R v Ruzehaji; R v Nasradden

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Court of Criminal Appeal)

R v RUZEHAJI; R v NASRADDEN

[2018] SASCFC 60

Reasons for Decision of The Court of Criminal Appeal

(The Honourable Justice Peek, The Honourable Justice Nicholson and The Honourable Justice Lovell)

21 June 2018

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - VERDICT UNREASONABLE OR INSUPPORTABLE HAVING REGARD TO EVIDENCE

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PARTICULAR GROUNDS OF APPEAL - MISDIRECTION AND NON-DIRECTION

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PARTICULAR GROUNDS OF APPEAL - IMPROPER ADMISSION OR REJECTION OF EVIDENCE

Appeals against conviction.

The two appellants were each charged with three drug offences contrary to the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) (‘the Criminal Code’): one count of trafficking in a commercial quantity of a controlled drug, one count of trafficking in a marketable quantity of a controlled drug, and one count of pre-trafficking in a controlled precursor.

The prosecution case was that CCTV footage taken on 15 October 2012 at the private storage premises, Safeco, depicted the two appellants moving the subject drugs from one storage unit leased by the appellant Ruzehaji, to another unit leased by Nasradden. The prosecution case was that either both of the appellants were in joint possession of the subject drugs, or one of the appellants was in possession of the drugs and the other was assisting him in performing the charged offences.

In respect of both appellants, as well as the CCTV footage, the prosecution relied upon a number of other items of circumstantial evidence including: the Safeco activity log, which recorded the dates and times of access to the respective storage units; and lease documents for the storage units, which had photocopies of the appellants’ respective drivers licences annexed to them. In the case against Ruzehaji, the prosecution also relied on: additional CCTV footage from 9, 12, 15 and 16 October 2012, showing a male of similar physical appearance to Ruzehaji attend Safeco in a vehicle similar to one registered to him, at times which, according to the activity log, corresponded to times when Ruzehaji’s storage unit was accessed; Ruzehaji’s DNA being found on tea towels in one of two wicker baskets moved between the units on 25 October 2012 (the other of which contained the subject drugs); and evidence that Ruzehaji had purchased locks of exactly the same appearance as those found on the two storage units.

In the case against Nasradden, as well as the CCTV footage, the prosecution relied upon a number of items of circumstantial evidence including: that Nasradden commenced leasing his storage unit 2 days before the alleged offending, at which time he requested a unit proximate to the unit registered to Ruzehaji; and that Nasradden and Ruzehaji were long-term friends.

Held by the Court (dismissing Ruzehaji’s appeal):

(1) Applying the precepts in M v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 487, the jury acted reasonably in finding, in reliance upon the cumulative weight of all of the circumstantial evidence, that it was proven…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Ruzehaji; R v Nasradden and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASCFC 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia concerned appeals by R v Ruzehaji and R v Nasradden against their convictions for offences under the *Criminal Code Act 1995* (Cth). The prosecution case was that CCTV footage depicted the two appellants moving drugs and other items between storage units at Safeco premises. The alternative charges alleged that either both men were in joint possession of the drugs, or one was in possession and the other was assisting him.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the verdicts were unreasonable or insupportable having regard to the evidence, and whether the trial judge had erred in law by failing to adequately direct the jury on the separate consideration of the cases against each appellant, including identifying the distinct paths to guilt for individual acts and joint commission, and the evidence admissible for each. Additionally, the court considered grounds of appeal relating to the alleged improper admission and insufficient directions concerning DNA evidence found on tea towels.

The court reasoned that the circumstantial evidence, including CCTV footage, Safeco activity logs, lease agreements, vehicle registration details, seized clothing, and photographic evidence of a tattoo, was capable of excluding any reasonable hypothesis consistent with innocence regarding Ruzehaji's involvement. The court found that the trial judge had adequately directed the jury on the need to consider each appellant separately and had outlined the evidence admissible against each, as well as the legal principles of joint commission. Regarding the DNA evidence, the court noted that the admissibility of this evidence had been determined in pre-trial rulings, and the trial judge had addressed the potential for contamination and the weight to be given to such evidence.

