NYVN and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

NYVN and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2023] AATA 249 (21 February 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/4276

Re:NYVN

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndMQJP

OTHER PARTY

Decision

Tribunal:Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Date:21 February 2023

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the AAT1 decision of 10 May 2022 and in substitution NYVN has 39% care of the children from 31 August 2021 and MQJP has 61% care of the children from 19 July 2021.

...........................[sgd].............................................

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Names used in all child support published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by sections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – review of care percentage determinations –change in care – actual care not varied from arrangements as provided for in Court orders – interpretation of the percentage of care in dispute – conflicting evidence of extent of impact of special days on actual care provided – decision under review set aside and substituted

Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Manifold and Manifold (Child support) [2019] AATA 1214
Peters and Child Support Registrar (Child support) [2019] AATA 5124
QXPD and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 318
Rainforth and Child Support Registrar (Child support) [2021] AATA 3851
Stone and Lamalfa (Child support) [2020] AATA
Ware and Ware (Child support) [2021] AATA 3607

Secondary Materials
Australian Law Reform Commission, Family Violence and Commonwealth Laws – Improving Legal Frameworks (Report No 117, February 2012)

Department of Social Services, Child Support Guide (Guides to Social Policy Laws, version 4.69, 6 February 2023)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

21 February 2023

  1. The Applicant, NYVN, is seeking a second-tier review by the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT2) of a decision by the Social Security and Child Support Division of this Tribunal (AAT1) of 10 May 2022. The AAT1 set aside the decision of the Child Support Agency (CSA) of 5 November 2021 and substituted a new decision that from 31 August 2021 NYVN had 38% care and from 19 July 2021 MGJP had 62% care.

  2. The application was heard on 23 November 2022 by telephone. NYVN and MQJP (the Other Party) were both self-represented. Mr Anthony Gardner, Solicitor at Minter Ellison, appeared for the Respondent, the Child Support Registrar.

    BACKGROUD

  3. The Applicant, NYVN, and the Other Party, MQJP, are the separated parents of three children born in 2008, 2010 and 2013 respectively, who the Tribunal will refer to as ‘the children’.

  4. On 11 April 2018, NYVN and MQJP entered into a Binding Child Support Agreement pursuant to the Child Support (Assessment)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NYVN and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 249
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review of a care percentage determination by the Child Support Registrar, involving parties NYVN and MQJP, and the Child Support Registrar. The dispute centred on the interpretation and calculation of care percentages for children, particularly in light of court orders detailing specific arrangements for "special occasions" such as Christmas, Easter, and birthdays, which deviated from the regular fortnightly care pattern. The case was heard by Ms A E Burke AO, Member.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was how to accurately assess the percentage of care provided by each parent when the court orders stipulated a regular pattern of care (five nights a fortnight for NYVN and nine nights for MQJP) but also included specific provisions for additional time on special days. The Tribunal was required to determine whether these "special occasion" nights constituted variations to the general pattern of care and how they should be factored into the overall percentage calculation for child support purposes, considering the actual care provided.

