R v Muirhead; R v Muirhead; Ex parte

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

R v Muirhead; R v Muirhead; Ex parte Attorney-General (Qld) [2019] QCA 244

PARTIES:

In CA No 39 of 2019:

R
v
MUIRHEAD, Andrew David
(applicant)

In CA No 41 of 2019:

R
v
MUIRHEAD, Andrew David
(respondent)
ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF QUEENSLAND
(appellant)

FILE NO/S:

CA No 39 of 2019
CA No 41 of 2019
DC No 265 of 2018

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Sentence Application
Sentence Appeal by Attorney-General (Qld)

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Maroochydore – Date of Conviction: 4 February 2019 (Jones DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

12 November 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

11 October 2019

JUDGES:

Fraser and McMurdo JJA and Buss AJA

ORDERS:

1.   Sentence application refused.

2.   Sentence appeal by the Attorney-General dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – APPEAL BY ATTORNEY-GENERAL OR OTHER CROWN LAW OFFICER – GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE – SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE – where applicant/respondent pleaded guilty to dangerous operation of a vehicle causing death – where applicant/respondent sentenced to imprisonment for three years six months – where applicant/respondent contends sentencing judge erred in finding offending conduct did not involve momentary inattention – whether sentence manifestly excessive – whether sentence manifestly inadequate

Barbaro v The Queen (2014) 253 CLR 58; [2014] HCA 2, cited
Lacey v Attorney-General (Qld) (2011) 242 CLR 573; [2011] HCA 10, cited
Lowndes v The Queen (1999) 195 CLR 665; [1999] HCA 29, cited
R v Allen[2012] QCA 259, cited
R v Boubaris[2014] QCA 199, cited
R v Browning[2018] QCA 337, cited
R v Burnett-Greenland (2017) 81 MVR 16; [2017] QCA 159, cited
R v Flew[2008] QCA 290, cited
R v Gruenert; Ex parte Attorney-General (Qld)[2005] QCA 154, cited
R v Hart[2008] QCA 199, cited
R v Henderson; Ex parte Attorney-General(Qld)[2013] QCA 63, cited
R v Huxtable[2014] QCA 249, cited
R v Lightbody (2019) 88 MVR 95; [2019] QCA 61, cited
R v MacDonald (2014) 244 A Crim R 148; [2014] QCA 9, cited
R v Maher[2012] QCA 7, cited
R v Osborne[2014] QCA 291, cited
R v Palmer; Ex parte Attorney-General (Qld)[2019] QCA 133, cited
R v Pham (2015) 256 CLR 550; [2015] HCA 39, cited
R v Schoner (2015) 255 A Crim R 470; [2015] QCA 190, cited
Veen v The Queen [No 2] (1988) 164 CLR 465; [1988] HCA 14, cited

COUNSEL:

A J Edwards for the applicant/respondent
M R Byrne QC for the respondent/appellant

SOLICITORS:

Wallace O'Hagan Lawyers for the applicant/respondent
Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland) for the respondent/appellant

  1. FRASER JA:  I agree with the reasons for judgment of Buss AJA and the orders proposed by his Honour.

  2. McMURDO JA:  I agree with Buss AJA.

  3. BUSS AJA: Andrew David Muirhead (the applicant) was charged on indictment with one count which alleged that on 27 July…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Muirhead; R v Muirhead; Ex parte and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCA 244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Muirhead; R v Muirhead; Ex parte involves the Attorney-General's appeal against a sentence imposed on the applicant for dangerous operation of a vehicle causing death. The applicant had pleaded guilty to the charge and was sentenced to imprisonment for three years and six months. The Attorney-General's appeal contends that the sentence imposed by the primary judge was manifestly inadequate. The appeal hinges on the question of whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate or excessive, and whether the primary judge erred in finding that the offending conduct did not involve momentary inattention.

The court had to determine whether the sentence imposed by the primary judge was manifestly inadequate or excessive, in light of the Attorney-General's appeal. The court considered the relevant legal principles and the circumstances of the case, including the applicant's personal circumstances, prior criminal record, and prior traffic history. The court found that the applicant's depression, self-medication with methylamphetamine and alcohol, and significant distress at the time of the offending were relevant mitigating factors. The court concluded that the sentence imposed by the primary judge was appropriate and that the appeal should be dismissed.

In conclusion, the court found that the Attorney-General's appeal against the sentence imposed on the applicant was not well-founded. The court held that the sentence was neither manifestly inadequate nor excessive, and that the primary judge's findings were not erroneous. The court dismissed the Attorney-General's appeal and refused the applicant leave to appeal against the sentence.

The orders of the court are as follows: 1. The application for leave to appeal against sentence is refused. 2. The appeal by the Attorney-General against sentence is dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Sentence application refused.

