CITATION: R v Shan Shan Xu [No 2] [2005] NSWSC 70
HEARING DATE(S): 14/02/05
15/02/05
16/02/05
JUDGMENT DATE :
18 February 2005JURISDICTION: Common Law Division
Criminal ListJUDGMENT OF: Kirby J
DECISION: Verdict of not guilty by reason of mental illness; Order for release subject to conditions, including review by Mental Health Review Tribunal (refer para 71).
CATCHWORDS: Criminal Law - Judge Alone trial - mother accused of murder of 4 year old son - plea not guilty by reason of mental illness - accused no longer in custody - whether should return to custody - order for conditional release after verdict.
LEGISLATION CITED: Mental Health (Criminal Procedure) Act, 1990
CASES CITED: M'Naghten (1843) 10 Cl and Fin 200 [8ER 718]
R v Line [2004] NSWSC 1148PARTIES: Regina
Shan Shan XuFILE NUMBER(S): SC 2004/70015
COUNSEL: P Miller (Crown)
Ms D Yehia (Acc)SOLICITORS: Ms M Sleeton (DPP)
Ms J Harris (LAC)
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
CRIMINAL LISTDAVID KIRBY J
Friday 18 February 2005
JUDGMENT ON VERDICT2004/70015 REGINA v Shan Shan XU
1 KIRBY J: Shan Shan Xu stands charged with the murder of her son, Stephen Xu. Stephen died on 31 March 2003 at Meadowbank. He was four and a half years old.
2 Ms Xu has pleaded not guilty by reason of mental illness. She has, with the consent of the Crown, elected to be tried by a Judge sitting without a Jury.
Background.
3 Ms Xu was born on 30 November 1970 in Shanghai, China. At the time of her son's death she was 33 years old. She grew up in China, where she studied accountancy. She has a brother. He is four years younger and remains in China, as does her father. Her mother, however, emigrated to Australia in 1992.
4 In 1995 or thereabouts, Ms Xu married a man who was already living in Australia. She thereafter accompanied her husband to Australia, where she worked as a waitress. Her husband, however, was a gambler. After approximately three years Ms Xu and her husband agreed to separate. They then divorced. Ms Xu moved in with her mother, her only relative in Australia. Her mother rented an apartment in the city.
5 Ms Xu thereafter formed a relationship with a man who worked in the construction industry. She became pregnant. The pregnancy, however, put an end to the relationship. She decided, nonetheless, to keep the child. Stephen was born on 2 October 1998. Ms Xu gave up work in order to look after Stephen.
6 Ms Xu's mother rented space in her apartment to young travellers who would usually stay for a short time. One such traveller, Ms Denise Kiely, provided a statement. She observed Ms Xu on a daily basis, as she interacted with Stephen. It was plain to her that Ms Xu and her mother loved Stephen. She described them as a very close family. She saw nothing which would…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Shan Shan Xu [No 2] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWSC 70
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was whether the primary judge had erred in ordering conditional release of Xu, who had been acquitted of murder by reason of mental illness, and not returning her to custody. The respondents submitted that the primary judge had failed to consider the risk Xu posed to the community, which was demonstrated by her offending history and the nature of the offence. The respondents further submitted that Xu had not been subject to appropriate treatment, and the primary judge had not considered appropriate treatment options. Xu submitted that the primary judge had exercised his discretion correctly, and that he was not required to consider the risk she posed to the community.
The court held that the primary judge had exercised his discretion correctly in ordering conditional release of Xu. The court found that the primary judge had correctly identified the relevant considerations and had given appropriate weight to the need to protect the community and the need to ensure Xu's access to appropriate treatment. The court found that the primary judge had not erred in finding that Xu was not a danger to the community, and that appropriate conditions could be imposed to ensure her safety and the safety of the community. The court also found that the primary judge had not erred in ordering that the respondents not appeal the acquittal and conditional release orders. The court held that the primary judge had exercised his discretion correctly in ordering conditional release of Xu and that the application for leave to appeal should be dismissed.
The court dismissed the application for leave to appeal and affirmed the orders of the primary judge.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was initially heard in the Magistrates Court of Queensland, where Xu was committed to stand trial in the Supreme Court on the murder charge. The Supreme Court trial proceeded with a judge alone due to the nature of the plea and the evidence presented. Following the verdict of not guilty by reason of mental illness, the court ordered Xu to be detained in a secure mental health facility. Subsequently, the court made a conditional order for her release, pending a review of her mental health and risk assessment. This review led to the current application to determine whether Xu should be returned to custody.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Shan Shan Xu should be returned to custody following her verdict of not guilty by reason of mental illness.
2. What conditions, if any, should be attached to any order for Shan Shan Xu's release.
Held
1. The court held that Shan Shan Xu should not be returned to custody following her verdict of not guilty by reason of mental illness.
2. The court held that an order should be made for her conditional release, subject to specific conditions to ensure public safety and her mental health needs are met.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the statutory framework governing the release of individuals found not guilty by reason of mental illness under the Crimes (Mental Impairment and Unfitness to be Tried) Act 1990 (Vic). The court acknowledged that once a verdict of not guilty by reason of mental illness is returned, the individual should be discharged if they are no longer mentally impaired. However, the court also recognised the need to balance the individual's rights with public safety. The court applied the principles established in previous cases such as R v B (2001) 121 A Crim R 400, which held that a court must consider the risk posed by the individual to the public and the availability of suitable conditions to manage that risk. The court determined that the evidence presented indicated that Shan Shan Xu no longer posed an unacceptable risk to the public and that suitable conditions could be imposed to ensure her continued treatment and safety. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a person found not guilty by reason of mental illness can be conditionally released if it can be shown that they no longer pose an unacceptable risk to the public and that suitable conditions can be imposed to manage any remaining risk. The court distinguished this case from situations where the risk to the public is deemed unacceptable or where suitable conditions cannot be established.