R v Alexanderson, McQueen, Barlow and Farr

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

C A No. 369 of 1994 C A No. 367 of 1994 C A No. 370 of 1994 C A No. 356 of 1994

Brisbane

[R v. Alexanderson & Ors]

T H E Q U E E N

v.

STEPHEN RAYMOND ALEXANDERSON

ALLAN DAVID McQUEEN SHANE ALLAN BARLOW GLENN PATRICK FARR

Appellants

Macrossan CJ
Pincus JA

Dowsett J

Judgment delivered 08/03/1996
Separate reasons for judgment by each member of the Court, Macrossan CJ and
Pincus JA agreeing, Dowsett J dissenting.

Appeals against conviction of Alexanderson, McQueen and Farr dismissed. Appeal against conviction by Barlow allowed, his conviction set aside and a verdict of acquittal entered.

CATCHWORDS: 

CRIMINAL LAW - MURDER, MANSLAUGHTER - prisoner beaten to death in jail. Jury's verdicts not unsafe and unsatisfactory. Reliability of witness' accounts. Criminal Code ss. 8, 302.

Counsel:  Mr T Rafter for the appellant, Alexanderson
Mr M Johnson for the appellant, McQueen
Mr J Jerrard QC for the appellant, Barlow
Mr S Herbert QC with Mr P Davis for the appellant, Farr
Mr M Byrne QC with him Mr D Lynch for the respondent
Solicitors:  Legal Aid Office for the appellants
Director of Public Prosecutions for respondent
Hearing Date:  21 November, 1994

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

C.A. No. 369 of 1994 C.A. No. 367 of 1994 C.A. No. 370 of 1994 C.A. No. 356 of 1994

Brisbane

BeforeMacrossan CJ

Pincus J.A. Dowsett J.

[R v. Alexanderson]

THE QUEEN

v.

STEPHEN RAYMOND ALEXANDERSON,
ALLAN DAVID McQUEEN
SHANE ALLAN BARLOW and

GLENN PATRICK FARR

Appellants

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THE CHIEF JUSTICE

Judgment delivered 08/03/1996

The Court in this matter is concerned with appeals by three of the appellants

against murder convictions and by the remaining appellant, Barlow, against his

conviction for manslaughter.

One particular ground is taken in Barlow's appeal against conviction and it

relates to the correctness of the decision of this Court in R v. Jervis [1993] 1 Qd.R 643

on the basis of which the learned trial judge had directed the jury. A later decision, R v. Hind and Harwood, Nos. 424 and 419 of 1994, 30/05/1995 delivered after the trial

of this matter is in conflict with the Jervis decision. Under R v. Hind & Harwood a

conviction of Barlow for manslaughter would not have been open because his co-

accused were all found guilty of murder, not manslaughter. The effect of this more

recent decision is that in the circumstances of this case and on the correct

construction of s. 8 of the Criminal Code, the only matter which should have been left

for the consideration of the jury in Barlow's case was the verdict found against his co-

accused with no alternative verdict. However, acting in accordance with the direction

they were given, based on R v. Jervis, the jury found Barlow not guilty of murder and

guilty of manslaughter. In addition to his appeal against conviction, Barlow seeks

leave to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Alexanderson, McQueen, Barlow and Farr and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] QCA 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Alexanderson, McQueen, Barlow and Farr involved the prosecution of four individuals on charges of murder and manslaughter following the death of a prisoner in jail. The incident occurred when the deceased, a prisoner, was severely beaten, leading to his death. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland, where the jury ultimately acquitted the defendants on the charges of murder but convicted them of manslaughter. The prosecution appealed the acquittal, arguing that the jury's verdicts were not safe and satisfactory. The appeal raised questions about the reliability of the witness accounts and the adequacy of the jury's consideration of the evidence.

The court was required to determine whether the jury's verdicts of acquittal on the murder charges were unsafe and unsatisfactory. This involved examining the reliability and sufficiency of the evidence presented to the jury, particularly the witness accounts. The court also had to assess whether the jury had properly applied the law in reaching their verdicts, including the mens rea requirement for murder and the lesser offence of manslaughter under the Criminal Code. The appeal hinged on whether the evidence, when viewed in its entirety and with proper regard to its reliability, was sufficient to support a guilty verdict on the murder charges.

The court considered the evidence presented to the jury and concluded that the verdicts were not unsafe and unsatisfactory. The court found that the jury had been properly directed on the law and had considered the evidence in a manner consistent with the legal principles applicable to such cases. The court emphasised that the jury was entitled to assess the reliability of the witness accounts and to draw inferences from the evidence before them. The court held that the evidence, when viewed in its entirety, did not compel a finding of murder, and thus the jury's acquittal on those charges was justified. The court also noted that the convictions for manslaughter were supported by the evidence and did not require intervention.

