"R" v Department of Community Services

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
CITATION: "R" v DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES [2001] NSWSC 419
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 10880/01
HEARING DATE(S): 15 May 2001
JUDGMENT DATE:
15 May 2001

PARTIES :


Plaintiff: "R"
Defendant: Department of Community Services
JUDGMENT OF: Hulme J at 1
LOWER COURT
JURISDICTION :
Local Court
LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Magistrate Mitchell
COUNSEL : Plaintiff: In person
Defendant: Mr AC Johnson
SOLICITORS: Plaintiff: In person
Defendant: IV Knight Crown Solicitor
DECISION: Summons dismissed


- 11 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT


OF NEW SOUTH WALES


COMMON LAW DIVISION

NO: 10880/01


Tuesday, 15 May 2001



JUDGMENT
R v DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES
NON-PUBLICATION ORDER

1    HIS HONOUR: I have before me an application by Richard S to whom I have referred in the title above as “R”, the father of JS for the return of his almost 2 year old daughter to him.

2    The background against which the application is made is that in January of 2000 the child was removed by the Department of Community Services when some six months old. A care application was lodged, and in October last, Mr Barnett, a children's Magistrate, made orders placing the child in the care of her maternal grandmother until the age of eighteen years. An appeal was lodged to the District Court and came before Judge Puckeridge. His Honour, on 30 November, dismissed that appeal, although in doing so disagreed with a number of findings made by Mr Barnett.

3    On 18 December last an application was made by Mr S and his wife, they having been the appellants in the District Court, seeking a rescission of the order placing the child in the care of its maternal grandmother. On 19 January another application was lodged, this time by Mr S, seeking that his daughter be returned to him. An affidavit in support of that application indicates that although in an apparently unsigned affidavit lodged in support of the December application, Mr and Mrs S had said they had a loving, strong and secure relationship, they had in fact separated on 5 January when the wife left the matrimonial home.

4    The matter or matters - for the moment I do not differentiate - came before Mr Mitchell, a children's Magistrate, on 19 February being dealt with as an application under section 90 of the Children and Young Persons' Care and Protection Act for leave to make an application for rescission or variation of the care order then in force. Mr Mitchell refused such leave. Then on 28 March the summons was filed in this Court.

5    Mr S has appeared for himself in these proceedings, though he has had the support of his wife who joined him at the Bar Table, and whom I allowed to address me in addition to such remarks as Mr S himself cared to make. It seems to me that given the nature of the application and the circumstances of the parties, this was an appropriate course. The application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read "R" v Department of Community Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 419
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of "R" v Department of Community Services was heard by Hulme J at the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff, "R", sought the return of his daughter who had been placed in the care of her maternal grandmother by the Department of Community Services. The case had a complex background involving multiple court proceedings and decisions, including an initial care application, an appeal, and subsequent applications for rescission or variation of the care order.

The legal issues before the court involved the jurisdictional scope of the Supreme Court in reviewing decisions of a children's magistrate and the criteria for granting leave to make a further application under section 90 of the Children and Young Persons' Care and Protection Act. The court had to determine whether it could intervene under its parens patriae powers or under the Justices Act and, if so, whether the application met the necessary criteria for relief.

Hulme J concluded that while the court had jurisdiction to review the magistrate's decision, the application did not meet the criteria for relief. The court found that the magistrate had erred in considering an incorrect application date and in not sufficiently addressing the inconsistencies in the evidence presented. However, the court declined to grant the relief sought by "R" and instead advised that a fresh application, properly supported by evidence and legal representation, would be more appropriate. The court emphasized the importance of addressing the inconsistencies and credibility issues before any further application is made.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the summons and to refrain from publishing the reasons for judgment to protect the identity of the parties and the child involved.

Background

Background to the litigation

In January 2000, when the child JS was six months old, she was removed from her parents by the Department of Community Services (DoCS). A care application was subsequently lodged. In October, a children's Magistrate, Mr Barnett, made orders placing the child in the care of her maternal grandmother until she reached eighteen years of age. An appeal against this decision was lodged with the District Court and dismissed by Judge Puckeridge on 30 November, though Judge Puckeridge disagreed with some of Mr Barnett's findings. On 18 December, JS's parents, Mr and Mrs S, applied for a rescission of the order placing JS in the care of her maternal grandmother. On 19 January, Mr S applied for his daughter to be returned to him. The wife had left the matrimonial home on 5 January, and the couple had separated. On 19 February, Mr S's application for leave to make an application for rescission or variation of the care order was refused by Mr Mitchell, a children's Magistrate. The summons was filed in the Supreme Court on 28 March.

The matter began in the Local Court where a care application was lodged, and orders were made placing JS in the care of her maternal grandmother until she reached eighteen. This decision was appealed to the District Court, which dismissed the appeal. Subsequently, applications were made by JS's parents for rescission of the care order and for JS to be returned to her father. These applications were refused by a children's Magistrate, leading to the summons being filed in the Supreme Court on 28 March. The summons was heard on 15 May by Hulme J.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Supreme Court has jurisdiction to review the decision of the children's Magistrate under section 104(4) of the Justices Act.
2. Whether the Supreme Court has parens patria jurisdiction to hear the matter as a substantive application for a care order.
3. Whether the children's Magistrate's reasons for refusing leave to make an application for rescission or variation of the care order are erroneous or flawed.

Held
1. The Supreme Court has jurisdiction to review the decision of the children's Magistrate under section 104(4) of the Justices Act.
2. The Supreme Court does not have parens patria jurisdiction to hear the matter as a substantive application for a care order.
3. The children's Magistrate's reasons for refusing leave to make an application for rescission or variation of the care order are erroneous or flawed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether it had jurisdiction to review the children's Magistrate's decision under section 104(4) of the Justices Act, which allows for an appeal on a question of law alone against an interlocutory order made by a Magistrate in summary proceedings. The court found that the application for leave to make an application for rescission or variation of the care order was indeed an interlocutory order and, therefore, the court had jurisdiction to review it. However, the court declined to hear the matter as a substantive application for a care order under its parens patria powers, as the case had not been prepared or presented in the detail necessary for the court to deal with it as such. The court further examined the children's Magistrate's reasons for refusing leave and found that they were erroneous or flawed. The Magistrate had proceeded on the basis that he was considering a joint application made by the parents rather than the father's individual application. Additionally, the Magistrate's reliance on the unexplained content of a Department of Community Services report was found to be clearly erroneous, as the father had denied the allegations and provided explanations for his actions. The court also noted that the report contained hearsay statements that lacked credibility and should not have been acted upon without some indication of reliability.

In light of these errors, the court did not set aside the Magistrate's orders and remit the matter to him. Instead, the court advised the parents to seek legal assistance to address the inconsistencies in their case and to present a more detailed case before any further application is heard. The court ultimately dismissed the summons and ordered that there be no publication of its reasons, with the final version to be altered to conceal the parties' and child's identity for potential future publication.