R v Doolan; R v Lebois-Agius; R v Shaw

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Criminal Appeal)

R v DOOLAN; R v LEBOIS-AGIUS; R v SHAW

[2016] SASCFC 111

Judgment of The Court of Criminal Appeal

(The Honourable Justice Kelly, The Honourable Justice Peek and The Honourable Justice Lovell)

27 September 2016

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - VERDICT UNREASONABLE OR INSUPPORTABLE HAVING REGARD TO EVIDENCE - APPEAL ALLOWED

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - VERDICT UNREASONABLE OR INSUPPORTABLE HAVING REGARD TO EVIDENCE - APPEAL DISMISSED

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PARTICULAR GROUNDS OF APPEAL - IMPROPER ADMISSION OR REJECTION OF EVIDENCE - OTHER CASES

EVIDENCE - ADMISSIBILITY - EXCLUSIONS: IMPROPERLY OBTAINED EVIDENCE

CRIMINAL LAW - EVIDENCE - MATTERS RELATING TO PROOF - STANDARD OF PROOF - GENERALLY

Appeals against conviction.

The appellants were found guilty after a trial by judge alone of five counts of aggravated robbery, two counts of attempted aggravated robbery, one count of aggravated assault causing harm, one count of aggravated recklessly causing serious harm, one count of aggravated serious criminal trespass in a place of residence and one count of theft as part of a joint criminal enterprise. Those 11 charges represented six separate incidents that occurred over a 12 hour period from midnight on 15 March 2014. A fourth co-offender, Weetra, pleaded guilty to each of the offences.

The primary issue at trial was the identity of Weetra's co-offenders. The trial Judge concluded that the same three co-offenders accompanied Weetra at all six incidents. The Judge went on to find that the appellants were those co-offenders.

All three appellants appeal on the basis that the verdicts of guilty are unreasonable or unsupported having regard to the evidence. The appellants Lebois-Agius and Doolan appeal on the further ground that the Judge erred in admitting telephone data evidence against each of them in circumstances where the prosecution had failed to properly establish compliance with s 178 of the Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 (Cth). Lebois-Agius also appeals on the ground that the Judge erred in admitting evidence in circumstances where the seizure of the evidence was tainted by the manner of the police's search of Lebois-Agius' home.

Whether the verdicts were unsatisfactory or unsupportable having regard to the evidence. Whether the Judge erred in admitting telephone data evidence against the appellants Lebois-Agius and Doolan. Whether the Judge erred in admitting evidence yielded from a search of the home of Lebois-Agius.

Held per Kelly J (Peek and Lovell JJ agreeing) (dismissing the appeals of the appellants Lebois-Agius and Doolan):

1.       The seizure of the mobile phones attributed to Doolan and Lebois-Agius was authorised under the general search warrant. The appellants have not established any illegality or impropriety in the conduct of the police during the search and seizure of the items at Lebois-Agius' home and there was no proper basis to exclude the evidence from the mobile phones attributed to Doolan or Lebois-Agius.

2. It was open to the Judge on the whole of the evidence to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Doolan; R v Lebois-Agius; R v Shaw and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASCFC 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *R v Doolan; R v Lebois-Agius; R v Shaw* involved appeals against convictions for aggravated robbery. The appellants, Doolan, Lebois-Agius, and Shaw, each argued that the findings of guilt were unreasonable or unsupported by the evidence. Additionally, Doolan and Lebois-Agius contended that the trial judge erred in admitting telephone data evidence against them, with Lebois-Agius also challenging the admission of evidence from a search of his home. The appeals were heard by Kelly, Peek, and Lovell JJ of the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the verdicts of guilt against each appellant were unreasonable or insupportable having regard to the evidence presented at trial. This required the court to assess the strength and reliability of the prosecution's case, particularly concerning the identification of the offenders and the connection of each appellant to the various incidents. Furthermore, the court had to determine if the trial judge had properly exercised their discretion in admitting certain evidence, specifically telephone data and evidence obtained from a search, against Doolan and Lebois-Agius.

The court's reasoning focused on a detailed review of the evidence presented at trial, including CCTV footage, victim accounts, and forensic evidence such as DNA. For Shaw, the court found that while his DNA was present on a screwdriver found at one scene, and he had innocent links to a vehicle used in the offences, the evidence was not capable of supporting a conclusion beyond reasonable doubt of his involvement in any of the crimes. The court acknowledged the possibility of secondary DNA transfer and the limitations of circumstantial evidence in establishing guilt. In contrast, for Doolan and Lebois-Agius, the court was satisfied that the telephone metadata and content, along with the nature of communications between their phones, provided sufficient evidence to establish their possession of the phones and their presence at relevant times and locations, thereby supporting the trial judge's findings of guilt.

