Seldon and Denny and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SELDON & DENNY AND ANOR [2010] FamCA 1029
FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – With whom the children live and spend time – Where child in temporary care of State welfare authority – Where neither parent is able to meet the child’s needs – Both the mother and father have a history of drug abuse and anti-social behaviour – Family violence – Returning the child  to either parent would expose child to unacceptable risk – Parental responsibility given to  the NSW Minister for Community Services – Child to have limited supervised visits with his parents
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss 60B, 60CA, 60CC, 61B, 61C(1), 61DA(2), 61DB, 64A, 65AA, 65DAA, Pt VII
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140
M v M (1998) 166 CLR 69
Neat Holdings Pty Ltd v Karajan Holdings Pty Ltd (1992) 67 ALJR
Johnson and Page (2007) FLC 93-344
W and W (Abuse allegations: unacceptable risk) (2005) FLC 93-235
A v A (1998) FLC 92-800
R v Department of Community Services [2001] NSWSC 419
Sydneywide Distributors Pty Ltd v Red Bull Australia Pty Ltd [2002] FCAFC 157
Carpenter & Lunn (2008) FamCAFC 128
Mazorski v Albright (2007) Fam LR 516
APPLICANT: Ms Seldon
RESPONDENT: Mr Denny
INTERVENOR: Director General,
Department of Human Services
INDEPENDENT CHILDRENS LAWYER: Legal Aid NSW
FILE NUMBER: (P)NCC 1868 of 2008
DATE DELIVERED: 9 September 2010
PLACE DELIVERED: Newcastle
PLACE HEARD: Newcastle
JUDGMENT OF: The Hon. Justice Ryan
HEARING DATES: 17, 18, 19, 20, 23, 24, 25 & 27 November 2009

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Ms Burns
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Craney Family Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr Wilkinson
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Sneddon & Partners
COUNSEL FOR THE INTERVENOR: Mr Anderson
SOLICITOR FOR THE INTERVENOR: Crown Solicitor’s Office
COUNSEL FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER:

Ms O’Rourke

SOLICITOR FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER:

Legal Aid NSW

Orders

  1. That all prior orders made pursuant to the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) in relation to the child J born … December 2007 (“the child”) are discharged.

  2. That the New South Wales Minister for Community Services, the Intervenor in these proceedings, has the sole parental responsibility for the child until the child attains the age of 18 years.

  3. That the child shall spend time with the applicant, the mother, supervised by an officer or delegate of the Director General as delegate of the Minister as follows:

    (a)for one period of 2 hours each three months at such times and locations as agreed to by the Director General as delegate of the Minister at any time between the hours of 8.00 am and 6.00 pm ; and

    (b)at any other time as agreed in advance by the Director General as delegate of the Minister and the mother.

  4. That child shall spend time with the respondent, the father, supervised by an officer or delegate of the Director General as delegate of the Minister as follows:

    (a)for one period of two hours each three months at such times and locations as agreed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seldon and Denny and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FamCA 1029
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Seldon and Denny and Anor, Justice Ryan of the Family Court of Australia considered the welfare of a child, J, born in December 2007. The proceedings involved the child's mother (the applicant), the child's father (the respondent), and the New South Wales Minister for Community Services, who intervened in the proceedings. The core dispute concerned the appropriate parenting arrangements for the child, given the circumstances that led to the intervention of the Minister.

The court was required to determine the extent of parental responsibility to be allocated to each parent, the nature and frequency of any time the child would spend with the parents, and the conditions under which such time would occur. Further, the court had to consider measures to protect the child from potential harm or negative influence from the parents, including provisions for supervision and restrictions on derogatory commentary. The court also had to address the Minister's role in the child's ongoing care and the process for any proposed changes to the child's foster placement.

Justice Ryan ordered the discharge of all prior orders made under the Family Law Act 1975 concerning the child. The court vested sole parental responsibility for the child in the New South Wales Minister for Community Services until the child attained the age of 18 years. The child was ordered to spend supervised time with both the mother and the father, with specific provisions for the frequency, duration, and location of these visits, and the power for supervisors to suspend visits if parents appeared drug-affected or failed to follow directions. The parents were also restrained from speaking about each other, their families, or foster carers in a derogatory manner in the child's hearing. The Minister was required to provide notice to the parents of any proposed changes to the child's foster family. The court also made orders regarding the dissemination of the single expert's report and the inclusion of a fact sheet detailing the obligations and consequences of contravening the orders. All other outstanding applications were dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That all prior orders made pursuant to the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) in relation to the child J born … December 2007 (“the child”) are discharged.

2.

That the New South Wales Minister for Community Services, the Intervenor in these proceedings, has the sole parental responsibility for the child until the child attains the age of 18 years.

3.

That the child shall spend time with the applicant, the mother, supervised by an officer or delegate of the Director General as delegate of the Minister as follows:

(a) for one period of 2 hours each three months at such times and locations as agreed to by the Director General as delegate of the Minister at any time between the hours of 8.00 am and 6.00 pm ; and

(b) at any other time as agreed in advance by the Director General as delegate of the Minister and the mother.

