R v NGUYEN

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Criminal Appeal)

R v NGUYEN

[2018] SASCFC 87

Judgment of The Court of Criminal Appeal

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Kelly and The Honourable Justice Blue)

21 August 2018

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - NEW TRIAL - IN GENERAL AND PARTICULAR GROUNDS - PARTICULAR GROUNDS - MISDIRECTION OR NON-DIRECTION - JUDGE'S SUMMING UP

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - DRUG OFFENCES

Application for permission to appeal against convictions by jury for aggravated serious criminal trespass in a place of residence and aggravated robbery of a mobile telephone and cash in the amount of $315.

The issue at trial was identity.  The prosecution case relied on the evidence of two eyewitnesses, Mr Robinson and Ms McDermott, who were cross-examined on what were suggested to be prior inconsistent statements given to police on the day of the robbery and at a previous trial.  The Judge directed the jury that they should consider the extent to which the making of the prior inconsistent statements affected the credibility and reliability of Mr Robinson and Ms McDermott and explained a process they might adopt in evaluating their testimony against the prior inconsistent statements.  After the jury, having been deliberating for four and a half hours, sent a note informing the Judge that they did not ‘consider’ that they could ‘reach a decision’.  The Judge directed the jury to resume its deliberation the following morning.

The applicant seeks permission to appeal on the ground that the Judge misdirected the jury in relation to the prior inconsistent statements of Mr Robinson and Ms McDermott. The applicant also contends that the deliberation direction placed undue pressure on the jury.

Held, per Kourakis CJ (Kelly and Blue JJ agreeing), granting permission to appeal on the first ground, refusing permission on the second ground, and dismissing the appeal:

1.       While some aspects of the Judge’s direction on prior inconsistent evidence could have been better expressed,  the irregularities contended for by the applicant could not possibly have caused a miscarriage of justice (at [38]-[44]).

2.       In all of the circumstances, including the open textured terms of the Judge’s explanation for giving the deliberation direction, there is no reason to think that it put the jury under unacceptable pressure (at [45]-[46]).

Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 137(1), s 170(1), referred to.
Black v The Queen (1993) 179 CLR 44, considered.

R v NGUYEN
[2018] SASCFC 87

Court of Criminal Appeal:   Kourakis CJ, Kelly and Blue JJ

  1. KOURAKIS CJ:       This is an application for permission to appeal against convictions for aggravated serious criminal trespass in a place of residence[1] and aggravated robbery[2] of a mobile telephone and cash in the amount of $315. 

    [1] Contrary to s 170(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA).

    [2] Contrary to s 137(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA).

  2. The principal evidence against the applicant was the testimony of a victim, Mr Tyler Robinson, who was a resident of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v NGUYEN and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASCFC 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a criminal conviction, with the appellant, Mr. Nguyen, appealing against the decision of the trial judge. The dispute arose from the trial judge's summing up to the jury, which the appellant contended contained misdirections. The appeal was heard by Kourakis CJ, Kelly J, and Blue J.

The central legal issue before the appellate court was whether the trial judge erred in their summing up to the jury. Specifically, the appellant argued that the judge failed to adequately direct the jury on the need for each juror to reach their own individual verdict, rather than being swayed by the majority or succumbing to pressure to agree. This related to the circumstances of the jury's deliberation, which were described as short.

The appellate court, in dismissing the appeal, reasoned that in the specific circumstances of this case, particularly given the short period of jury deliberation, a specific warning against jurors joining in a verdict they did not honestly believe was correct was not necessary. The court implicitly applied the principle that the nature and length of jury deliberations can inform the necessity of particular directions. The court found no error in the judge's summing up.

The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I elaborate on my reasons below.The evidence Mr Robinson testified that the residents of the house at Prospect on the day of the robbery were himself, Mr Colin Trowbridge, Mr Graham Hall, and Mr Lam, the last of whom had started living in the house several months before the robbery. On the night before the robbery, Ms McDermott visited Mr Robinson. They watched television and smoked some cannabis. At the time, Mr Lam was in his bedroom with his girlfriend. Mr Robinson retired to his room to sleep at about 11.00 pm leaving Ms McDermott to sleep on the couch in the lounge room at the back of the house. At about 8.00 am, Mr Robinson was awoken by banging on the front door of the house. Looking through the door of his room he saw two men standing near the front door next to Mr Lam. The men had bandanas over their faces, and were wearing hoodies, sunglasses, gloves and long pants. Mr Robinson retreated back into his bedroom. Minutes later, Mr Lam called Mr Robinson out of his room. He then saw that one of the intruders was carrying a .22 rifle which had been sawn off and resembled a pistol. The intruders showed Mr Robinson into the lounge room at the back of the house. There the men accused Mr Lam of not repaying a debt he owed them. At Mr Lam’s suggestion, he and the armed intruder moved to the front of the house where they remained for about 20 minutes. The other intruder stayed within sight of Mr Robinson and Ms McDermott. Not surprisingly both Ms McDermott and Mr Robinson were very scared. Ms McDermott was shaking uncontrollably. They smoked some cannabis to calm their nerves. Mr Robinson testified that when Mr Lam and the armed intruder returned, the armed intruder had taken off his bandana and sunglasses. He could see his face clearly. He watched the gunman for five to 10 minutes. During the course of the incident, Mr Robinson observed the other intruder looking at his phone. After the intruders had left, Mr Robinson noticed that his phone and wallet had gone. Both intruders left over the back fence. Mr Robinson was cross-examined about a statement he gave to the police on the morning of the robbery. He explained that he was questioned while sitting in the back of a police car, and that a police officer wrote down his questions and Mr Robinson’s answers as he spoke to him. Mr Robinson testified that at the time he was still in shock and shaken and he was reluctant to give a statement. He was eventually approached by another police officer, Constable William Walker. He gave him a statement at about 9.28 am. In cross-examination, it was put to Mr Robinson that he did not tell Constable Walker that either of the intruders had removed his disguise. Mr Robinson responded ‘That’s right, because it was a traumatic experience where I needed to get my head together and I was quite distraught from it’. Mr Robinson also agreed that he told Constable Walker that he would not recognise either of the intruders if he were to see them again. Mr Robinson explained that he answered in that way because he was ‘quite scared’.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the circumstances of this case and in particular given the short period of deliberation, it was not necessary for the Judge to warn the jurors against joining in a verdict which they did not honestly think was the correct one.[3][3] Black v The Queen (1993) 179 CLR 44 at 51-52.Conclusion I would grant permission to appeal on the first ground. I would refuse permission on the second ground. I would dismiss the appeal. KELLY J: I agree. BLUE J: I agree.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established