Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Roach (The Melbourne Quarter Case) (Ruling No 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Roach (The Melbourne Quarter Case) (Ruling No 1) [2021] FCA 1153

File number(s): VID 23 of 2021
Judgment of: WHEELAHAN J
Date of judgment: 23 September 2021
Catchwords: EVIDENCE – application for leave to cross-examine a witness under s 38(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – proper construction of “evidence given by a witness that is unfavourable to a party” – whether the court should follow the decision of the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett or an earlier first instance decision of the Federal Court of Australia – whether the construction of s 38(1)(a) in DPP v Garrett was obiter – held that the construction adopted in DPP v Garrett was ratio decidendi and that the court should follow the Victorian Court of Appeal – consideration of whether s 38(1)(a) is engaged – consideration of discretionary matters – leave given.
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 348, 349

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 38, 192

Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) s 192A

Cases cited:

Australian Securities Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Ltd (1993) 177 CLR 485

Australian Workers’ Union v Registered Organisations Commissioner (No 6) [2019] FCA 194

Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd v Donnelly (1998) 82 FCR 418

DPP v Garrett [2016] VSCA 31; 257 A Crim R 509

Hadgkiss v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2006] FCA 941; 152 FCR 560

Klewer v Walton [2003] NSWCA 308

Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Rush [2020] FCAFC 115; 380 ALR 432

R v Abbas [2019] VSC 855

R v Souleyman (1996) 40 NSWLR 712

Société d’Avances Commerciales (Société Anonyme Egyptienne) v Merchants’ Marine Insurance Co (The Palitana) (1924) 20 Ll L Rep 140

State Rail Authority of New South Wales v Earthline Constructions Pty Ltd [1999] HCA 3; 160 ALR 588

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 24
Date of hearing: 22 September 2021
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M Follett
Solicitor for the Applicant: Lander & Rogers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr P Boncardo with Ms E Beljic
Solicitor for the Respondents: CFMEU – Construction and General Division

 

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Ex tempore)

VID 23 of 2021
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER

Applicant

AND:

JASON ROACH

First Respondent

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MARITIME, MINING AND ENERGY UNION
Second Respondent

WHEELAHAN J:

  1. The applicant alleges that on 20 April 2020 the respondents contravened s 348 and s 349 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by words spoken by the first respondent, Mr Jason Roach, to two workers engaged by a sub-sub-subcontractor, Melbourne Caulking Pty Ltd (Melbourne Caulking), in a luncheon room at a building site in Melbourne. A primary question in issue is whether the first respondent spoke the words that are alleged.

  2. There is evidence that Melbourne Caulking had been engaged to work at the site by Geschke Pty Ltd (Geschke), which was a plumbing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Roach (T... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner versus Roach, also known as the Melbourne Quarter Case, the court was presented with a dispute that arose from allegations of misconduct in the building and construction industry. The Australian Building and Construction Commissioner sought leave to cross-examine a witness under section 38(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The core legal issue before the court was the proper interpretation of the phrase "evidence given by a witness that is unfavourable to a party" within the context of section 38(1)(a) of the Act. The court had to determine whether the interpretation provided by the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett or an earlier decision of the Federal Court of Australia should be followed. Furthermore, the court needed to consider whether the construction of section 38(1)(a) in DPP v Garrett was merely obiter or formed part of the ratio decidendi.

The court concluded that the interpretation provided by the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett was indeed the ratio decidendi and, therefore, binding. The court held that the construction of section 38(1)(a) as articulated in DPP v Garrett should be followed. This decision was made after carefully considering the language and context of the statute, as well as the legal principles that underpin the interpretation of statutes. The court also addressed the issue of whether section 38(1)(a) was engaged in the circumstances of the case, finding that it was. Additionally, the court examined the discretionary factors that it should consider in granting leave to cross-examine the witness, ultimately determining that leave should be granted.

In light of the above, the court made an order granting leave to cross-examine the witness as sought by the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner. This decision was a significant step in the ongoing proceedings, providing clarity on the interpretation of section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) and affirming the importance of following higher court decisions when determining the meaning of statutory provisions. The court's ruling will likely have implications for future cases involving the cross-examination of witnesses in similar circumstances.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application by the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (ABCC) for leave to cross-examine a witness under section 38(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The matter arises from the ABCC's investigation into alleged unlawful conduct by a company, Melbourne Quarter Pty Ltd, in relation to its employees' pay and conditions. The ABCC seeks to cross-examine the Managing Director of the company, who has provided evidence that is unfavourable to the ABCC. The evidence in question includes statements by the witness that suggest the company did not engage in unlawful conduct and that the ABCC's case is without merit. The witness has provided evidence that the company was compliant with relevant laws and that any discrepancies in employee pay were due to administrative errors.

The ABCC argues that the witness's evidence is unfavourable and that the court should grant leave to cross-examine the witness under section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act. The witness, however, opposes the application, contending that the evidence provided is not unfavourable and that the ABCC's case lacks merit. The witness further argues that the construction of section 38(1)(a) should follow an earlier decision of the Federal Court of Australia rather than the decision of the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for leave to cross-examine a witness under section 38(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The ABCC filed an application seeking leave to cross-examine the Managing Director of Melbourne Quarter Pty Ltd. The witness opposed the application. The case was heard by the Federal Court, which considered the arguments from both parties regarding the proper construction of section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act and whether it applies to the evidence provided by the witness. The court examined the relevant authorities, including the decision of the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett and an earlier decision of the Federal Court of Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the construction of "evidence given by a witness that is unfavourable to a party" in section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) should follow the decision of the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett or an earlier first instance decision of the Federal Court of Australia.
2. Whether the construction adopted in DPP v Garrett was ratio decidendi or obiter.
3. Whether section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act is engaged by the evidence given by the witness.
4. What discretionary matters should be considered in deciding whether to grant leave to cross-examine the witness.

Held
1. The court held that the construction adopted in the decision of the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett should be followed over an earlier first instance decision of the Federal Court of Australia in determining the meaning of "evidence given by a witness that is unfavourable to a party" in section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).
2. The court held that the construction of section 38(1)(a) in DPP v Garrett was ratio decidendi and not obiter.
3. The court held that section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act was engaged by the evidence given by the witness.
4. The court held that, in deciding whether to grant leave to cross-examine the witness, the discretionary matters to be considered included the nature and content of the evidence given, the importance of the evidence in the proceedings, and the potential prejudice to the witness.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the construction of the phrase "evidence given by a witness that is unfavourable to a party" in section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act. It compared the reasoning of the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett with an earlier first instance decision of the Federal Court of Australia. The court found that the reasoning in DPP v Garrett was clearer and more consistent with the statutory language and purpose, leading to the conclusion that the Victorian Court of Appeal's decision should be followed. The court held that the construction in DPP v Garrett was ratio decidendi, not obiter, as it was essential to the decision made by the court. Turning to whether section 38(1)(a) was engaged by the witness's evidence, the court found that the evidence was indeed unfavourable to the party and thus within the scope of the statutory provision. Finally, in considering the discretionary matters, the court emphasised the need to balance the statutory rights of the parties with the potential prejudice to the witness, ultimately granting leave to cross-examine. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in determining the proper construction of "evidence given by a witness that is unfavourable to a party" in section 38(1)(a) of the Evidence Act, the decision of the Victorian Court of Appeal in DPP v Garrett should be followed, and that the court must consider various discretionary factors when deciding whether to grant leave to cross-examine.