The appeals were dismissed. The court concluded that it was open for the jury to find beyond reasonable doubt that Ruzehaji was one of the men shifting the drugs, and that the evidence at trial did exclude any reasonable hypothesis of innocence. The court also found no error in the directions given concerning the DNA evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Each count charged in the alternative an offence either committed by the respective accused as a principal or alternatively as a joint principal by reference to the appropriate sections of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) (‘the Criminal Code’). The reason for that method of alternative charging is that the prosecution case was that CCTV footage taken on 15 October 2012 at the private rental storage premises of Safeco at Windsor Gardens, an Adelaide suburb (‘Safeco’), depicts the two appellants moving the subject drugs and other items from one area (Unit 508) to another area (Unit 521); the prosecution case was that either both men were then in joint possession of the subject drugs or that one was in possession of the drugs and the other was assisting him in performing the offences charged.An overview of the prosecution evidence The Safeco premises were open to the public during business hours but after-hours access could be physically gained if a person entered on a keypad at the front gate an individual access code (unique to each leased unit). As to access to the individual leased units, the responsibility for locking individual leased storage units was that of the lessee; lessees could purchase locks at the premises, bring their own locks or leave their units unlocked. However, irrespective of the matter of locking a unit, lessees accessing their leased units at any time (locked or unlocked) were supposed to enter on a keypad the individual access code unique to each unit; a failure to enter this code would not prevent access but it would cause a silent alarm to be triggered and recorded on the Safeco computer system. This system recorded, and was able to produce, an ‘activity log’ (the ‘Safeco activity log’) which displayed, amongst other information, the dates, times and duration of access taken to both the Safeco premises (after-hours) and to the individual leased units (at any time), including any triggering of the silent alarm. The prosecution relied on the Safeco activity log, and the Safeco CCTV footage, together with various other items of circumstantial evidence, to prove that the two men seen in the CCTV footage on 15 October 2012 were the appellants. The evidence at trial included the following items. As at 15 October 2012, Ruzehaji and Nasradden were long-term friends. The terms of their conversations revealed in intercepted telephone communications between them made that quite clear. It is also to be noted that Ruzehaji had been a witness to Nasradden’s marriage in 2009. On 5 July 2012, Ruzehaji commenced to lease Unit 508 at Safeco. The lease document (exhibit P9) signed by Ruzehaji contains his full personal and contact details and a copy of his driver’s licence with photographic identification (‘the Ruzehaji Unit 508 lease agreement’). On each of the days 9, 12, 15 and 16 October 2012, the Safeco activity log recorded access to Ruzehaji’s unit (Unit 508) by the entry of the correct code and on each of those days, at times corresponding to those recorded in the activity log, the Safeco CCTV video footage showed a male person of similar physical appearance to Ruzehaji near the location of Unit 508 after office hours. Further:-On each of these occasions, this person was recorded driving a silver sedan (seen in external CCTV Safeco footage). On the Ruzehaji Unit 508 lease agreement Ruzehaji gave his vehicle details as registration number SO60-ASG. It was proven that a silver Toyota sedan registration number SO60-ASG was registered to Ruzehaji Enterprises between 15 May 2012 and 21 October 2012.-The Safeco CCTV footage of 9 October 2012 showed this person wearing a green singlet; and later, on 19 December 2012, police seized a green singlet of the same appearance from Ruzehaji’s bedroom at his home premises.-The Safeco CCTV footage of 9 October 2012 and 13 October 2012 both showed that this person had a tattoo-like mark on the front of his left shoulder. On 23 October 2012, a police officer conducting surveillance of Ruzehaji took a number of photographs of Ruzehaji; exhibit P24 contains three of those photographs which depict a tattoo at the same position on the front of his left shoulder.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A further submission made in writing, but not developed on the hearing, was that after Unit 508 had been leased by Ruzehaji on 5 July 2012, it was accessed while Ruzehaji was overseas for the period from 6 July to 8 August 2012. We find that, in all of the circumstances, this matter carries little weight.Conclusion concerning Ruzehaji’s ground 1 of appeal We conclude that it was well open for the jury to find beyond reasonable doubt that Ruzehaji was one of the two men shifting the drugs on 15 October 2012 on the basis of the whole of the evidence at trial. We conclude that the whole body of circumstantial evidence at trial was well capable of excluding any reasonable hypothesis consistent with innocence and in fact did so. Applying the precepts in M v The Queen,[13] we do not consider that, on the whole of the evidence, the jury should have held a doubt concerning the guilt of Ruzehaji, and we do not hold any such doubt. GROUND OF APPEAL 2: DNA EVIDENCE 2.The Learned Trial Judge erred in law in the admission of, and directions relating to, the DNA evidence:2.1. The Learned Trial Judge erred in admitting the evidence of the tea towels from which DNA samples were obtained;2.2. The Learned Trial Judge erred in admitting the evidence of the DNA samples themselves; and2.3. The Learned Trial Judge erred by failing to give any or sufficient specific directions relating to the reliability of the DNA sample taken from the tea towels.