Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
There are screen shots of various conversations between the Other Party and Child A, and the Other Party and the Applicant, including those in which Child A is referred to not by his name but as “your son”.[30][30] Exhibit MC 3 to the Affidavit of the Other Party dated 7 August 2020; T documents at 71 and 317.Documentary evidence Both the Applicant and Other Party have provided calendars showing their versions of the nights which Child A has spent with each parent.[31][31] Calendars filed by the Applicant on 28 May 2020, 3 June 2020, 3 July 2020, 5 November 2020 and 20 November 2020. Calendars filed by the Other Party on 21 October 2020 and 25 November 2020. The calendars of the Applicant and Other Party from the weekend commencing 2 March 2019 until 31 December 2019 are not in agreement. There are two versions of a calendar submitted by the mother, each of which records Child A being in the care of his father for a total of 38 nights in this period.[32][32] Calendars filed by the Applicant on 20 November 2020. The father’s calendar shows that Child A was in his care for a total of 45 nights in that period.[33] Discrepancies between the Applicant’s and Other Party’s calendars occur in March, May, August and December. [33] Calendars filed by Other Party on 21 October 2020 and 25 November 2020; T documents at 224. There is a dispute as to two nights in May and in December. The father claims to have had care of Child A on 30 and 31 December whereas the mother asserts that Child A was with her as per the Federal Circuit Court’s order dated 20 February 2018 which provides that Child A be in her care “On New Year’s every year from 10:00am to 5.30pm on 30 December 2018 and each even year thereafter to 10.00 am 1 January”.[34][34] T documents at 176. In her written submission the Applicant states that “Dec 30th + 31st as per orders dated 20/2/2018 No: 2(b) HOME EACH YEAR”.[35][35] Calendars filed by the Applicant on 20 November 2020. However, it is clear that the order states “from … 5:30pm on 30 December 2018 and each even year thereafter to 10:00am 1 January”. Presumably this means that every year on 30 December, Child A is to spend that night with his mother and every even year he is to spend the night of 30 December as well as the night of 31 December (until 10:00am 1 January) with his mother. As 2019 was not an “even year” as provided by the order, at most, it can only be assumed that he spent the night of 30 December 2019 with his mother. It cannot be assumed that Child A was with his mother that year on the night of 31 December 2019. in the absence of any specific and corroborative evidence (other than the testimony of each parent) as to the location of Child A on 30 and 31 December 2019, the Tribunal is in no position to be definitive about the matter, other than to say that on the balance of probabilities Child A was with his father. Despite the existence and operation of the Court order, the Applicant’s own evidence filed with the Respondent for her objection application, as at 27 August 2019, anticipated that Child A would be in the care of the Other Party for a continuous holiday period from 23 December 2019 until 7 January 2020.[36] Furthermore, per the Applicant’s claims, Child A would have spent 23 December 2019 until 29 December 2019 with his father, 30 and 31 December with his mother, and then from 1 January 2020 would have been returned back for a resumed period with his father. The Tribunal is of the view that it is more likely than not that Child A spent a continuous holiday period with his father and such possibility is not so foreign. Although the February 2018 order was not yet in place, as per calendar evidence submitted by the Applicant, it indicates that Child A had previously spent a continuous period from approximately mid-December 2017 until early January 2018 in the care of the Other Party.[37][36] T documents at 190, 192 and 202-203.[37] Calendars filed by the Applicant on 3 July 2020.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Acts themselves are models of complexity, and rather than attempt to summarise the relevant provisions or to reproduced them in the Tribunal’s own terminology, the Tribunal will, with acknowledgment and gratitude, hereafter reproduce the outline of the legislative framework as set out in the Respondent’s submission:[11][11] Respondent’s SFIC at [14]-[27]. Footnotes and citations omitted. Emphasis in original.Jurisdiction and power14. The Tribunal has jurisdiction, pursuant to ss 4 and 96A(b) of the Collection Act, to review the AAT1’s decision. The review application was lodged within the 28-day period prescribed by s 29(2) of the AAT Act.15. On review, the Tribunal may affirm the AAT1’s decision if it considers it the correct and preferable decision. If the Tribunal sets aside the AAT1 decision, it would need to:a. First, make a determination, relevantly under ss 54F, 54G, or 54H of the Assessment Act, as to whether the existing care percentage determination must or should be revoked.b. Second, in the event the existing care percentage determination is revoked, make a new care percentage determination under ss 49 or 50 of the Assessment Act.Date of effect if Tribunal substitutes AAT1 decision16. In the event that the Tribunal decides to set aside the AAT1 decision and in its place makes a decision to vary or substitute the objection decision under review, s 95N of the Collection Act will be relevant. This is because the applicant applied to the AAT1 on 17 January 2020, being more than 28 days after notice was given of the objection decision made on 1 November 2019.17. Section 95N is in the following terms:Date of effect of AAT first review decision relating to care percentage decision(1) If:(a) on AAT first review, the AAT varies or substitutes a decision on an objection to a care percentage decision; and(b) the application for AAT first review was made more than 28 days, or, if the applicant is a resident of a reciprocating jurisdiction, 90 days, after notice of the decision was given; then, despite subsection 43(6) of the AAT Act, the decision as varied or substituted by the AAT has or is taken to have had effect on and from the day the application for AAT first review was made.(2) If the AAT is satisfied that there are special circumstances that prevented the application for AAT first review being made within the period referred to in paragraph (1)(b), the AAT may determine that subsection (1) applies as if:(a) for an applicant who is a resident of a reciprocating jurisdiction – the reference to 90 days in that paragraph were a reference to such longer period as the AAT determines to be appropriate; or(b) otherwise – the reference to 28 days in that paragraph were a reference to such longer period as the AAT determines to be appropriate.(3) The AAT must give written notice of a decision to make, or not to make, a determination under subsection (2) in relation to a person, to each person affected by the decision.Note: The AAT's decision about the determination is reviewable (see paragraph 96A(c)).The review is an AAT second review.18. Accordingly, s 95N of the Collection Act governs the date of effect of an AAT1 decision where a person has applied to the AAT1 more than 28 days after they received the objection decision and the AAT1 varies or sets aside that objection decision. In such situations, s 95N(1) operates so that the date of effect of the AAT1 decision will be the date of application to the AAT1. However, the AAT1 (or this Tribunal on review) can consider if special circumstances existed that prevented the application being made within time, pursuant to s 95N(2). If the Tribunal is satisfied that s 95N(2) is met, then it may treat the application to the AAT1 as having been made within time.Revocation of the existing care percentage determination19. The revocation of care percentage determinations is dealt with in Subdivision C of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act. As noted above, the relevant provisions are ss 54F, 54G and 54H.20. Sections 54F and 54G of the Assessment Act deal with circumstances in which a care percentage determination must be revoked. Section 54F of the Assessment Act provides:54F Determination must be revoked if there is a change to the responsible person’s cost percentage(1) The Registrar must revoke a determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care (the existing percentage of care) for a child made under section 49 or 50 if:(a) the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, that the care of the child that is actually taking place does not correspond with the responsible person’s existing percentage of care for the child; and(b) the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person’s cost percentage for the child would change if the Registrar were to determine, under section 49 or 50, another percentage to be the person’s percentage of care for the child; and(c) section 54G does not apply; and(d) subsection (2) applies in relation to the individual.(2) This subsection applies in relation to a responsible person if:(a) disregarding paragraph 53(1)(c), section 51 did not apply in relation to the responsible person; or(b) section 51 did apply in relation to the responsible person but the maximum interim period for the determination has ended; or(c) all of the following apply:(i) section 51 did apply in relation to the responsible person;(ii) the maximum interim period for an earlier determination of the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child has not ended;(iii) an interim period does not currently apply in relation to the earlier determination;(iv) the determination referred to in subsection (1) was made while the earlier determination was suspended under this Subdivision.(3) The revocation of the determination takes effect at the end of:(a) if the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, of the matter referred to in paragraph (1)(a) within 28 days after the change of care day for the responsible person – the day before the change of care day; or(b) if the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, of that matter more than 28 days after the change of care day for the responsible person and:(i) the responsible person’s care of the child has increased – the day before the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, of that matter; or(ii) the responsible person’s care of the child has reduced – the day before the change of care day.21. Section 54G of the Assessment Act is in the following terms:54G Determination must be revoked if there is less than regular care etc.(1) If:(a) a responsible person (the first responsible person) for a child was to have at least regular care of the child during a care period under a determination (the first care determination) made under section 50; and(b) the first responsible person has had no care of the child, or has had a pattern of care that is less than regular care of the child, despite another responsible person for the child making the child available to the first responsible person; and(c) a determination of the other responsible person’s percentage of care for the child has been made under section 50; and(d) the other responsible person notifies the Registrar or the Secretary of the matter referred to in paragraph (b) of this subsection within a period that the Registrar considers is reasonable in the circumstances;the Registrar must revoke both determinations.(2) The revocation of each determination takes effect:(a) if the first responsible person never established a pattern of care in accordance with the first care determination – at the beginning of the application day for that determination; or(b) if the first responsible person established a pattern of care in accordance with the first care determination but later ceased the established pattern of care – at the end of the day before the day on which the person ceased the previously established pattern of care.(3) To avoid doubt, a responsible person never establishes a pattern of care if:(a) the responsible person could not have established the pattern of care until a particular period that occurs later in a child support period; and(b) the responsible person does not establish that pattern during that particular period.22. Section 54H of the Assessment Act is concerned with situations in which a decision-maker may revoke a care percentage determination. Section 54H is in the following terms:54H Registrar may revoke a determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care(1) The Registrar may revoke a determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care (the existing percentage of care) for a child made under section 49 or 50 if:(a) the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, that the care of the child that is actually taking place does not correspond with the responsible person’s existing percentage of care for the child; and(b) the Registrar is satisfied that, if the Registrar were to determine, under section 49 or 50, another percentage to be the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child, the other percentage would not be the same as the person’s existing percentage of care for the child; and(c) sections 54F, 54FA and 54G do not apply; and(d) subsection (2) applies in relation to the individual.(2) This subsection applies in relation to a responsible person if:(a) disregarding paragraph 53(1)(c), section 51 did not apply in relation to the responsible person; or(b) section 51 did apply in relation to the responsible person but the maximum interim period for the determination has ended; or(c) all of the following apply:(i) section 51 did apply in relation to the responsible person;(ii) the maximum interim period for an earlier determination of the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child has not ended;(iii) an interim period for the earlier determination does not currently apply;(iv) the determination referred to in subsection (1) was made while the earlier determination was suspended under this Subdivision.(3) The revocation of the determination takes effect at the end of:(a) if the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, of the matter referred to in paragraph (1)(a) within 28 days after the change of care day for the responsible person – the day before the change of care day; or(b) if the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, of that matter more than 28 days after the change of care day for the responsible person and:(i) the responsible person’s care of the child has increased – the day before the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, of that matter; or (ii) the responsible person’s care of the child has reduced – the day before the change of care day.23. Section 54H can only apply if ss 54F and 54G do not apply: s 54H(1)(c) of the Assessment Act. Further, s 54F can only apply if s 54G does not apply: s 54F(1)(c). It is therefore appropriate for the Tribunal to first consider whether s 54G of the Assessment Act applies.24. With respect to s 54G of the Assessment Act and the question of whether a person who was to have at least regular care has had less than regular care or none at all, it should be noted that s 5(2) of the Assessment Act provides that a person will have “regular care” where that person’s “percentage of care for the child during a care period is at least 14% but less than 35%”: s 5(2).25. Care is not defined in either the Assessment Act or the Collection Act. The level of care provided by a person for a child is a question of fact to be determined in each case by reference to the particular facts and circumstances.26. The Guide[12] (at [2.2.1]) provides the following guidance for determining whether care exists:[12] Child Support Guide published by the Registrar to assist decision-makers.Determining whether care existsAn object of the CSA Act [i.e., Assessment Act] is 'that persons who provide ongoing daily care for children should be able to have the level of financial support to be provided for the children readily determined without the need to resort to court proceedings' (section 4(2)(c)). The CSA Act does not define the term 'ongoing daily care', however the Registrar will take into account a number of factors in determining whether a person cares for a child. In most cases, it will be relatively clear whether and to what extent a person is caring for a child. However, where there is doubt, the Registrar will consider whichever of the following are relevant to the particular case:·To what extent the person has control of the child, including having overall responsibility for the child and making:omajor decisions relating to who the child spends time with and the child's health, education, discipline, recreational and/or social activities, andoarrangements for others to meet the needs of the child (delegated care).·To what extent the person meets the needs of the child by providing the child with accommodation, clothing, food, child care, education, health care, emotional support, supervision, transport and extra-curricular activities.·To what extent the person pays for the costs of meeting the needs of the child.·To what extent the person otherwise provides financial support for the child.·To what extent the child provides for his or her own needs or has those needs met from another source.·To what extent the child is financially independent or financially supported from another source.27. In Polec & Staker[13] the Federal Magistrates Court held that in determining whether and to what extent a person has care of a child for the purpose of child support legislation, the following non-exhaustive list of factors may provide guidance:a. To what extent does the person meet the needs of the child by providing the child with accommodation, clothing, food, child care, education, health care, emotional support, supervision, transport and extracurricular activities?b. To what extent does the person make arrangements for others to meet the needs of the child?c. To what extent does the person pay for the costs of meeting the needs of the child?d. To what extent does the person otherwise provide financial support for the child?e. To what extent does the child provide for his or her own needs or have those needs met from another source?f. To what extent is the child financially independent or financially supported from another source?[13] Polec v Staker (SSAT Appeal) [2011] FMCAfam 959, [56].