Consequently, the court allowed Shaw's appeal, quashed his convictions, and directed that verdicts of acquittal be entered. The appeals of Doolan and Lebois-Agius were dismissed, upholding their convictions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Each appellant appeals on the ground that the findings of guilt are unreasonable or unsupported having regard to the evidence. The appellants Lebois-Agius and Doolan both appeal on the further ground that the Judge erred in admitting telephone data evidence against each of them. In the case of Lebois-Agius, there is a further complaint that the Judge was wrong to admit the evidence of the search which took place at his home on 16 March 2014. Background The primary issue at trial was the identity of the other three offenders accompanying Weetra. It is convenient to set out the relevant evidence at trial. Count 1 – Croydon Park At approximately midnight on Saturday 15 March 2014 a 16 year old man was attacked and robbed as he walked home from a railway station. He saw three or four men get out of a red car before he was punched in the head. The victim’s mobile phone was later found in Weetra’s possession. This offending was the subject of a charge of aggravated robbery.Count 2 – West Croydon Less than five minutes later and just a few hundred metres from the attack in Croydon Park, three aboriginal men ran at Ms Elliot and her friend in a park. One of the men had a pole. He threatened Ms Elliot, told her to hand over her property and ripped a necklace from around her neck. The other assailants hit her friend over the head and chased him away. During this attack Ms Chilcott drove a car around the corner. The three men went to the car and starting hitting it, one of them with a pole. During this attack on the car Ms Elliot ran away and Ms Chilcott drove around the block and called 000 before meeting up with Ms Elliot. A shop located across the road from the park had closed circuit television (CCTV) surveillance cameras that captured the end of the incident. Although of poor quality, the footage appears to show three men running and getting into a car which immediately drives off, driven by a fourth man. This offending was the subject of a charge of aggravated robbery.Counts 3 and 4 – Welland At 12.16 am three women were attacked outside the Coles supermarket at Welland Plaza. CCTV cameras at Welland Plaza and the ‘On The Run’ service station on Port Road (adjacent to Welland Plaza) captured footage of the movements of a red or maroon Holden vehicle with a ‘P-plate’ visible in the front windscreen prior to the attack. I shall refer to that vehicle as ‘the Holden’. The ‘On The Run’ CCTV cameras recorded the Holden travelling on the Adelaide bound lanes of Port Road before turning right across the median strip and entering the vicinity of the service station. Footage shows Weetra wearing a hooded jumper going into the service station and making a purchase while another person is visible in the front passenger seat of the Holden. The Welland Plaza footage shows the Holden a short time later driving past the three victims standing in the car park outside the Coles building and then around a corner out of sight. The footage does not show the attack, however the evidence at trial was that the women were attacked by three men who ran towards them. One of the victims called 000 at 12.16 am, immediately after the Holden drove off.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At trial a number of hypotheses were put forward by defence counsel to explain the telephone evidence. It was suggested that the Doolan phone did not in fact belong to Doolan and although he had used it between 12 March 2014 and 20 March 2014, he was not in possession of it on 15 March 2014. Regarding the Lebois-Agius phone it was suggested that Lebois-Agius was home but not in possession of the phone, and indeed he tried to contact his own phone by calling it from the Rankine phone. However the Judge found beyond reasonable doubt from the meta data, the content of the phones and also the nature and content of the communications between the three mobile phones that Doolan and Lebois‑Agius were in possession of the Doolan and Lebois-Agius phones respectively on 15 March 2014. DNA evidence In addition to being a passenger in the Holden before the offending began, Shaw is linked to the Holden by DNA evidence on the interior of the Holden and on a toothbrush found inside the Holden. The Judge accepted counsel for Shaw’s submissions that, given Shaw’s innocent links to the Holden, this evidence did not connect Shaw with the commission of the offences. Shaw’s DNA was, however, on the screwdriver left at the scene of the Adelaide offending. The Judge acknowledged expert evidence given regarding secondary transfer of DNA and also counsel’s submissions in relation to Fitzgerald v The Queen,[2] but considered the DNA evidence to be of some weight in the prosecution’s circumstantial case against Shaw. [2] (2014) 88 ALJR 779.The Judge’s findings The Judge concluded that Weetra and three others, travelling in the Holden, were present at all six locations before going on to consider whether Weetra was accompanied by the same three men at all locations. He found that the same three men were involved in the Croydon Park, West Croydon and Welland offending. The Judge noted that there was sufficient time in the almost two hours between the Welland and Norwood offending, the four hours between the Norwood and Adelaide offending, and the almost six hours between the Adelaide and Ridgehaven offending for the configuration of people accompanying Weetra to change. His Honour noted the similarities in the modus operandi of the offending but also distinguishing features of the Adelaide and Ridgehaven offending. He also considered that, despite differences in descriptions of the offenders at each location, there were no marked dissimilarities and also it is likely that the offenders would wish to keep their numbers low to minimise the risk of detection. His Honour concluded “[o]n balance, I think it is more likely than not that Weetra had the same three co-offenders at each location.”[3][3] R v Doolan, Le Bois-Agius and Shaw [2016] SADC 5 at [91]. He was satisfied that whoever was present at the location of each incident of offending was part of a joint enterprise to commit the offences.The appeal All three appellants complain that the verdicts are unreasonable and unsatisfactory having regard to the evidence and that it was not open to the Judge to be satisfied of each appellant’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Counsel for the appellants pointed to various aspects of the prosecution case and evidence in support of this ground, including weaknesses in the identification evidence, temporal gaps between sets of offending, the generic modus operandi of the offending, differences between the Ridgehaven and Adelaide offending compared to other incidents, the imprecise evidence regarding the number of assailants, and the limitations on the use of the mobile phone evidence to place the appellants either together or at different locations at particular times.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KELLY J
In summary, for these reasons I do not consider that the evidence against Shaw is capable of supporting a conclusion beyond reasonable doubt of his involvement in any of the offences and the appeal of Shaw must be allowed. Conclusion I would make the following orders:1I would grant permission to Shaw to add the additional ground of appeal. 2I would allow the appeal of Shaw.3I would quash the convictions in relation to Shaw and direct that a judgment and verdicts of acquittal be entered. 4I would dismiss the appeals of Doolan and Lebois-Agius. PEEK J: I agree with the orders proposed by Kelly J and with her reasons. LOVELL J: I agree with the orders proposed by Kelly J and with her reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KELLY J

Full text does not contain this section.