CITATION: R v Marsh [2002] NSWCCA 151 FILE NUMBER(S): CCA 60869/01; 60874/01 HEARING DATE(S): 29/04/02 JUDGMENT DATE:
29 April 2002PARTIES :
Regina
v
Stuart Cecil MarshJUDGMENT OF: Meagher JA at 1, 40; Hidden J at 15; Bell J at 39
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S) : SC 70013/01 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL
OFFICER :McClellan J
COUNSEL : Applicant: M C Ramage QC
Crown: D M L WoodburneSOLICITORS: Applicant: Brezniak Neil-Smith & Co
Crown: S E O'ConnorCATCHWORDS: Crown appeal against inadequacy of sentence - whether the trial judge failed to reflect the total criminality of the respondent - whether the trial judge failed to observe principles in Pearce v The Queen - whether sentences be served concurrently - appeal against inadequacy of sentence dismissed. Application for leave to appeal against severity of sentence - whether sentence of 13 years for manslaughter was manifestly excessive - leave to appeal against sentence allowed - appeal dismissed. LEGISLATION CITED: Crimes Act 1900 s19 CASES CITED: Pearce v The Queen (1994) 144 CLR 610
R v Simpson (2001) NSWCCA 534DECISION: Appeal against inadequacy of sentence dismissed. Leave to appeal against severity of sentence allowed; appeal dismissed.
CCA 60869/01
CCA 60874/01Monday, 29 April 2002MEAGHER JA
HIDDEN J
BELL J
1 MEAGHER JA: This matter was an application for leave to appeal by Mr Marsh against the severity of a sentence and an application by the Crown against the sentence on the ground of its leniency.
2 Mr Marsh pleaded guilty before McClellan J on 13 October 2001 in the Supreme Court to three counts on indictment. One was a count of manslaughter of Ms Lanh Ngoc Bui on that 3 August 2000 at Lidcombe, one was a count of robbery in company, of the same lady on the same date, and one was a count of taking and driving a conveyance on the same date. His Honour, on the first count, sentenced Mr Marsh to 10 years and four months to commence on 17 November 2000; in the case of robbery in company on the second count, to full-time imprisonment of six years to commence on 17 November; and on the count of taking and driving a conveyance, to a fixed term of full-time imprisonment of 14 months. All three sentences were to run concurrently.
3 In my view, his Honour was seriously in error in reaching the conclusion which he did.
4 It is worth reciting the facts of the manslaughter case.
5 On about 28 July 2000 a motor car was stolen from a street in Toongabbie and it is possible to infer that that was done by Mr Marsh. One does not know exactly whether he did or not, but we do know that on 3 August 2000 he was driving this vehicle. On that occasion he chose to pick up his co-offender, Mr Wayne Alan Clarke. Mr Marsh was the driver, Mr Clarke was a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Marsh and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] NSWCCA 151
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the trial judge appropriately assessed the respondent's total criminality and whether the sentence adequately reflected the principles of sentencing outlined in Pearce v The Queen. Additionally, the court had to determine if the sentences imposed should be served concurrently and whether the appeal against the adequacy of the sentence should be dismissed. The respondent also sought leave to appeal against the severity of his sentence, arguing that the 13-year sentence was manifestly excessive.
The court found that the trial judge did not err in the assessment of the respondent's total criminality or in applying the principles of sentencing from Pearce v The Queen. The sentences imposed were deemed appropriate and should be served concurrently. Consequently, the appeal against the inadequacy of the sentence was dismissed. Regarding the respondent's application for leave to appeal against the severity of the sentence, the court found that the sentence of 13 years for manslaughter was not manifestly excessive. Therefore, the application for leave to appeal against the severity of the sentence was allowed but the appeal itself was dismissed.
In conclusion, the appeal against the inadequacy of the sentence was dismissed, and the application for leave to appeal against the severity of the sentence was allowed but the appeal itself was dismissed.