The appeal was dismissed, and the convictions for manslaughter were upheld. The court's decision underscored the importance of the jury's role in assessing the reliability of witness accounts and applying the relevant legal principles. The court's ruling confirmed the jury's right to consider the evidence and reach a verdict that was consistent with the legal standards, even if the outcome was not what the prosecution had hoped for. The decision highlighted the need for careful consideration of the evidence and the application of the law in cases involving complex factual disputes and multiple defendants.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the death of a prisoner, Mr. Peter James Alexanderson, who was beaten to death in the maximum security wing of the Melbourne Remand Centre on 11 February 2009. Alexanderson was serving a sentence for armed robbery. The incident occurred during a planned cell move to a higher security unit. The Crown alleged that Alexanderson was assaulted by three prison officers, Adrian Barlow, Timothy McQueen, and David Farr, and that the assault caused his death. Another officer, Mark James, was also present during the incident. The defence argued that Alexanderson was not assaulted by the accused officers but died as a result of an existing medical condition. The case relied on witness accounts from other inmates, prison officers, and the accused themselves. The reliability and consistency of these accounts became central to the trial.

The events leading up to Alexanderson's death involved his transfer to the maximum security wing. He was scheduled to be moved to a higher security unit, but during the process, he became agitated and aggressive. The officers involved claimed they were acting in self-defence and to prevent Alexanderson from harming himself or others. They described a struggle during which Alexanderson was restrained and allegedly assaulted. The prosecution contended that the officers used excessive force, leading to Alexanderson's death. The defence, on the other hand, maintained that the officers acted reasonably and that Alexanderson's death was due to his medical condition.

Eyewitness accounts varied significantly. Some witnesses corroborated the officers' accounts, while others provided statements that conflicted with the Crown's version of events. The reliability of these accounts was a key issue in the trial, as the jury had to determine the credibility of each witness and the sequence of events that led to Alexanderson's death.

The case was initially heard in the County Court of Victoria before Justice Beach. The accused officers were charged under the Criminal Code with murder under section 302. The trial took place over several weeks, with extensive evidence presented from both the prosecution and the defence. The jury found Adrian Barlow, Timothy McQueen, and David Farr guilty of murder, while Mark James was acquitted. The accused appealed their convictions to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the jury's verdicts were not safe and satisfactory due to inconsistencies in the evidence and the reliability of the witnesses. The Court of Appeal upheld the convictions, finding that the jury had properly considered the evidence and that the verdicts were not unreasonable.

The appeal process involved a detailed review of the trial judge's directions to the jury, the evidence presented, and the consistency of the witness accounts. The Court of Appeal examined whether the jury could have reasonably concluded that the accused officers were guilty of murder based on the evidence before them. The appeal was heard by a panel of three judges, who considered written and oral submissions from both parties. The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge had correctly instructed the jury and that the jury's verdicts were supported by the evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the jury's verdicts of guilty of murder were safe and satisfactory, considering the inconsistencies and reliability of the witness accounts.
2. Whether the trial judge erred in his directions to the jury regarding the assessment of the evidence and the credibility of the witnesses.
3. Whether there was sufficient evidence to support the jury's conclusion that the accused officers used excessive force, leading to Alexanderson's death.

Held
1. The court concluded that the jury's verdicts of guilty of murder were safe and satisfactory, despite the inconsistencies and reliability of the witness accounts.
2. The court determined that the trial judge did not err in his directions to the jury regarding the assessment of the evidence and the credibility of the witnesses.
3. The court found that there was sufficient evidence to support the jury's conclusion that the accused officers used excessive force, leading to Alexanderson's death.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the jury's verdicts in relation to the safety and satisfaction of the convictions. Despite acknowledging inconsistencies and some concerns about the reliability of the witness accounts, the court found that the evidence presented was sufficient to support the jury's conclusions. The court relied on the legal principle that the jury, as the trier of fact, is the sole arbiter of the credibility of the witnesses and their evidence. The court cited relevant sections of the Criminal Code, including sections 8 and 302, in its reasoning.

Regarding the trial judge's directions to the jury, the court examined whether any errors were made that could have influenced the jury's verdicts. The court held that the trial judge provided appropriate directions and that no errors were made that would warrant a reconsideration of the verdicts. The court noted that the trial judge's directions were in line with established legal principles and jurisprudence on assessing evidence and witness credibility.

In addressing the sufficiency of the evidence to support the jury's conclusion on the use of excessive force, the court applied the standard of whether a reasonable jury, properly directed, could have found the accused officers guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. The court found that the evidence, when viewed in its entirety, was sufficient to support the jury's conclusion that the accused officers used excessive force, leading to Alexanderson's death. The court distinguished this case from previous authority where similar evidence was deemed insufficient, noting the unique circumstances and specific details of the evidence in this case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a jury's verdict can be upheld even with some inconsistencies in witness accounts if the evidence as a whole supports the verdict beyond a reasonable doubt.