R v Hartnett

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

[2001] QCA 512

COURT OF APPEAL

McPHERSON JA
MACKENZIE J
CHESTERMAN J

No CA 221 of 2001

THE QUEEN

v.

JAMIE JOHN HARTNETT

BRISBANE

..DATE 16/11/2001

JUDGMENT

McPHERSON JA:  I will ask Mr Justice Chesterman to give the first judgment.

CHESTERMAN J:  On 30 July, last, the applicant pleaded guilty in the District Court at Maryborough to three counts of the unlawful use of a motor vehicle.  The offences were committed about a week apart on 20 September, 27 September and 1 October 2000.

On each occasion the application negotiated to sell a stolen motor vehicle to an undercover police officer.  Each vehicle was comparatively new and of substantial value. 

The applicant was described as "a cog in a very sophisticated scheme" to steal and sell motor vehicles in and around Bundaberg.  The applicant was not, himself, a thief but was, in effect, the agent for the sale of those who stole and organised the theft of cars.  He does appear to have co-operated with the police in their investigation. 

The applicant was sentenced to two and a half years' imprisonment on each count to be served concurrently.  The imprisonment in each case to be suspended after serving nine months with an operational period of the sentence for a period of four years.

The applicant makes no complaint about the time he must spend in custody but does complain that the term of imprisonment is excessive and should have been 18 months.  As well, he argues for a reduction in the operational period to two years.

The applicant is comparatively young. He was 24 at the time of the offences and is now 25. He has a criminal history, though not for offences of dishonesty. He has twice been convicted of offences against the Drugs Misuse Act and twice of breaching obligations of community based orders.

He obtained an apprenticeship as a carpenter and had almost qualified as a tradesman when convicted.  He appears to have been a capable employee who has favourably impressed his employers.

The applicant's lapse into crime was caused by drugs.  He became addicted to amphetamines and incurred debts to his suppliers.  It was to discharge those debts as well as to obtain some cash for himself that he participated in the organised theft of motor vehicles.

At the time of conviction the applicant had returned to live with his parents who are supportive.  He was in employment and had apparently overcome his drug addiction.  He anticipates that he will have to pay just over $3,000.00 by way of compensation to those whose vehicles were taken.

The argument advanced on his behalf is that a comparison of sentences for like offences indicate that the appropriate range was between 18 months and two years, making the imposed sentence of two and a half years excessive.

Secondly, it is said that the operational period of four years is particularly harsh because it extends the applicant's liability to serve the balance of the period of imprisonment should he re-offend…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Hartnett and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QCA 512
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Jamie John Hartnett, the appellant, challenged the sentence imposed on him by the District Court at Maryborough for three counts of the unlawful use of a motor vehicle. The offences were committed between September 20 and October 1, 2000, where Hartnett negotiated to sell stolen motor vehicles to an undercover police officer. Hartnett was not the thief but was the agent for the sale of stolen vehicles as part of a sophisticated scheme. He was sentenced to two and a half years' imprisonment on each count, to be served concurrently, with the imprisonment suspended after nine months, and an operational period of four years. Hartnett argued that the sentence was excessive and should have been 18 months, and that the operational period should have been reduced to two years.

The court was required to determine whether the sentence imposed by the District Court was excessive and whether the operational period was disproportionately long. Hartnett's legal team relied on previous cases to support their arguments, suggesting that the appropriate sentence range was between 18 months and two years. They also argued that the operational period of four years was particularly harsh as it extended the applicant's liability to serve the balance of the period of imprisonment should he re-offend well beyond the notional finishing point of the sentence.

The court found that the sentence imposed on Hartnett was not manifestly excessive, even when considering the suspension of the sentence after serving nine months. The court noted that the involvement in organised crime made this case worse than others and that a sentencing judge is entitled to structure a suspended sentence in such a way as to provide a substantial incentive for an accused not to re-offend. The court concluded that the sentencing discretion was properly exercised, and the application for leave to appeal against the sentence was dismissed.

The final orders were that the application for leave to appeal against sentence was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established