R v Khelwaty & Khelwaty No. DCCRM-02-520

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

R v KHELWATY & KHELWATY
[2002] SADC 63

Judge Vanstone
Criminal

Introduction

  1. Each accused man is charged jointly by Information dated 30 July 2001 with two counts of Threatening Life, contrary to section 19(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935.  The offences are alleged to have occurred on 4 January 2001 at Oaklands Park.  The trial of these charges was originally scheduled to take place before Justice Besanko on 14 January 2002.  Pre-trial argument did indeed commence on that day and continued on 15 and 16 January.  Then, as now, Mr G Aitken appeared for the accused Habibullah Khelwaty and Mr G Mancini appeared for Sulaiman Khelwaty.  Ms S McDonald then appeared for the Director of Public Prosecutions, but before me Mr M Anders appears to prosecute. 

  2. On 15 January His Honour delivered rulings on the various applications he had heard.  On 16 January, as a result of new information given her by the complainants, Ms McDonald sought and was granted an adjournment of the trial.  For reasons which are not known to me the matter was later removed to this court.

  3. Since the proceedings in January took place, new Rule 9 notices have been filed on behalf of both accused men.  Some of the applications therein raise new issues which are related to the reasons for which Ms McDonald sought to vacate the January trial but other matters in them were previously ventilated before Justice Besanko.  As far as those latter topics are concerned, I take the view that defence counsel are entitled to re-argue those matters before me and are not bound, as it were, by the rulings given by another judge.  On Friday, 17 May I ruled on the various matters raised.  What follows are my reasons for those rulings.  I deal with the various applications in turn. 

    Rule 8 Applications

  4. On 15 January 2002, Rule 8 applications in identical terms were filed on behalf of both accused men.  The orders sought were that the trial be stayed as an abuse of the process of the court.  I set out the particulars given in support of the application:

    “2.1A material witness Anthony Constantinou is not to be called by the prosecution.

    2.2The prosecution has obtained a statement from Anthony Constantinou.

    2.3The prosecution has supplied the applicant with a copy of that statement.

    2.4The applicant will be deprived of an opportunity of acquittal if the material witness Anthony Constantinou is not called by the prosecution and would therefore be deprived of a fair trial such as to amount to an abuse of the process of the Court.

    2.5The applicant has a legitimate expectation that the witness Anthony Constantinou would be called and will be called by the prosecution at trial.”

  5. It is unnecessary to go to the affidavits filed in support of the applications.  The factual background to the applications is that when interviewed by police in relation to these allegations, Habibullah Khelwaty said that at the relevant time he had been with a person…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Khelwaty & Khelwaty No. DCCRM-02-520 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SADC 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the District Court of South Australia, Habibullah Khelwaty and Sulaiman Khelwaty were jointly charged with threatening life under section 19(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935. The alleged offence occurred on January 4, 2001, at Oaklands Park. The trial was initially scheduled before Justice Besanko but was later transferred to Judge Vanstone. The court was required to decide various pre-trial applications, including whether the trial should be stayed due to the prosecution's decision not to call a material witness, whether certain individuals should be cross-examined before the trial, whether an interview should be presented via audio or video tape, and whether evidence of previous violence should be admitted.

Judge Vanstone ruled that the trial should not be stayed as an abuse of process due to the prosecution's decision not to call the material witness. The court also declined to allow cross-examination of certain individuals before the trial, stating that the interests of justice did not require it. The court decided that the interview should be presented via video tape rather than audio tape, as it would be more useful to the jury. Evidence of previous violence was deemed admissible, as it was relevant to the case and its probative force outweighed any prejudicial effect. Lastly, the court set aside a subpoena for the Director of Public Prosecutions' counsel to provide evidence and documents, finding it to be vexatious and an abuse of process.

The trial proceeded as a joint one, as the interests of justice dictated. The court ruled that the evidence of the previous violent incident was not prejudicial to Sulaiman Khelwaty, as it was not alleged that he was present, and any prejudice could be cured by direction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established