amended to reflect that the defendants were not heard on all grounds of appeal. On 25 September 2015, the Court reconvened to deliver its amended orders and reasons.[1] In his amended reasons, the Chief Justice stated that he would have set aside the convictions of manslaughter and listed the appeals of the defendants on the unreasonable verdict ground. Prior to delivering those amended orders and reasons, counsel for Stakaj and HN made an oral application to be heard on the common form appeal grounds. In the alternative, counsel requested that the Court hear submissions as to whether the Court should order an acquittal or a permanent stay, instead of a retrial, on the Director’s application. [1] Case Stated on Acquittal (No 1 of 2015); R v Stakaj & N, H (2015) 123 SASR 523.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established