2. Sentence appeal by the Attorney-General dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 328A(4)(a), as currently enacted, came into operation on 20 March 2007.The facts and circumstances of the offending On 27 July 2017, at about 4.55 pm, the victim parked her car outside her house on School Road. The car was parked legally on the left shoulder of the southbound lane, behind her husband’s utility. The outer edge of the victim’s car was about 20 cm ‑ 30 cm inside the fog line marked on the road. The applicant was driving an Isuzu truck which was towing an item of wood-chipping equipment. The applicant was approaching the victim’s parked car from behind. His vehicle was of a size and type that required a special licence to drive it. Before the applicant’s vehicle reached the victim’s parked car, the applicant had driven around a slight left-hand bend. At that stage there was at least 105 m of straight road, and an unobstructed line of sight, to the place where the victim’s car was parked. If the applicant had been travelling at the speed limit, it would have taken him about 7.6 seconds to travel the distance. There was no suggestion that the applicant had been speeding. When the applicant’s vehicle reached the victim’s parked car, the victim had alighted from her car and was standing near the driver’s door of her car. The driver’s door was shut. The front left side mirror of the applicant’s vehicle struck the rear right tail light section of the victim’s car. The applicant’s vehicle continued forward and other parts of his vehicle (the left rear tailgate hinge, the front left side indicator and the rubber moulding/support arm) struck the right side of the victim’s car. The front left side of the applicant’s vehicle (not the side mirror) then struck the victim. The applicant did not brake, swerve or take any other action to avoid the collision. The applicant stopped his vehicle on the side of the road about 40 m after the point of the collision. He then ran to the victim, who was lying on the road. The applicant showed clear signs of distress that he had struck and killed the victim. The applicant was breathalysed upon the police arriving at the scene. His blood alcohol reading was 0.037 per cent. A sample of the applicant’s saliva revealed the presence of methylamphetamine. However, no testing was undertaken to determine the concentration of that drug. At the time of the collision, the road was in good condition and the weather was fine.The applicant’s personal circumstances, prior criminal record and prior traffic history The applicant was aged 39 at the time of the offending. He was aged 40 when sentenced. When the offending occurred the applicant was feeling very depressed as a result of his separation from his partner of eight years. They had one child who was aged five when the applicant was sentenced. After the offending, the applicant consulted and was treated by a psychologist, Merri Hughes. He saw Ms Hughes on 13 occasions. The applicant reported to Ms Hughes that, when the offending occurred, he was experiencing significant sleep disturbance, fatigue and difficulties concentrating and he was under significant financial stress. He had been using methylamphetamine and alcohol as self-medication. Ms Hughes was of the view that there was a direct link between the applicant’s “presenting issues” and the incident which resulted in the victim’s death. The applicant expressed deep remorse and sorrow to Ms Hughes, on numerous occasions, for the victim’s death and the trauma that his actions had caused to the victim’s family. Ms Hughes diagnosed the applicant as suffering from a major depressive disorder with moderate to severe anxious distress. As a consequence of the incident, the applicant’s health deteriorated to such an extent that his capacity to work in any meaningful way was greatly diminished.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Attorney‑General’s sole ground of appeal has not been made out.Conclusion Accordingly, I would refuse to grant the applicant leave to appeal and I would dismiss the Attorney‑General’s appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 328A(6) provides, relevantly, that in s 328A:“operates, or in any way interferes with the operation of, a vehicle dangerously means operate, or in any way interfere with the operation of, a vehicle at a speed or in a way that is dangerous to the public, having regard to all the circumstances, including –(a)the nature, condition and use of the place; and(b)the nature and condition of the vehicle; and(c)the number of persons, vehicles or other objects that are, or might reasonably be expected to be, in the place; and(d)the concentration of alcohol in the operator’s blood or breath; and(e)the presence of any other substance in the operator’s body.” Section 328A(4)(a), as currently enacted, came into operation on 20 March 2007.The facts and circumstances of the offending On 27 July 2017, at about 4.55 pm, the victim parked her car outside her house on School Road. The car was parked legally on the left shoulder of the southbound lane, behind her husband’s utility. The outer edge of the victim’s car was about 20 cm ‑ 30 cm inside the fog line marked on the road. The applicant was driving an Isuzu truck which was towing an item of wood-chipping equipment. The applicant was approaching the victim’s parked car from behind. His vehicle was of a size and type that required a special licence to drive it. Before the applicant’s vehicle reached the victim’s parked car, the applicant had driven around a slight left-hand bend. At that stage there was at least 105 m of straight road, and an unobstructed line of sight, to the place where the victim’s car was parked. If the applicant had been travelling at the speed limit, it would have taken him about 7.6 seconds to travel the distance. There was no suggestion that the applicant had been speeding. When the applicant’s vehicle reached the victim’s parked car, the victim had alighted from her car and was standing near the driver’s door of her car. The driver’s door was shut. The front left side mirror of the applicant’s vehicle struck the rear right tail light section of the victim’s car. The applicant’s vehicle continued forward and other parts of his vehicle (the left rear tailgate hinge, the front left side indicator and the rubber moulding/support arm) struck the right side of the victim’s car. The front left side of the applicant’s vehicle (not the side mirror) then struck the victim. The applicant did not brake, swerve or take any other action to avoid the collision. The applicant stopped his vehicle on the side of the road about 40 m after the point of the collision. He then ran to the victim, who was lying on the road. The applicant showed clear signs of distress that he had struck and killed the victim. The applicant was breathalysed upon the police arriving at the scene. His blood alcohol reading was 0.037 per cent. A sample of the applicant’s saliva revealed the presence of methylamphetamine. However, no testing was undertaken to determine the concentration of that drug.