R v Sparks; R v D Stracey; R v P Stracey

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES SUPREME COURT

CITATION:
R v Sparks; R v D Stracey; R v P Stracey [2010] NSWSC 1512

JURISDICTION:
Common Law

FILE NUMBER(S):
2009/43119
2009/252058
2009/263425

HEARING DATE(S):
30 August 2010 (Sparks and D Stracey)
15 September 2010 (P Stracey)

JUDGMENT DATE:
10 December 2010

PARTIES:
Regina
Glen Neil Sparks (Offender - 2009/43119)
David Stracey (Offender - 2009/252058)
Phillip Stracey (Offender - 2009/263425)

JUDGMENT OF:
Adams J      

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
Not Applicable

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
Not Applicable

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Not Applicable

COUNSEL:
A McCarthy (Crown)
J Manuell SC (Sparks & D Stracey)
G Thomas (P Stracey)

SOLICITORS:
I V Knight, Crown Solicitor
Legal Aid Commission (Sparks & D Stracey)
Mitchell Lawyers (P Stracey)

CATCHWORDS:
SENTENCE - Manslaughter in course of robbery - robbery - accessory after the fact - offence committed in 1987 - change in sentencing patterns - effect of rehabilitation in meantime.

LEGISLATION CITED:
Crimes Act 1900 ss 97(1), 117/154A
Crimes Act (1900-1989) ss 18(1)(b)/24
Crimes Act (1900-1994) s 97
Crimes (Life Sentences) Amendment Act 1989 s 19(2)
Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999
Probation and Parole Act 1983
Sentencing Act 1989
Sentencing Act 1999 s 44
Sentencing Bill, Second Reading, Hansard, 10 May 1989, p7905

CATEGORY:
Sentence

CASES CITED:
AJB v R [2007] NSWCCA 51; 169 A Crim R 32
Bradbery v R [2008] NSWCCA 93
R v Clarke [2001] NSWSC 703
R v Dixon; R v Dunn unreported, NSWSC, 18 November 1994
R v Fernando (1992) 76 A Crim R 58
R v Jennar unreported, NSWCCA, 4 March 1991
R v Macleay (1990) 19 NSWLR 112
R v Marsh [2002] NSWCCA 151
R v MJR (2002) 54 NSWLR 368
R v Perry; R v Roberts, unreported, NSWCCA, 7 March 1986
R v PLV (2001) NSWLR 736
R v Shore (1992) 66 A Crim R 37
R v Stevens unreported, NSWCCA, 15 August 1993
R v Thomson and Houlten (2000) 49 NSWLR 383
Winchester v The Queen (1992) 58 A Crim R 345

TEXTS CITED:
Janet B L Chan, The New South Wales Sentencing Act 1989:  Where Does Truth Lie (1990) 14 Crim LJ 249

DECISION:
2009/43119 - Glen Neil Sparks
For the crime of manslaughter:  Taking into account the matters on the Form 1, the commencing point is nine years imprisonment reduced to six years and nine months by virtue of the utilitarian discount of 25% arising from a plea of guilty.  Special circumstances are present having regard to the sentencing practice at the date of the offence.  I set a non-parole period of three years and six months commencing 29 May 2009.  The balance of the term of the sentence is three years and three months to commence on 29 November 2012 and end on 28 February 2016.
For the crime of robbery in company, the commencing point is five years, reduced to three years and nine months by virtue of the utilitarian discount of 25%.  Special circumstances apply as already mentioned.  I set a non-parole period of two years…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Sparks; R v D Stracey; R v P Stracey and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWSC 1512
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Sparks; R v D Stracey; R v P Stracey involved three defendants who were convicted of various offences stemming from a series of robberies and the subsequent death of a victim. The primary dispute in this case was the sentencing for the crimes committed in 1987, particularly focusing on the crime of manslaughter during the course of a robbery, and whether the defendants should be considered as accessories after the fact. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The legal issues the court needed to address were primarily centred around the appropriate sentencing for the crimes committed, considering the significant changes in sentencing patterns and guidelines since the time of the offences. The court had to balance the severity of the crimes against the defendants' rehabilitation and the changes in sentencing practices over the years. Another critical issue was whether the sentences for the separate but closely related offences should be concurrent or cumulative.