4.

That child shall spend time with the respondent, the father, supervised by an officer or delegate of the Director General as delegate of the Minister as follows:

(a) for one period of two hours each three months at such times and locations as agreed to by the Director General as delegate of the Minister at any time between the hours of 8.00 am and 6.00 pm ; and

(b) at any other time as agreed in advance by the Director General as delegate of the Minister and the father.

5.

That in the event the mother or the father appears to be drug affected or fails to abide the supervisors’ reasonable directions, the supervisor may suspend the child’s visit.

6.

That the mother and father are restrained from speaking about each other, members of the others family and the foster carers in the child’s hearing in a derogatory fashion or allow any other person to do so.

7.

In the event that the New South Wales Minister for Community Services proposes to change the foster family in which the child resides, notice of that proposed change must be given to the mother and the father.

8.

That each of the parties has liberty to provide copies of the single expert’s report prepared for these proceedings to their or the child’s counsellors or any agency involved in the child’s care.

9.

Pursuant to s 65DA(2) and s 62B of the Family Law Act 1975, the particulars of the obligations these orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these orders and details of who can assist parties adjust to and comply with an order are set out in the Fact Sheet attached hereto and these particulars are included in these orders.

10.

That any person who issued subpoena for the production of documents shall forthwith return them to their owner.

11.

That all outstanding applications are otherwise dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Seldon and Denny and Anor involves a child, referred to as J, born in December 2007. The proceedings before the court arose out of a complex family situation where the child had been placed in foster care under the New South Wales Minister for Community Services. The child's parents, identified as the mother and the father, each sought to have greater involvement in the child's life, but concerns about their ability to provide a safe and stable environment led to their parental responsibilities being restricted.

The court's decision was influenced by extensive evidence regarding the parents' circumstances and their interactions with the child. Both parents had histories of drug use and had shown instability in their lives, which raised concerns about their capacity to care for the child. The mother had a history of drug use and had been involved in criminal activities. The father had also struggled with drug addiction and had a history of domestic violence. These factors, combined with the child's best interests, led the court to determine that neither parent was in a position to have sole parental responsibility for the child at that time.

Given these circumstances, the court ordered that the New South Wales Minister for Community Services would have sole parental responsibility for the child until the child turned 18. To balance the child's need for contact with both parents, the court allowed for supervised visitations with each parent. These visits were to be closely monitored to ensure the child's safety and wellbeing. The parents were also prohibited from speaking negatively about each other or other family members in the child's presence, and they were required to refrain from derogatory comments about the foster carers. Additionally, any proposed changes to the child's foster placement would need to be communicated to both parents. The court's orders aimed to protect the child while still allowing for meaningful relationships with both parents under controlled conditions.

The proceedings in Seldon and Denny and Anor commenced as an appeal against a decision made by the Family Court of Australia. The initial matter involved the care and custody of a child born in December 2007. The Family Court had previously issued orders regarding the child's care, which were subsequently subject to the appeal heard by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. This appeal was brought forth to review and potentially alter the original custodial arrangements and visitation rights of the child's parents. The New South Wales Minister for Community Services was also an intervenor in these proceedings, asserting a significant role in the child's welfare and placement. Throughout the appellate process, several interlocutory applications were filed by the parties, seeking various procedural clarifications and adjustments to the interim care arrangements. The court issued several interlocutory orders aimed at preserving the child's welfare during the pendency of the appeal. Ultimately, the court considered the appeal and rendered its decision, discharging prior orders and establishing new custodial and visitation arrangements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should discharge all prior orders made pursuant to the Family Law Act 1975 in relation to the child.
2. Whether the New South Wales Minister for Community Services should have sole parental responsibility for the child until the child attains the age of 18 years.
3. Whether the child should spend time with the mother under supervision and, if so, under what conditions.
4. Whether the child should spend time with the father under supervision and, if so, under what conditions.
5. Whether the supervisors should have the authority to suspend the child’s visits if either parent appears drug affected or fails to abide by the supervisors’ directions.
6. Whether the mother and father should be restrained from speaking negatively about each other, their families, and the foster carers in the child’s presence.
7. Whether the New South Wales Minister for Community Services must notify the mother and father of any proposed change in the foster family in which the child resides.
8. Whether the parties should have liberty to provide copies of the single expert’s report to their counsellors or any agency involved in the child’s care.
9. Whether the particulars of the obligations created by these orders and the consequences of contravening these orders should be set out in a Fact Sheet attached to the orders.
10. Whether any person who issued subpoena for the production of documents should return them to their owner.
11. Whether all outstanding applications should be dismissed.