The Tribunal reasoned that the percentage of care is determined by the actual care provided, which can be reflected in court orders. It found that a pattern of care had been established from 19 July 2021, as per the final Family Court Orders of 4 February 2022. The Tribunal was satisfied that the dispute was not about the fundamental pattern of care but rather its assessment in percentage terms, specifically concerning the inclusion of special occasion nights. The Tribunal concluded that the actual nights of care as contained within the court orders, which incorporated a factor for special nights, represented the correct and preferable approach.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the previous Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision and substituted its own finding. It determined that NYVN had 39% care of the children from 31 August 2021, and MQJP had 61% care of the children from 19 July 2021, reflecting the actual care arrangements including the special occasion provisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Also at 2.2.1, the Guide provides the following on percentage of care:The percentage of care is the mechanism used in the child support assessment formula to take into account the amount of time a parent or non-parent carer is responsible for providing care for the child.A person's percentage of care for a child will generally be determined according to the actual care that they have of the child. The actual care may be reflected in care arrangements agreed upon by the parents, including non-parent carers. This agreement might take the form of a written agreement, parenting plan or court order in relation to a child's care.A parent or non-parent carer's percentage of care for a day in a child support period is the percentage of care that the person is likely to have of the child during the care period.Care will generally be worked out based on the number of nights that the child is likely to be in the care of the person during the care period (CSA Act section 54A).…Additionally, in limited circumstances, a person may have care of a child who is not living with them for a period of time. For example, a person can provide care for a child who is at boarding school, in hospital or in separate accommodation. However, a person who simply supervises the child (for example, a baby sitter, a child minder such as a grandparent or a schoolteacher) does not provide care.Consideration is given to who has responsibility for making arrangements for, and decisions about, the child's welfare, as well as who is meeting the child's costs, rather than just the accommodation arrangements themselves. The Registrar will give weight to statements from both parents and any non-parent carers.EVIDENCE The Final Family Court Orders of 4 February 2022 provide the care arrangement for the children on special days:Notwithstanding any other order, the children shall spend additional time with each of the mother and the father on special occasions as follows:During Christmas:12.1.1 the children spend time with the father from 3pm on Christmas Day to 3pm on Boxing Day in odd-numbered years and from 3pm on Christmas Eve until 3pm on Christmas Day in even-numbered years;12.1.2 the children spend time with the mother from 3pm on Christmas Day to 3pm on Boxing Day in even-numbered years and from 3pm on Christmas Eve until 3pm on Christmas Day in odd-numbered years; and12.1.3 for the purposes of the time referred to in points 12.1.1 and 12.1.2 above, the children are to remain in …, unless otherwise agreed between the mother and the father.12.2 During Easter:12.2.1 commencing 2023, the children spend time with the father from after school (or 3pm on a non-school day) on the Thursday immediately prior to Good Friday until 3pm on Easter Monday in odd numbered years;12.2.2 the children spend time with the mother from after school (or 3pm on a non-school day) on the Thursday immediately prior to Good Friday until3pm on Easter Monday in even numbered years; and12.2.3 notwithstanding the provisions in 10 above, commencing Easter 2022, if Easter falls during week 1 of the school holiday period at the end of term 1, then the children shall spend the first week of those holidays with the parent they are spending Easter with.12.3 On each child's birthday:12.3.1 the children will spend time with the father from after school (or 3pm on a non-school day) on the day before each child's birthday until before school (or 3pm on a non-school day) in even-numbered years;12.3.2 the children will spend time with the mother from after school (or 3pm on a non-school day) on the day before each child's birthday until before school (or 3pm on a non-school day) in odd-numbered years;12.3.3 the children will spend time with the father from after school (or 3pm on a non-school day) on each child's birthday until before school (or 3pm on a non-school day) on the day following each child's birthday in odd-numbered years;…..12.3.4 the children will spend time with the mother from after school (or 3pm on a non-school day) on each child's birthday until before school (or 3pm on a non-school day) on the day following each child's birthday in even-numbered years; and12.4 On the Mothers' Day weekend, the children shall spend time with the mother fro5pm on Saturday until before school (or 9.00am on a non-school day) on Monday.12.5 On the Fathers' Day weekend, the children shall spend time with the father from 5pm on Saturday until before school (or 9.00am on a non-school day) on Monday.12.6 The children spend time with each parent from 5pm on the day prior to that parent’s birthday until before school (or 9am on a non-school day) on the day after that parent's birthday.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds the actual nights of care contained in the court orders is the correct and preferable decision, that being 142 nights with NYVN and 223 with MQJP, including a factor for the special nights which results in NYVN having 39% care and MQJP as having 61% care.Decision The Tribunal sets aside the AAT1 decision of 10 May 2022 and in substitution decides that NYVN has 39% care of the children from 31 August 2021 and MQJP has 61% care of the children from 19 July 2021.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

MQJP provided the following written submission for these proceedings:The nights of care are in accordance with the Orders which were finalised on 4 Feb 2022 and have been adhered to by both myself and NYVN.I have forwarded a copy of the Final Orders for review.The pattern of care since 19 July 2021 has been 9 nights a fortnight to me and 5 nights a fortnight to NYVN (during term time) and school holidays are shared equally. This gives NYVN a total of 142 nights and me 223 nights per year.The problem arises with the ‘special occasion’ nights.I was satisfied with the outcome of the last hearing and the way it was explained made sense to me.It was described that the ‘special occasion’ nights of care were ‘variations’ in the general pattern of care (9 nights me, 5 nights) NYVN which is exactly what they are. Although the occasion itself does not change from year to year the particular day it falls on obviously changes from year to year and thus which parent has care at that particular time.CONSIDERATION The Tribunal is satisfied that there was a change in care from 19 July 2021 when NYVN and MQJP commenced the pattern of care agreed to by consent in family court proceedings which were eventually finalised on 4 February 2022. The agreement fundamentally provided for a two-week cycle of care, with the children spending five nights a fortnight with NYVN and nine nights a fortnight with MQJP. The order also provides that the children split their school holidays between NYVN and MQJP and provide for each parent to have additional nights with the children outside of this pattern to ensure each parent sees the children on special occasions such as birthdays, Christmas, Easter etc. The Tribunal is satisfied that, at all relevant times since 19 July 2021, there was a ‘pattern of care’ for the children for the purpose of satisfying s 50(1)(b)(ii) of the Assessment Act. This was not in dispute. The percentage of care determined by the Tribunal must be based on the actual care that was provided to the children by each parent during the ‘care period’. The Act states at section 50:…the Registrar is satisfied that a responsible person for the child has had, or is likely to have, a pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances. NYVN, MQJP and the Respondent all agree that the pattern of care for the children is that which is set out in the final parenting order and that is the actual care which the children are receiving. NYVN, MQJP and the Respondent all agree that the dispute is not about the pattern of care but how the court orders have been assessed in percentage terms. The issue in contention boils down to whether special nights should form part of the assessment and allocation of care percentages. NYVN, MQJP and the Respondent all contended and accepted that the assessment of the percentage of care must have regard to: NYVN contends that The Tribunal should adopt a probability methodology to balance out these special nights for the next 11 years to ensure these disputes do not arise each year. On this basis, NYVN contends that he has an average of 146 nights a year, equating to 40% care of the children. NYVN summarised his position as: