QWKW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

QWKW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 2060 (2 July 2021)

Division:General Division

File Number(s):               2020/3028

Re:               QWKW

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

And               VLJH

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member P J Clauson AM

Date:2 July 2021

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and in substitution, the Tribunal decides that for the assessment period from 9 August 2019 to 19 March 2020, that the Applicant had 85% and the Other Party had 15% of care of the children.

.....[SGD]...................................................................
Senior Member P J Clauson AM

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether Tribunal should approach assessment with retrospective approach – where parent alleged other parent had occasional missed care events – whether missed care events were established – where pattern of care established regular care – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Evidence Act1995 (Cth)

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

Cases

Reddish and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 721

Re Williams v. Australian Electoral Commission (1995) 38 ALD 366

Secondary Materials

Guides to Social Policy Law, Child Support Guide, Version 4.56, released 10 May 2021.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member P J Clauson AM

OVERVIEW

  1. This matter concerns the care of three children of the Applicant and the Other Party who are the separated parents of child B, born in 2013, and children T & Z, twins born in 2015. The decision under review is a decision made by the Social Services & Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘AAT1’) on 4 May 2020 which set aside the decision of the Child Support Registrar (‘Respondent’) that the Applicant had 86% care of the children B, T & Z and that the Other Party had 14% care from 9 August 2019, and, in substitution found that the Applicant had 80% care of the children and that the Other Party had 20% care of the children from 9 August 2019.[1]

    [1] Exhibit 1, T2, 7-11.

  2. A care arrangement was entered into by the Applicant and the Other Party on 3 June 2019 by way of an Order of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (the ‘care arrangement’).[2]  Pursuant to the Care Arrangement, the Applicant was to have 93% of the care of the children and the Other Party 7% of the care from 15 June 2019.[3] Further, these Orders included an arrangement whereby the Other Party’s care was to increase to two nights per fortnight from 9 August 2019. On 8 August 2019, the Other Party informed the Department of Human Services (the Department) that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QWKW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 2060
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) of a decision by the Child Support Registrar regarding the percentage of care of children. The applicant sought to challenge an objection decision that had disallowed her claim that the other party had missed requisite care events, thereby altering the established pattern of care. The core dispute revolved around whether the other party's alleged missed care occasions meant he had less than regular care of the children.

The Tribunal was required to determine several substantive issues. These included identifying the appropriate care period for consideration, whether the Tribunal could assess care with the benefit of retrospectivity by examining actual care provided, the extent to which the other party had or was likely to have care of the children during the relevant period, and the consequences of the Tribunal's assessment of the percentage of care. Preliminary issues also arose regarding the precise date a change in care occurred and whether any order made by the Tribunal could have practical effect given subsequent decisions.

The Tribunal determined that the appropriate care period for its review was from 9 August 2019 to 19 March 2020. It held that it was entitled to consider the actual care provided by the parties with the benefit of hindsight, citing *Shi v Migration Agent Review Authority* [2008] HCA 31, which permits tribunals to consider events occurring after the original decision was made unless the legislative scheme dictates otherwise. The Tribunal found that a change in care occurred on 9 August 2019.

Ultimately, the AAT set aside the Registrar's objection decision and substituted its own decision. This substituted decision revoked the existing care percentages and determined that, with effect from 9 August 2019, the other party had 20% care and the applicant had 80% care of the children.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In considering the situation as to the Applicant’s receipt of the decision relating to the objection that she had lodged, it is of assistance to examine the relevant section of the Evidence Act1995 (Cth) (Evidence Act), s163, which provides, inter alia:“Proof of letters having been sent by Commonwealth agencies(1)A letter from a Commonwealth agency addressed to a person at a specified address is presumed (unless evidence sufficient to raise doubt about the presumption is adduced) to have been sent by prepaid post to that address on the fifth business day after the date (if any) that, because of its placement on the letter or otherwise, purports to be the date on which the letter was prepared. (2)In this section:“business day” means a day that is not:(a)a Saturday or a Sunday; or(b)a public holiday or bank holiday in the place in which the letter was prepared.“letter” means any form of written communication that is directed to a particular person or address, and includes: (a)any standard postal article within the meaning of the Australian Postal Corporation Act 1989; and(b)any envelope, packet, parcel, container or wrapper containing such a communication; and(c)any unenclosed written communication that is directed to a particular person or address. Note: Section 5 extends the operation of this section to proceedings in all Australian courts.”(Emphasis added). Regard must also be had to s 29 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) (Acts Interpretation Act), which provides:29 Meaning of service by post (1) Where an Act authorises or requires any document to be served by post, whether the expression “serve” or the expression “give” or “send” or any other expression is used, then the service shall be deemed to be effected by properly addressing, prepaying and posting the document as a letter and, unless the contrary is proved, to have been effected at the time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary course of post. (2) This section does not affect the operation of section 160 of the Evidence Act 1995.(Emphasis added). It can be seen from both s 163 of the Evidence Act and s 29 of the Acts Interpretation Act that a statutory presumption exists to reflect when the Applicant was deemed to have received the letter. However, in both statutory provisions, the presumption can be overcome. The emphasis added by the Tribunal in both provisions shows that the Applicant can overcome the presumptions by reference to satisfying an evidentiary burden placed upon her. In the Tribunal’s view, the Applicant has discharged her burden. The Tribunal considers that the facts outlined above, together with the oral evidence of the Applicant to the Tribunal, is supportive of the Applicant’s contention that she received the objection decision letter on 6 March 2020. It is the view of the Tribunal that it would be most improbable for a person to be continuing to contact the Department seeking such correspondence if they had already received it.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 8 February 2020, an objections officer within the Department disallowed the objection on the basis that the Other Party had not missed the requisite care events in order for there to be a change in the pattern of care (the objection decision).[7] [7] Exhibit 1, T14, 118-122. On 23 March 2020, the Applicant sought further review of that decision by the AAT1.[8] [8] Exhibit 1, T16, 149. The AAT1, on 4 May 2020, set aside the decision under review and substituted a decision that the existing care percentages were revoked and, with effect from 9 August 2019, the Other Party had 20% care and the Applicant had 80% care of the children.[9][9] Exhibit 1, T2, 7-11. On 13 May 2020, the Applicant sought further review by the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.[10] [10] Exhibit 1, T1, 1-6.PRELIMINARY MATTERS The Tribunal considers that, in addition to the substantive issues to be considered in this matter as outlined and discussed later in this decision, there are some issues that can be dealt with on a preliminary basis. The Tribunal considers that the following matters can be resolved at a preliminary stage:(a)Whether a change in care occurred on 9 August 2019 or 11 August 2019; and(b)Whether an order made by this Tribunal can have any effect at all.Did a Change in Care Occur on 9 August 2019 or 11 August 2019? The Other Party notified the Respondent on 8 August 2019 that a change of care would take place on 11 August 2019. As the Respondent notes, that date is inconsistent with the terms of the Court Orders which were the basis of the change. The Court Orders properly reflect that a change in care was to occur on 9 August 2019. Having noted the apparent discrepancy, the Respondent sought confirmation from the Applicant as to when care changed.[11] The Applicant conceded that care had changed on 9 August 2019 but contended that the change had not been to the extent that the Other Party suggested.[11] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [44]. It was submitted by the Respondent that the date of the change in the care of the children was indeed 9 August 2019. The Tribunal agrees with that assessment and is satisfied that a change in the care of the children occurred on 9 August 2019. Can an Order Made by This Tribunal Have Any Effect at All? This matter was not reserved at the close of the hearing. The Tribunal sought submissions from the Respondent in relation to the Applicant’s apparent lateness in filing an appeal to the AAT1. In short, the resulting submissions suggested that if the Tribunal considered that the Applicant was late in filing her application to the AAT1, then the effect of the Tribunal’s decision could only be backdated to 23 March 2021: see s 95N of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the ‘Collection Act’). Given that a new change in care decision has already been made by the Respondent, with a date of effect of 20 March 2021, there remained a possibility that any decision by the Tribunal in the Applicant’s favour may therefore be of no practical effect. It is well established that if that were the case, the Tribunal should not engage in a fruitless consideration of the Applicant’s merit: Reddish and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 721 at [33] per DP Blow:“… an application to this Tribunal may be dismissed on the ground that it is frivolous if the Tribunal is unable to make a decision that would be of any practical benefit to the applicant. Plainly this Tribunal will not be able to make a decision that will be of any practical benefit to the applicant, and it would be a waste of everyone’s time and money for [the application for second review] to be allowed to remain on foot.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Other Party told the Tribunal that he and the Applicant:“Can’t agree on the fact that the sky is blue … “[22]and had very differing views about the interpretation of the Orders for the period of four years. [22] Transcript of proceedings, P-16, ln 10.CONSIDERATION The fundamental basis for this review by the Applicant was that the Other Party had, by his omissions, broken the pattern of care as formalised in the Court Orders of 3 June 2019 insofar as he had missed care on the occasions outlined above and thus had less than regular care. Outline of Issues The substantive issues for the Tribunal’s consideration are as follows:(a)What is the appropriate care period for the Tribunal to consider in making its decision;(b)Whether the Tribunal may have regard to the actual care of the parties with the benefit of retrospect; or whether, alternatively, the Tribunal must have regard to the likely care of the parties at the time the original decision was made;(c)To what extent the Other Party had or was likely to have care of Children B, T and Z throughout the care assessment period; and(d)What consequences fall as a result of the Tribunal’s assessment of the percentage of care.What is the Appropriate Care Period for the Tribunal to Consider in Making its Decision? In order to determine the whether the Other Party had at least regular care within the meaning of the Assessment Act, the Tribunal must first determine an appropriate care period. The Tribunal notes the submissions made on behalf of the Respondent at the hearing that on 20 March 2020 a new care determination regarding the children was made. This determination gave the Applicant 100% care of the children and the Other Party 0% care of the children. The Registrar further submitted that the effect of the March 2020 determination would be to revoke any existing care determination which may have been in place prior to 20 March 2020. This means that any determination made by this Tribunal would also be revoked as from the same date. Thus, for the purpose of this review, the appropriate care period for the Tribunal to consider is that from 9 August 2019 to 19 March 2020 (inclusive). This period is of 224 days duration and will be the period governing the decision of this Tribunal. Can the Tribunal Have Regard to the Actual Care of the Parties with the Benefit of Retrospect? In order to establish the appropriate relative care percentage of the parties, it is necessary for the Tribunal to determine the method by which it should measure the parties’ care of the children. A question arises as to whether the Tribunal is entitled to look, with the benefit of hindsight, at the actual care provided by the parties; or whether the Tribunal is bound to objectively assess, at the point in time when the percentage of care assessment begins. The Tribunal received submissions on this issue from the Respondent, which submitted that the Tribunal was indeed permitted to take a retrospective approach. The Applicant also contended for a retrospective approach. In its submissions, the Respondent referred the Tribunal to an unpublished decision of the Tribunal in 2015,[23] which in relevant part, stated:[57]Care decisions are generally predictive in nature, given the period to which they apply at the time they are made. However, where, as is the case here, evidence of the “actual care” provided by the parents of the child in the relevant care period is available (i.e. because the relevant care period has already passed), the Tribunal should have regard to the “actual care” that was provided during the period under review: see Shi v Migration Agent Review Authority [2008] HCA 31. In Shi, the High Court held that it was open to the Tribunal to take into account conduct and events that occurred after the original decision was made, and that the Tribunal was not confined to the evidence that was before the original decision-maker, unless the legislative scheme requires the decision to be made by the Tribunal with reference to a particular point in time.[58]Further, there is nothing in Division 4 Part 5 of the Assessment Act or in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 that suggests it is not appropriate for the Tribunal to take into account new evidence or evidence of actual events that have occurred after the Original Decision was made in circumstances where the dispute before the Tribunal relates to the percentage of care that each parent had in a single care period. (citations omitted)[23] See Exhibit 2, [22].