Queensland Rail v Richards

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
COURT OF APPEAL [1999] QCA 471

DAVIES JA PINCUS JA ATKINSON J

Appeal No 2796 of 1999
QUEENSLAND RAIL Appellant (Defendant)
and
HILTON JAMES RICHARDS Respondent (Plaintiff)
BRISBANE
..DATE 08/11/99
081199 T7/HMH8 M/T COA268/99

PINCUS JA: This is an appeal against an assessment of damages in a personal injury case, the appellant complaining that the assessment was excessive. It is not in dispute that the respondent suffered an injury to his left wrist while at work on 12 May 1993, having previously suffered an injury in the same area 10 months before.

The appellant was liable to compensate the respondent for the second injury, but not for the first which had nothing to do with his work. The problem for the Judge, in outline, was that there were differing medical opinions as to the extent to which the disability after the second injury suffered by the respondent was due to the second injury as opposed to the first injury. The appellant argues that the primary Judge wrongly assessed the reliability of the evidence of the doctors. Apart from that, there are other complaints about the assessments, which I will deal with shortly.

It must be said, at the outset, that the summary of the argument presented by the appellant says that this Court is in as good a position as the learned trial Judge was to deal with the medical evidence as to the impact of the first incident. That appears to me not to be so. The case is one in which three doctors gave oral evidence, either personally or by telephone,

and one would expect that the conclusions the Judge reached must have been influenced by
his impressions of that oral evidence. The appellant's counsel below attacked the credibility
of Dr Graham, whom the Judge accepted, on the basis that he was an advocate on behalf of
the respondent. His Honour rejected that contention, remarking:

"Dr Graham was patently convinced that his opinion was the correct one and expressed

himself forcefully but I did not consider him to be partial."

The task which the appellant has, in attempting to achieve the rejection of the evidence of Dr
Graham and the acceptance of the other two doctors, Drs Morgan and Millroy, is a
formidable one.

The work injury was suffered when a railway sleeper, which was tossed on top of other sleepers, rolled back towards the respondent, who threw up his left arm to stop it. The sleeper struck his left wrist, causing him pain. He was taken to hospital where he was told that the wrist would heal but two weeks later, still in pain, was sent to Dr Graham who is an orthopaedic specialist. After conservative treatment failed to resolve the problem, Dr Graham operated on the respondent on 10 August 1993, some five months after the work injury. At the operation, the distal radial ulnar joint was fused, restricting movement and strength in that wrist.

The Judge found that there is tingling or ache present most…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Rail v Richards and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QCA 471
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal in Queensland Rail v Richards considered an appeal by Queensland Rail, the appellant and defendant, against an assessment of damages for a personal injury sustained by Hilton James Richards, the respondent and plaintiff. The dispute centred on the extent of the disability caused by a workplace injury to the respondent's left wrist, which was complicated by a previous injury to the same wrist. The central legal issue was whether the primary Judge had erred in assessing the medical evidence regarding the impact of the workplace injury, as opposed to the previous injury, on the respondent's condition.

The Court found that the primary Judge was in as good a position as the Court of Appeal to evaluate the medical evidence. The Judge accepted the evidence of Dr Graham, the orthopaedic specialist who treated the respondent, over the other doctors because of his extensive history with the respondent and his successful surgical interventions. The Judge's assessment of future economic loss, reduced from approximately $300,000 to $100,000, was considered moderate and reasonable given the respondent's previous employment history and the nature of his injuries. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established