R v Brp (No. 2)rst Rc No. DCCRM-02-627

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

R v BRP (No. 2)
[2003] SADC 50

Judge Bishop

Criminal

Reasons for Ruling

In reasons delivered on 24 March 2003 (R v BRP [2003] SADC 47), I ruled that three separate trials be held in relation to ten offences of a sexual nature alleged in an information presented against the accused. Thereupon the Crown elected first to proceed with joint trial of the offences alleged in counts 1 and 10 of the information. Before empanelment of a jury, Mr Kane, counsel for the accused, made application that the video record of interview of the accused by Senior Constable Lengyel conducted on 21 December 2001 be excluded from evidence. There ensued a voir dire enquiry during which oral and documentary evidence was presented from five police officers.  Upon that enquiry, the following position emerged.

About 3.50 a.m. on Friday 21 December 2001, uniformed police officers attended at a Craigmore residence in relation to a potentially violent domestic disturbance in which the accused had been threatened with a knife by his de facto spouse (O).  When she was being detained and taken from the premises, the police officer in charge, Sergeant McCue, heard O refer to the accused as a rock spider, which is a slang expression for a paedophile.  About 4.50 a.m., Constable McFadyen was asked by Mc Cue to take O’s two children to the house of O’s sister and enquire of the elder, nine years old child whether she knew anything of that expression.  Upon that enquiry, the child (who is here the complainant) told McFadyen that the accused had that night (for the first time) made her “lick his willy” and that her mother had then entered the room.  When Constable McFadyen returned to the Elizabeth Police Station soon after 5.00 a.m., she told McCue of what the complainant had told her.

Meanwhile, Constable Andrews (who had also attended at the Craigmore residence and assisted in apprehending O) took the accused to the police station for the purpose of obtaining from him a statement about what had occurred that night. (She had not heard him being referred to as a rock spider.)  About 5.10 a.m., Andrews began taking a statement from the accused.  About 5.40 a.m., the accused told her that the complainant had grabbed and begun stroking his penis.  Perceiving that the statement was moving in an unanticipated direction, Andrews left the interview room and spoke with McCue about what she had been told by the accused.  McCue was told that the complainant had stroked the accused’s penis.  (He had previously been told by McFadyen that the complainant had said that the accused had made her lick his penis.)  After discussing the position with McCue, Andrews returned to the interview room and, without administering to him a caution, continued taking the accused’s statement.

About 7.00 a.m. that morning, when CIB officers commenced duty, Andrews again paused in taking the accused’s statement and spoke with McCue, Detective Bavey and Senior Constable Lengyel about…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Brp (No. 2)rst Rc No. DCCRM-02-627 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v BRP (No. 2), the defendant faced allegations of ten sexual offences. The court was required to determine the admissibility of the video record of an interview conducted by Senior Constable Lengyel, following an earlier uncautioned interview with Constable Andrews. The Crown sought to introduce the video record as evidence, but the defence moved to exclude it, arguing that it was tainted by the failure to administer a caution during the initial interview.

The court examined the circumstances surrounding the two interviews, particularly focusing on the legal requirement to caution suspects when a reasonable suspicion of an offence arises. The court found that Constable Andrews should have cautioned the accused during the initial interview, which did not occur. This omission, coupled with the failure to comply with statutory recording requirements, compromised the integrity of the initial statement. The subsequent video interview, conducted by Senior Constable Lengyel, was inextricably linked to the tainted initial interview, as Lengyel alluded to the earlier admissions during the cautioning process.

Given these findings, the court ruled that both the initial uncautioned interview and the subsequent video interview were inadmissible. The court emphasised the importance of procedural fairness and the need to protect the rights of the accused. The ruling was based on common law principles, though the court noted that the statutory provisions would have led to the same conclusion. The court exercised its discretion under section 74G(b) of the Summary Offences Act to exclude the video record, ensuring that the interests of justice were upheld by preventing the use of tainted evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.