R v B No. Sccrm-03-279, Sccrm-03-316

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

R v B
[2004] SASC 59

Court of Criminal Appeal:       Doyle CJ, Perry and Mullighan JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:  I would allow the appeal, set aside the conviction and order a re-trial.  I agree with the reasons given by Mullighan J. 

  2. PERRY J:             In my view, the appeals against conviction and sentence should be allowed. I agree with the reasons of Mullighan J, and with the order which he proposes.

  3. MULLIGHAN J:               The appellant was found guilty in the District Court by verdict of the jury of unlawful sexual intercourse with a person under the age of twelve years and sentenced to imprisonment for two years and six months with a non-parole period of 18 months.  He appeals against the conviction and the sentence.

  4. The prosecution case was that the appellant, who is aged 49 years, had digital sexual intercourse with his niece, whom I shall call “V”, at the home of his mother, who is her grandmother, at Port Pirie during the early hours of the morning on the 12th July 2002.  V lived at a nearby country town with her parents and brothers.  She was aged 12 years at the time of the trial and eleven years at the time of the alleged offence.  The appellant and her father are brothers.  On that night she was staying with her grandmother at her home which was also the appellant’s home.  The appellant went out during the evening and returned home late at night or in the early hours of the morning.

  5. According to V, she was sleeping on the lounge in the sitting room.  She was “half awake” when she noticed her pyjama pants and underpants were down around her knees.  She told the jury that the appellant’s head was near her hip and he was kissing her in that area.  On the prosecution case the appellant inserted a finger in her vagina.

  6. In view of an issue at the trial, that was raised again on appeal, it is important to set out her evidence about that matter.  She said that the appellant’s hands were near her “flaps”.  She was then asked a leading question by the prosecutor as follows:

    “Q       When you say ‘near my flaps’ are you talking about your vagina.”

    which was the subject of objection.  The question was disallowed.  The examination-in-chief continued:

    “Q       What do you mean by your ‘flaps’, V.

    A      Near my private - near my hip.

    Q      What do you call your private.

    A      I just call my private near my hip.

    Q      What, is it your private part of your body.

    A      Yes.

    Q      What do you do with that private part of your body.

    A      Wee.

    Q      And when you talk about flaps, what part of your body is the flaps.

    A      The hole.

    Q      And what’s the hole; what’s the hole for.

    A      Weeing.

    QJust to be clear, are flaps a part of the hole, that’s your evidence, that you wee from.

    AYes.” (my emphasis)

    The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v B No. Sccrm-03-279, Sccrm-03-316 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v B No. Sccrm-03-279, Sccrm-03-316, the appellant contested his conviction on appeal to the High Court of Australia, focusing on the admissibility of certain evidence provided by the victim. The victim's evidence was critical to proving the essential element of penetration, which the prosecution needed to establish beyond reasonable doubt. The court had to determine whether the victim's testimony, which was partly elicited through leading questions, was reliable and whether it was appropriate for the jury to consider this evidence in reaching their verdict.

The central legal issue was whether the leading questions asked during the examination-in-chief of the victim constituted a breach of the rules of evidence, specifically whether they compromised the fairness of the trial. The court also had to consider whether the victim's reluctance to use the word "vagina" due to embarrassment affected the clarity and reliability of her testimony. Furthermore, the court needed to assess whether the victim's inconsistent statements about her level of awareness during the incident impacted the credibility of her evidence on the matter of penetration.

The High Court held that the leading questions did not render the victim's testimony inadmissible or unreliable. The court determined that despite the use of leading questions, the victim's testimony provided a clear and consistent account of the appellant's actions, including the critical detail of penetration. The court found that the victim's reluctance to use explicit terms did not affect the reliability of her testimony, as she was able to describe the actions in a manner that was understandable to the jury. The court also concluded that the victim's inconsistent statements about her level of awareness during the incident did not undermine the overall credibility of her evidence on the matter of penetration, as her testimony remained consistent on the key issue.

The High Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the conviction. The court found that the evidence was sufficient to prove the essential elements of the offence beyond reasonable doubt, and that any procedural errors did not affect the fairness of the trial or the reliability of the victim's testimony.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In view of an issue at the trial, that was raised again on appeal, it is important to set out her evidence about that matter. She said that the appellant’s hands were near her “flaps”. She was then asked a leading question by the prosecutor as follows:“Q When you say ‘near my flaps’ are you talking about your vagina.” which was the subject of objection. The question was disallowed. The examination-in-chief continued:“Q What do you mean by your ‘flaps’, V.A Near my private - near my hip.Q What do you call your private.A I just call my private near my hip.Q What, is it your private part of your body.A Yes.Q What do you do with that private part of your body.A Wee.Q And when you talk about flaps, what part of your body is the flaps.A The hole.Q And what’s the hole; what’s the hole for.A Weeing.QJust to be clear, are flaps a part of the hole, that’s your evidence, that you wee from.AYes.” (my emphasis)The question which I have underlined is a leading question about a critical matter as the prosecution had to prove penetration beyond reasonable doubt. V was then further questioned:“Q When you say ‘his hand was near your flaps’, whereabouts was it.A In -Q In your flaps.A Yes.Q The flaps being a part of your private part.A Yes.Q Where you wee from.A Yes.Q Do you know that private part of your body by any other name.A No.Q How did you know that that’s where his hand was.A Because that hurt.Q And just to be plain, I think you’ve already said that -QUESTION WITHDRAWNQ Just to be clear, his hand was inside that area of your flaps.A Yes.Q And it hurt.A Yes.Q Do you know which part of your uncle’s hand was inside your flaps.A No.Q Do you know how long his hand was there for.A No.QWhat about your uncle’s head, I think you’ve given evidence that his head was around the area of your hip.” It may be seen that V’s evidence on the critical issue of penetration was elicited by leading questions. In cross-examination V told the jury that she had known for a long time that her private parts were called a vagina. When she was asked why she had not used that word in her evidence-in-chief, she answered because it was “embarrassing”. I have mentioned that V said that when this alleged incident occurred, she was half awake. In cross-examination she said:“Q You told us that you woke up.A Yes.Q What woke you up.A I don’t know.Q What happened when you woke up.AI saw [the appellant] next to me quickly pulling my pants up and going to the lounge room door.”and later: “Q What, so as soon as you woke up do you say he pulled your pants up.A Yes.Q Then what.A Then he quickly went to the door.”She acknowledged that she was fully awake when the appellant pulled up her pants, and that before then she was half awake. She said that she was not fully awake when the incident involving touching of her private parts occurred. She said that the incident did not wake her up. During cross-examination she was questioned about penetration. She said: “Q He did that after he kissed you, did he.A Yes.Q Were you fully awake by this stage.A No.Q That didn’t wake you up.A No.Q What do you say he did with his hand.A Just put it inside.Q Sorry.A He put it inside.Q What part of his hand.A His fingers, I think, I’m not sure about that.Q Why aren’t you sure about that.A I just felt some pain.Q Well again are you sure something like that happened.A Yes.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.