SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | R v Cunningham (No 2) |
Citation: | [2021] ACTSC 325 |
Hearing Dates: | 22 and 23 November 2021 |
DecisionDate: | 24 November 2021 |
Before: | Mossop J |
Decision: | See [34] |
Catchwords: | CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – Admissibility of photo identification evidence – whether photo board identification by two witnesses is admissible – where police conducted the photo board procedures in breach of s 235 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) – consideration of s 138 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) – consideration of probative value of evidence – desirability of admitting the evidence not outweighed by the undesirability of admitting evidence obtained in the way in which the evidence was obtained – photo board evidence not admissible |
Legislation Cited: | Crimes Act 1900 (ACT), ss 233, 235 Evidence Act 2011 (ACT), s 138 |
Cases Cited: | |
Parties: | The Queen ( Crown) Christopher Cunningham ( Accused) |
Representation: | Counsel M Dyason ( Crown) M Jones SC ( Accused) |
| Solicitors ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown) O’Connor Harris ( Accused) | |
File Numbers: | SCC 214 of 2019 SCC 270 of 2019 |
MOSSOP J:
Introduction
This is a ruling in relation to the admissibility of photo identification evidence that would be given by Mr Dimitrov. I have been asked to rule on the admissibility of that photo board evidence. In this case, the incident occurred on 2 March 2019. The accused was arrested on 1 May 2019.
Statutory provisions
The relevant statutory provisions are ss 233 and 235 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) and s 138 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT). Sections 233 and 235 are as follows:
233 Identification parades—general
(1)This section applies to identification parades held in relation to offences.
(2)Subject to subsection (3) and to section 234, an identification parade—
(a) may be held if the suspect agrees; or
(b) shall be held if—
(i) the suspect has requested that an identification parade be held; and
(ii) it is reasonable in the circumstances to do so.
(3)An identification parade shall not be held unless the suspect has been informed that—
(a) he or she is entitled to refuse to take part in the parade; and
(b) if he or she refuses to take part in the parade without reasonable excuse, evidence of that refusal and of any identification of the suspect by a witness as a result of having seen a photograph or of having seen the suspect otherwise than during an identification parade may be given in any subsequent proceedings in relation to an offence; and
(c) in addition to any requirement under section 234, a legal representative or other person of the suspect’s choice may be present while the person is deciding whether to take part in the parade, and during the holding of the parade, if arrangements for that person to be present can be made within a reasonable time.
(4)The giving of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Cunningham (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] ACTSC 325
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the accused was "otherwise available" as defined by the statutory provisions, and the decision to forgo an identification parade was not justified under the circumstances. While the evidence had significant probative value and was crucial to the case, the court emphasised the importance of adhering to legislative mandates designed to protect the rights of the accused. The decision-making process behind opting for a photo board instead of an identification parade was unclear and suggested a misunderstanding of the legislative obligations. The court concluded that the desirability of admitting the photo board evidence did not outweigh the undesirability of admitting evidence obtained in breach of the statutory requirements. Consequently, the court ruled that the photo board identification evidence was inadmissible in the proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The material facts begin with the Crown's concession that there was a breach of section 235 of the Crimes Act. The accused was available for an identification parade as he was reporting to police weekly from 11 March 2019, and police were aware of his residence, workplace, and contact details. Despite this, the witnesses had significant safety concerns, which influenced the decision to proceed with a photo board instead of an identification parade. The decision to forgo the identification parade was reportedly influenced by the witnesses' fear of potential repercussions if they identified the accused.
The photo board identification occurred at approximately midnight on 30 April 2019 at Mr Dimitrov's house. The evidence regarding the timing and rationale behind the decision not to conduct an identification parade was contested. It was suggested that the decision was made by "Major Crime," but the exact process and reasoning were unclear. There was evidence that Sergeant Innes had reopened the possibility of an identification parade shortly before the photo board identification took place. The witnesses' safety concerns were significant, but it was not established that the risk was so immediate and severe as to make an identification parade unreasonable.
The probative value of the photo board identification was considered high, given Mr Dimitrov's substantial time spent with the offender. The significance of the identification evidence in the proceeding was noted, as it was a crucial piece of evidence in identifying the accused. The nature of the offences and the proceeding were serious, and the contravention of the legislative requirement was clear but not deliberate or reckless. The difficulty of obtaining the evidence without breaching the law was deemed minimal, as the accused was on bail and regularly reporting to police.
