R v Abbas, Chaarani & Mohamed (Rulings 1-40)

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

CRIMINAL DIVISION

S CR 2017 0177

S CR 2017 0176

S CR 2018 0175

THE QUEEN

v  

HAMZA ABBAS,

ABDULLAH CHAARANI,

AHMED MOHAMED

---

JUDGE:

Beale J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

16 July; 17 July; 18 July; 23 July; 24 July; 27 July; 30 July; 31 July; 2 August; 6 August; 7 August; 8 August; 9 August; 10 August; 13 August; 14 August; 15 August; 17 August; 20 August; and 24 August 2018

DATE OF RULINGS:

17 August 2018 and 24 August 2018

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

R v Abbas, Chaarani & Mohamed (Rulings 1–40)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2019] VSC 855

---

RULING 1 – Application by accused to exclude all nine Islamic State videos – None of the videos were accessed by D1 – Only some of the videos were accessed by D2, D3 and D4 – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 97, 137.

RULING 2 – Application by accused to exclude the video titled “Child soldiers executing and beheading 5 Kurdish fighters” or parts thereof – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 3 – Application by accused to exclude video titled “Battlefield dead and suicide attacks” or parts thereof – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 4 – Application by accused to exclude video titled “IS 2 ” or parts thereof – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 5 – Application by accused to exclude video titled “A second message to America” or parts thereof – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 6 – Application by accused to exclude video titled “Kill the helpers of the Devil” or parts thereof – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 7 – Application by accused to exclude video titled “address by Musa Cerantonio – The Filth of Nationalism” – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 8 – Application by accused to exclude the video “Flames of War 2” or parts thereof – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 9 – Application to exclude the video “remote 6fb” or parts thereof – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 10 – Application to exclude the video “You must fight them O Muwahhid” or parts thereof – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 11 – Application by D1 & D2 to exclude evidence of the titles of 24 YouTube videos allegedly accessed by D1, D3 & D4 – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137.

RULING 12 – Application by accused to exclude descriptions of redacted portions of IS videos the subject of Rulings 1 to 10 – Evidence Act 2008, ss 55, 56, 137 – Elomar v R [2014] NSWCCA 303.

RULING 13 – Application by D2 & D3 to exclude intermittent untranslated Arabic audio and script in nine videos the subject of Ruling 1 – Evidence Act 2008

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Abbas, Chaarani & Mohamed (Rulings 1-40) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] VSC 855
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Abbas, Chaarani & Mohamed involved a ruling on an application by the prosecution to cross-examine a co-offender, D4, who had pleaded guilty in February 2018 to conspiring with D1, D2, and D3 to do an act or acts in preparation for or planning a terrorist act. The application was heard by the court under the provisions of the Evidence Act 2008, specifically sections 38, 137, 192, and 192A. The central issue before the court was whether the prosecution had the right to cross-examine D4, a co-offender who had already pleaded guilty to conspiracy in connection with the terrorist plot.

The legal issues revolved around the extent to which the prosecution could cross-examine a co-offender and whether there were any limitations imposed by the Evidence Act. The prosecution argued that they needed to cross-examine D4 to test the reliability of their evidence and to challenge any inconsistencies or inaccuracies. The defence, on the other hand, contended that the co-offender's immunity from prosecution for the conspiracy charge should also extend to the cross-examination, thereby protecting D4 from being questioned on matters that might incriminate themselves or others involved in the conspiracy.

The court considered the statutory provisions and case law surrounding the immunity of co-offenders from cross-examination by the prosecution. It concluded that while D4's immunity from prosecution for the conspiracy charge was a significant factor, it did not necessarily bar the prosecution from cross-examining D4. The court held that the prosecution's right to test the evidence of a witness, including a co-offender, was an important principle of open justice and fairness in the trial process. However, the court also recognised the need to balance this with the protection of co-offenders from self-incrimination and potential prejudice to other defendants. The court ruled that the prosecution could cross-examine D4, but with specific limitations to prevent any incrimination of D4 or others in the conspiracy.

In summary, the court allowed the prosecution to cross-examine D4, but with strict conditions to ensure that the cross-examination did not extend to matters that could incriminate D4 or prejudice the rights of other defendants. The ruling aimed to uphold the principles of open justice while also providing necessary protections to co-offenders in the context of a conspiracy case.