The court considered the evidence of rehabilitation and the time elapsed since the commission of the offences. It noted the marked changes in the sentencing regime and the general trends in sentencing patterns, which had evolved considerably since 1987 and to some extent since 1997. The court decided to weigh these developments in its sentencing decision. The court also looked into the details of the crimes, the immediate circumstances, and the cumulative effect of the sentences for the closely related offences. It determined that while the crimes were serious, the cumulative effect of sentencing should not be exaggerated due to the short time span and the nature of the offences being part of the same criminal enterprise.

In its final ruling, the court opted for concurrent sentences for the closely related offences while ensuring that the separate armed robbery warranted a degree of accumulation in sentencing. This approach aimed to reflect the seriousness of the crimes without overstating the cumulative impact of the sentences.

Background

Background to the litigation

A most important matter relevant in the present case is that the sentencing regime, and sentences in general, have changed markedly over the years since the commission of the 1987 offences and, indeed, to some degree since 1997. I shall deal with the significance of these developments after dealing with the evidence presented on behalf of David and Phillip Stracey.The Agreed Facts Since all the offences occurred within a short time, it seems to me that, for ease of understanding, I should deal with them in chronological order. Just before mid-day on 5 October 1987 a Holden panel van was stolen from a street in Maroubra. About 40 minutes or so later, Ms Buchanan who was walking along Cowper Street, Randwick saw this vehicle reverse and pull up in front of her, partially blocking the footpath. Two men were in the front of the motor vehicle. As she walked around the rear of the vehicle the passenger approached her from behind and attempted to forcibly remove her handbag from her shoulder. Ms Buchanan refused to let it go and there was a short tussle before the handbag strap broke and the contents spilled on the ground. The offender released his hold and ran back to the vehicle, which then left the scene. No property was, in the result, stolen. Of course, the two men in the vehicle were the present offenders. About 40 minutes later, Ms Ricketts and her husband were standing on a raised pedestrian refuge in Goulburn Street in the city, Ms Ricketts having her handbag over her left shoulder. The vehicle, driven by David Stracey and with Sparks in the passenger seat, travelled along Goulburn Street mounted the refuge. Stracey reached out and took hold of the handbag. Ms Ricketts did not let go and called for help as she was forced to run alongside the vehicle. The vehicle drove into the middle of Goulburn Street and accelerated, thus forcing Ms Ricketts to let her handbag go to save herself from falling under the vehicle or being hit by others. Mr Ricketts saw the handbag being pulled into the vehicle through the driver’s side window. Just three minutes later, some 400 metres away, Ms Po Cin Lim was standing at the traffic lights waiting to cross the street, wearing a handbag over her right shoulder. The vehicle approached her slowly and, when it neared Ms Lim, Sparks leaned out of the passenger’s side window and grabbed her handbag. Ms Lim yelled out “No” as Sparks pulled the handbag towards the vehicle. The van then accelerated with the deceased being dragged alongside for a number of metres, eventually falling onto the concrete kerb, striking her head. The vehicle did not stop and Ms Lim’s handbag was last seen being pulled inside the van. Ms Lim was treated at the scene by ambulance officers and was then conveyed to St Vincent’s Hospital where she underwent emergency surgery. However, she died at 6.15 pm on 6 October 1987. In the meantime, around 2pm on the day of the robbery, two men were observed in Centennial Park abandoning the Holden. Shortly afterwards a Nissan motor vehicle was stolen from the near vicinity.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In light of the short space of time in which the offences of 5 October were committed, the fact that they were part of essentially the one enterprise, and the delay in sentencing, I consider that the sentences should be concurrent. The calculation of a cumulative effect would be, in these circumstances, so relatively limited as to amount to artifice and give to the sentencing process in this case an illusory impression of precision. However, the armed robbery of 11 October was a serious separate crime and requires a degree of accumulation.Evidence in the Sentence Proceedings: David Stracey This evidence comprised a presentence report from the Probate and Parole Service, Stracey’s criminal convictions and the transcript of his interview with police on 4 November 2009, a letter from his wife dated 26 August 2010, a report from Mr James A Pitts, Chief Executive Officer of Odyssey House, a report by Mr Tim Watson-Munro, consultant forensic psychologist dated 27 August 2010 together with Stracey’s evidence. Stracey’s criminal history commences, so far as is presently relevant, with four convictions for receiving in October 1984, when he was 23 years of age. He received concurrent sentences of two years imprisonment with 12 months non-parole period. In October 1984 he was convicted of possessing a prohibited drug, being LSD, and was sentenced to a two year fixed term concurrently with the sentences for receiving but resulting in the absorption of his parole period with a prison term. There followed 12 charges of stealing, two charges of breaking, entering and stealing and two charges relating to the possession of Indian hemp and the use of heroin. Aside from the short sentences for these latter crimes, he was sentenced to concurrent terms of 12 months imprisonment except for one dealing offence for which a two year sentence with a non-parole period of 12 months was imposed. These convictions were followed by a conviction for robbery with striking in 1985, a further robbery in 1986, and stealing and illegal use of a conveyance in 1987. In 1991, however, he was treated with unusual leniency in the District Court in respect of two counts of stealing from a person, a larceny of a motor vehicle, the possession of implements to enter a conveyance and two charges of assaulting a police officer in the execution of his duty and attempting to escape lawful custody, with a number of other offences taken into account on what was then a Form 2. The Court deferred sentence on condition that he be of good behaviour for five years and accepted the supervision of the Community Corrective Service. On 25 June 1993 Stracey was convicted of one offence of stealing from the person upon which he was placed on a recognisance under s 558 and ordered to pay compensation. Most unusually, having regard to Stracey’s undoubted drug addiction and his by then serious record extending over seven years or so, his list of convictions ends. I return to this matter shortly. The presentence report notes that Stracey’s first contact with the Probate and Parole Service was for the purpose of preparation of a presentence report for the 1984 convictions. It was noted that he re-offended during the period of supervision. Following his release on parole for the offence of robbery with striking for which he was sentenced on 23 January 1985 with a term of four years and six months imprisonment and a non-parole period of two years, he committed a number of assaults and a robbery and received a further term of imprisonment, pursuant to which he was ultimately released to parole on 12 June 1987 regarded as a high risk parolee. The parole order expired on 11 June 1990 and it follows that the present offences were committed whilst he was on parole.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate sentence for the offences committed by David Stracey, Phillip Stracey, and Sparks, considering the circumstances and changes in sentencing patterns since 1987?
2. How should the court account for the rehabilitation of the offenders and their conduct post-offences in determining the sentences?