The decision ultimately focused on the importance of ensuring police compliance with legislative requirements for identification procedures. The evidence suggested institutional incentives to favour more flexible methods of identification over the more cumbersome identification parades. The court concluded that the desirability of admitting the evidence did not outweigh the undesirability of admitting evidence obtained in breach of the statutory requirements, leading to the ruling that the photo board identification evidence was inadmissible.
The matter R v Cunningham (No 2) came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory for a ruling on the admissibility of photo identification evidence in relation to the accused, Christopher Cunningham. The case was presided over by Mossop J, with the hearing dates set for 22 and 23 November 2021, and the decision handed down on 24 November 2021. This case followed a prior decision R v Cunningham [2020] ACTSC 269, which dealt with a similar issue regarding the admissibility of photo identification evidence. The current proceedings involved a challenge to the admissibility of photo board evidence obtained in breach of s 235 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT). The Crown conceded that there had been a breach of the statutory requirement, which mandates that an identification parade should be held unless certain conditions are met. The primary consideration in determining the admissibility of the photo board evidence was under s 138 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT). The court had to weigh various factors, including the probative value of the evidence, its importance in the proceedings, and the nature of the contravention, against the desirability of upholding the legislative preference for identification parades. Ultimately, Mossop J ruled that the desirability of admitting the evidence did not outweigh the undesirability of admitting evidence obtained in breach of the statutory requirement, thereby deeming the photo board evidence inadmissible.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the photo board identification by Mr Dimitrov is admissible given the police breached s 235 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) by not conducting an identification parade when the accused was otherwise available.
2. If s 235 was breached, whether the probative value of the photo board evidence outweighs the undesirability of admitting evidence obtained in breach of the statute under s 138(3) of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT).
3. Whether the contravention of s 235 was deliberate or reckless, or based on a misapprehension of the law.
4. Whether the contravention of s 235 was contrary to or inconsistent with a right recognised by the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
5. Whether the contravention was such that other proceedings have been or are likely to be taken in relation to it.
6. Whether it would have been difficult to obtain the evidence without contravening s 235.
Held
1. Whether the photo board identification by Mr Dimitrov is admissible given the police breached s 235 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) by not conducting an identification parade when the accused was otherwise available. The photo board identification by Mr Dimitrov is not admissible.
2. If s 235 was breached, whether the probative value of the photo board evidence outweighs the undesirability of admitting evidence obtained in breach of the statute under s 138(3) of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT). The desirability of admitting the evidence does not outweigh the undesirability of admitting the evidence obtained in the way in which it was obtained.
3. Whether the contravention of s 235 was deliberate or reckless, or based on a misapprehension of the law. The contravention was based upon a misapprehension of the strength of the obligation in s 235 of the Crimes Act.
4. Whether the contravention of s 235 was contrary to or inconsistent with a right recognised by the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. No particular right under the ICCPR was pointed to as having been contravened.
5. Whether the contravention was such that other proceedings have been or are likely to be taken in relation to it. There are no other proceedings that have been or will be taken in relation to the contravention.
6. Whether it would have been difficult to obtain the evidence without contravening s 235. It would not have been difficult to obtain the evidence without the contravention of an Australian law.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In this case, the court had to determine whether the photo board identification by Mr. Dimitrov was admissible, despite the police breaching s 235 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) by not conducting an identification parade when the accused was otherwise available. The court considered the probative value of the photo board evidence, whether the contravention of s 235 was deliberate or reckless, and if it was contrary to or inconsistent with a right recognised by the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. The court also assessed if other proceedings had been or were likely to be taken in relation to the contravention and whether it would have been difficult to obtain the evidence without contravening s 235.
The court found that the probative value of the photo board evidence was high, but the desirability of admitting the evidence did not outweigh the undesirability of admitting evidence obtained in breach of s 235. The contravention was characterised as based on a misapprehension of the strength of the obligation in s 235 of the Crimes Act and institutional incentives to favour the use of convenient and flexible methods of identification. No particular right under the ICCPR was pointed to as having been contravened. There were no other proceedings that had been or would be taken in relation to the contravention, and it would not have been difficult to obtain the evidence without contravening s 235.
The court concluded that the Crown had not discharged the persuasive burden that the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighed the undesirability of admitting the evidence obtained in the way it was obtained. Therefore, the evidence of the photo board identification of the accused by Mr. Dimitrov was not admissible in the proceedings.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the desirability of admitting evidence obtained in breach of s 235 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) does not outweigh the undesirability of admitting such evidence, even if the evidence has high probative value. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring significant incentives for police to comply with clearly expressed legislative requirements, in this case the preference for conducting identification parades.