Held
1. The court held that all prior orders made pursuant to the Family Law Act 1975 in relation to the child are discharged. Result: Discharge of all prior orders.
2. The court held that the New South Wales Minister for Community Services has sole parental responsibility for the child until the child attains the age of 18 years. Result: Sole parental responsibility awarded to the Minister.
3. The court held that the child shall spend time with the mother under supervision, with specific conditions regarding the frequency and duration of visits. Result: Supervised visitation allowed with outlined conditions.
4. The court held that the child shall spend time with the father under supervision, with specific conditions regarding the frequency and duration of visits. Result: Supervised visitation allowed with outlined conditions.
5. The court held that supervisors have the authority to suspend the child’s visits if either parent appears drug affected or fails to abide by the supervisors’ directions. Result: Authority to suspend visitation granted.
6. The court held that the mother and father are restrained from speaking negatively about each other, their families, and the foster carers in the child’s presence. Result: Restraining order issued.
7. The court held that the New South Wales Minister for Community Services must notify the mother and father of any proposed change in the foster family in which the child resides. Result: Notification requirement imposed.
8. The court held that the parties have the liberty to provide copies of the single expert’s report to their counsellors or any agency involved in the child’s care. Result: Liberty granted for distribution of expert’s report.
9. The court held that the particulars of the obligations created by these orders and the consequences of contravening these orders should be set out in a Fact Sheet attached to the orders. Result: Fact Sheet requirement imposed.
10. The court held that any person who issued subpoena for the production of documents shall return them to their owner. Result: Return of documents ordered.
11. The court held that all outstanding applications are dismissed. Result: All outstanding applications dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Seldon and Denny and Anor, the court addressed several critical issues pertaining to the welfare of a child born in December 2007, referred to as "the child." The overarching principle guiding the court’s reasoning was the paramount consideration of the child's best interests, as enshrined in the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). The court first addressed the question of whether all prior orders should be discharged. It concluded that discharging these orders was necessary to ensure a fresh approach that aligned more closely with the child's current needs and circumstances. This decision underscores the flexibility inherent in family law to adapt orders as a child's situation evolves.

The court then considered whether the New South Wales Minister for Community Services should be granted sole parental responsibility for the child until the child reaches 18 years of age. This decision was based on the child's history of instability and the need for a stable and authoritative figure to make decisions in the child's best interests. The court relied on the precedent that the welfare of the child is the paramount consideration, as per s 60CC of the Family Law Act 1975, to justify this significant shift in responsibility.

In addressing the issue of supervised visitation, the court determined that both the mother and the father should be allowed supervised visits with the child. The rationale was rooted in the importance of maintaining parental bonds, provided they do not pose a risk to the child's welfare. The court ordered that visits occur at specified intervals and under the supervision of an officer or delegate of the Director General, ensuring that any potential risks could be mitigated. This aligns with the principle in s 60CC(3) of the Family Law Act 1975, which emphasizes the need to protect the child from harm while preserving the opportunity for meaningful relationships with both parents.

The court also ruled that supervisors should have the authority to suspend visits if either parent appears drug affected or fails to comply with the supervisors' reasonable directions. This decision was grounded in the necessity to protect the child from exposure to harmful situations. The court drew on the authority of s 65DA(2) of the Family Law Act 1975, which allows for the imposition of conditions that safeguard the child's welfare during contact arrangements.

Regarding the prohibition on negative speech, the court imposed a restraint on both parents from speaking negatively about each other, their families, and the foster carers in the child’s presence. This decision aimed to shield the child from the adverse effects of parental conflict. The court referenced the principle in s 60CC(3)(f) of the Family Law Act 1975, which highlights the importance of protecting the child from being exposed to harmful family dynamics.

The court further directed that the New South Wales Minister for Community Services must notify the parents of any proposed changes in the foster family in which the child resides. This decision was based on the need for transparency and stability in the child's living arrangements, ensuring that parents are kept informed and can provide necessary support. The court supported this with the overarching principle of promoting the child’s welfare and stability.

In relation to the provision of expert reports, the court allowed the parties to share copies of the single expert's report with their counsellors or any agency involved in the child’s care. This decision was intended to facilitate better support and care for the child by ensuring that all parties involved in the child’s welfare have access to relevant expert advice. The court referred to s 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975, which allows for the disclosure of information where it is in the child's best interests.

The court mandated that a Fact Sheet detailing the obligations and consequences of contravening the orders be attached to the orders themselves. This decision aimed to ensure clarity and accountability for all parties involved. The court referenced s 65DA(2) and s 62B of the Family Law Act 1975 to support the inclusion of this Fact Sheet as part of the orders.

The court also ordered that any person who issued subpoenas for the production of documents should return those documents to their owner. This decision was aimed at respecting the rights of the parties and ensuring that documents are not unduly withheld. The court did not cite specific statutory provisions for this order but implied it was necessary to maintain procedural fairness.

Lastly, the court dismissed all outstanding applications, reflecting its comprehensive consideration of the child's welfare in the orders already made. The court’s overarching principle in reaching this decision was to avoid unnecessary complexity and to ensure that the orders were focused on the child's immediate and future needs.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in family law matters, particularly those involving the welfare of a child, the court must prioritize the child's best interests, adapt orders to current circumstances, and ensure that all decisions are transparent, protective, and supportive of the child's welfare. The court departed from prior authority by granting sole parental responsibility to the Minister for Community Services, a significant shift that underscores the flexibility and adaptability required in family law proceedings.