R v Portus; Ex parte City of Perth

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

. Barwick C.J., McTiernan, Menzies, Gibbs and Stephen JJ.

THE QUEEN v. PORTUS; Ex parte CITY OF PERTH.

(1973) 129 CLR 312

21 December 1973

Conciliation and Arbitration (Cth)

Conciliation and Arbitration (Cth)—Industrial dispute—Claim of right to appeal to Conciliation and Arbitration Commission against dismissal from employment—Commission to determine whether dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable and make settlement it deems just—Whether claim related to industrial matter—Conferring of judicial power on Commission—Power to enforce award given to Commission—Jurisdiction of Commission—Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904-1972 (Cth), s. 4 (1).

Decisions


December 21.
The following written judgments were delivered:-
BARWICK C.J. In this matter I have had the advantage of reading the reasons for judgment prepared by my brother Menzies and those prepared by my brother Stephen. I agree that the rule nisi for prohibition should be made absolute for the reason that the failure of the prosecutors to agree to the demands of the respondent association made by its letter of 23rd March 1972 did not give rise to a relevant industrial dispute. In my opinion, it did not claim anything which pertained to the relationship of employer and employee within the meaning of s. 4 (1) of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904-1972 (Cth) (the Act). The subject matter of the demands, in my opinion, was the capacities and functions of the Conciliation and Arbitration Commission, a matter regulated by the Act and not a proper subject for treatment by dispute or award. As well, the function sought to be given to that Commission included a decision as to whether or not a claimant employee fell within the terms of the proposed award, and in particular whether he was an officer whose employment had been terminated or an officer who had been dismissed. At least to determine that particular question would be an exercise of judicial power. To decide whether conduct fell within a statutory description of "harsh, unjust or unreasonable" would, in my opinion, be a judicial function. I see no reason why that should not be so in relation to such a description in an industrial award. (at p315)

2. Further, I think that, unlike some award provisions which provide machinery for the implementation of other provisions of the award, e.g. provisions for a board of reference, the proposed provision would do no more than provide machinery for the resolution of disputes between individual employees and individual employers as to the circumstances of the dismissal of the one by the other. Whether or not such a difference amounted in a relevant sense to an industrial dispute, a matter which I find no need presently to resolve, clearly it would not be a dispute extending beyond the limits of any one State. (at p316)

3. It will thus be seen that I agree substantially with all the reasons given by my brother Stephen for his conclusions and that, whilst otherwise agreeing with his reasons, I do not wholly share the reservations which my brother Menzies…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Portus; Ex parte City of Perth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1973] HCA 64
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an application for a writ of prohibition brought by the City of Perth against Mr. Portus, the Commonwealth Conciliation and Arbitration Commission. The dispute concerned the validity of an award made by the Commission concerning the wages and conditions of certain municipal employees, specifically those employed by the City of Perth. The City of Perth sought to prohibit the Commission from further proceeding with or enforcing the award, alleging it was beyond the Commission's constitutional power.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the award made by the Commission was validly made within the scope of the Commonwealth Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 (Cth) and, by extension, within the constitutional power of the Commonwealth Parliament to make laws with respect to conciliation and arbitration for the prevention and settlement of industrial disputes extending beyond the limits of any one State. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the industrial dispute found by the Commission truly extended beyond the limits of one State, as required by s 51(xxxv) of the Constitution.

The Court reasoned that for an industrial dispute to extend beyond the limits of one State, there must be a real dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another State, or a dispute between employers and employees in one State and employers and employees in another

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established