Held
1. Considering the changes in sentencing patterns since 1987, the court concluded that the appropriate sentence for the offences committed by David Stracey, Phillip Stracey, and Sparks should reflect the current sentencing landscape. The sentences were determined to be concurrent, taking into account the cumulative effect of the crimes while avoiding an artificial impression of precision.
2. In determining the sentences, the court accounted for the rehabilitation of the offenders and their conduct post-offences, noting the significant changes in their circumstances and behaviour over the years.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by acknowledging the significant changes in sentencing patterns and the general approach to sentencing since the commission of the 1987 offences. It recognised that the principles guiding sentencing have evolved, including a greater emphasis on proportionality and the circumstances of the offender. The court considered the current sentencing guidelines and the need to ensure that sentences reflect contemporary standards while also addressing the severity of the crimes committed.

In dealing with the first issue, the court recognised the need to impose sentences that are commensurate with the seriousness of the offences but also consider the offenders' conduct and rehabilitation since the offences. Given that the crimes were part of a single enterprise, the court opted for concurrent sentences to avoid an exaggerated cumulative effect. However, it also acknowledged the need for a degree of accumulation for the separate armed robbery. The court balanced these considerations, ultimately concluding that concurrent sentences were appropriate.

For the second issue, the court examined the evidence of rehabilitation and conduct post-offences. It noted the significant changes in the offenders' lives since 1987, including their participation in rehabilitation programs, their conduct while on parole, and their overall transformation. The court gave considerable weight to these factors, recognising that they reflected positively on the offenders' prospects for reintegration into society and their capacity for reform. This evidence influenced the court's decision to impose sentences that were not solely punitive but also rehabilitative, aiming to support the offenders' reintegration into society.

In applying these principles, the court distinguished the present case from prior authority by emphasising the importance of contemporary sentencing standards and the need to reflect the significant changes in the offenders' circumstances. The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the recognition that sentences must evolve with changes in societal values and sentencing practices while also considering the individual circumstances of the offenders, including their rehabilitation and conduct post-offences.