[13] (1994) 181 CLR 487.A matter of chronology: the pre-trial application to exclude the DNA evidence A pre-trial application was made to exclude the DNA evidence. Full argument was heard and on 11 August 2017, well before the commencement of the trial, the trial Judge ruled that the evidence would be admitted. His Honour delivered reasons for that ruling which correctly summarised the specific bases upon which the application had been made. Thus his Honour stated:[14][138] The thrust of the challenge to the admissibility of the DNA evidence is that the evidence is not capable of being circumstantial evidence linking the accused with the drugs. There is such a risk of contamination of the tea towels, or secondary or subsequent transfer of the accused’s DNA to the tea towels, that the presence of R’s DNA on the tea towels should be excluded. Even if the evidence is strictly capable of being circumstantial evidence of the accused’s association with the drugs, the slight probative weight of the evidence is outweighed by the prejudicial effect, such that it should be excluded in the exercise of the Christie[15] discretion. There is a danger of the ‘CSI effect’ that is, the jury may give to the DNA evidence greater weight than it is truly capable of bearing. [14] R v R & Nasradden [2017] SADC 111.[15] [1914] AC 545. The Judge then dealt with the facts upon which the challenge was based, including matters of possible contamination of the tea towels through inadequate wearing or changing of gloves. His Honour noted that:[141] There are several possible mechanisms by which contamination of the tea towels might have occurred. If the police had put on their gloves before they entered the warehouse they might have touched the stair rails on the way up to the unit 521. R might have shed some DNA on those stair rails and there may have been a secondary transfer to the gloves and the tertiary transfer to the tea towels. In the course of handling some of the exhibits in the unit there might have been a secondary transfer of R’s DNA to the gloves then tertiary transfer to the tea towels.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to paragraph [48] of the submission, this does indeed put what had preceded it into “other words”. No further comment is necessary.GROUND 5 OF APPEAL: SEPARATE CONSIDERATION OF THE CASE AGAINST EACH APPELLANT Ground 5 of appeal appears as follows:5.The Learned Trial Judge erred in law by failing to adequately direct the jury on the separate consideration of the cases against each of the two accused:5.1. The Learned Trial Judge failed to apply the law to the facts by identifying the separate paths to guilt for the Appellant acting alone and by way of joint commission.5.2. The Learned Trial Judge failed to direct the jury in respect of the use to which the evidence could be put in respect of the separate paths to guilty [sic].Ground 5.1: Identifying separate paths to guilt The Judge directed as to the alternative nature of the prosecution case thus:The prosecution case is that each of the accused is guilty of the three offences either acting alone or acting jointly with each other. The Crown case is that both accused are depicted in the CCTV footage either together or separately, and in that way, they were either both separately committing the offences or they were acting jointly. The Judge first directed the jury as to the case against the respective appellants based on their respective individual acts. In that context, his Honour made plain that the position of each appellant must be considered separately and directed the jury as to the respective bodies of evidence admissible against the respective appellants thus:Before I direct you on the ingredients of the three charges I make the following introductory remarks. One, I will deliberately refer to the ingredients as if they refer to a single accused. I do that partly out of convenience but more importantly to emphasise the fact that you must consider the position of each accused separately. …In respect of Mr Ruzehaji, the prosecution relies on the following pieces of circumstantial evidence. First, the accused rented unit 508 on 5 July 2010.Second, the correlation between the car registration detail on the unit lease agreement with the agreed fact about the car bearing that number being registered to the accused.Next, the activity log relating to the units 508 and 521. Next, the CCTV footage. Next, the green singlet. Next, the tattoo. Next, the lock. Next, the DNA and I will return to the lock and the DNA in a moment. Next, the connections between the two accused and finally, the telephone calls between the two accused.In respect of Mr Nasradden the prosecution relies on the following pieces of circumstantial evidence.1. The accused renting unit 521 on 13 October 2013.2.The Wilby evidence about the accused wanting his unit close to his friend's unit and initially not wanting a PIN card.3. The activity log.4. The CCTV footage.5. The connections between the two accused.6. The drugs being found in his unit. (Emphasis added) The Judge later directed the jury as to what amounts in law to “joint commission”, the alternative way in which the prosecution put its case (at pages 7 to 8 of the summing up in a passage reproduced at paragraph [101] above).