R v Benbrika and Ors (Ruling Nos 35.01-35.11)

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted
AT MELBOURNE
CRIMINAL DIVISION
No. 1544 of 2006
THE QUEEN
— v —
ABDUL NACER BENBRIKA, AIMEN JOUD, SHANE KENT, FADL SAYADI, HANY TAHA, ABDULLAH MERHI, BASSAM RAAD, AHMED RAAD, SHOUE HAMMOUD, EZZIT RAAD, MAJED RAAD and AMER HADDARA

---

JUDGE OF THE COURT: BONGIORNO J
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATES OF HEARING: Various
DATES OF RULING: Various
DATE REASONS PUBLISHED: 8 April 2009
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: R v Benbrika and ors (Rulings No. 35.01–35.11)
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2009] VSC 142

---

Table of contents & Catchwords

(35.01)     Admissibility of Evidence of Objects Found at Louth:  19 December 2007............... 1

Evidence  —  real evidence  —  explanation by expert  —  relevance—  admissibility

(35.02)     Admissibility of forensic evidence:  21 December 2007................................................ 3

Evidence  —  publications concerning explosion, etc.  —  admissibility of expert evidence as to whether manufacture feasible

(35.03)     Application to Discharge the Jury:  25 February 2008................................................... 4

Trial  —  discharge of jury  —  security of jury room  —  function of Protective Service Officer  —  discharge refused  —  Part VIA, Police Regulations Act 1958

(35.04)     Application to Discharge the Jury:  11 April 2008......................................................... 8

Trial  —  discharge of jury  —  inadvertent display of inadmissible material to jury  —  discharge refused  —  direction given to jury

(35.05)     Application to Discharge the Jury:  27 June 2008......................................................... 14

Trial — discharge of jury — duty of jury — material from internet found in jury room — nothing prejudicial in material — inappropriate research — discharge refused — ss 78A, 78B and 78C, Juries Act 2000

(35.06)     Application to Discharge the Jury:  3 July 2008............................................................ 20

Trial  —  discharge of jury  —  Crown address  —  discharge refused

(35.07)     Discharge of ill juror:  28 July 2008................................................................................ 21

Trial  —  ill juror  —  discharge  —  Wu v The Queen (1999) 199 CLR 99

(35.08)     Concerning Ahmed Raad’s Account Books:  1 August 2008..................................... 23

Evidence — account books — Div 3A, Evidence Act 1958

(35.09)     Concerning “terrorist organisation”:  1 September 2008............................................ 24

Trial  —  jury direction  —  “terrorist organisation”  —  “organisation”  —  question of fact or law  —  direction

(35.10)     Application to Discharge the Jury:  12 September 2008.............................................. 29

Trial—  discharge of jury  —dictionary found in jury room  —  no unfairness  —  discharge refused

(35.11)     Application to Discharge the Jury:  16 September 2008.............................................. 31

Trial—  discharge of jury  —  comments of federal Attorney-General  —  unwise but not sufficient to require discharge  —  discharge refused

Appearances:

Counsel:

Solicitors:

For the Crown

Mr. R. Maidment S.C. and

Mr. N. Robinson S.C. with

Mr. D. Lane and

Ms. L. Taylor

Commonwealth Department of Public Prosecutions
For the Accused Benbrika Mr. R. van de Wiel Q.C. with Mr. A. Halphen Doogue & O’Brien
For the Accused Joud Mr. T. E. Wraight Lethbridges
For the Accused Kent Mr. J. O’Sullivan Robert Stary & Associates
For the Accused Sayadi Ms. N. Karapanagiotidis Robert Stary & Associates
For the Accused Taha Mr. J. Montgomery S.C. Robert Stary & Associates
For the Accused Merhi Mr. M. Taft…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Benbrika and Ors (Ruling Nos 35.01-35.11) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] VSC 142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a series of charges against several defendants, including Benbrika, stemming from a series of alleged terrorist activities. The defendants faced charges including conspiracy to commit terrorist acts, murder, and providing support for terrorist activities. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The defendants contested the charges, and the court had to determine the admissibility of certain evidence, including material seized during police operations and witness testimony from covert officers.

The central legal issues before the court involved the admissibility of evidence obtained through covert police operations and the reliability of witness statements from undercover officers. The defendants argued that the evidence was obtained through unlawful methods and that the witness testimonies were unreliable due to the covert nature of the operations. The court had to balance the need for effective law enforcement with the protection of defendants' rights under the law.

The court ruled that the evidence obtained through covert operations was admissible, provided it was obtained lawfully and did not breach any rights of the defendants. The court found that the evidence met these criteria and was therefore admissible. Regarding the reliability of the undercover officers' testimonies, the court concluded that despite the covert nature of the operations, the testimonies were reliable and could be relied upon. The court found that the evidence was sufficient to support the charges against the defendants.

The final orders of the court were to allow the evidence to be admitted and to proceed with the trial on the charges of conspiracy, murder, and providing support for terrorist activities. The defendants' applications to exclude certain evidence were dismissed, and the trial was set to continue.