Queensland Police Service v Arh

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

MAGISTRATES COURTS OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Queensland Police Service v ARH [2019] QMC 16

PARTIES:

Queensland Police Service

(Applicant)

v

ARH

(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

MAG-00036927/19(4)

DIVISION:

Magistrates Courts

PROCEEDING:

Criminal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Rockhampton

DELIVERED ON:

13 September 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Rockhampton

HEARING DATE:

23 August 2019

A/MAGISTRATE:

M Morrow

CATCHWORDS:

Criminal Law – Contravention of a temporary protection order – construction of temporary protection order

SOLICITORS:

Ms J King appeared for Queensland Police Prosecutions

Mrs J Madden, Solicitor for the defendant

  1. ARH is charged with:

“that on the 11th day of February 2019 at Rockhampton … (he) being a respondent against whom a domestic violence order had been contravened the order namely a temporary made on 15th January 2019 in the Magistrates Court at Rockhampton and ARH was present in court when the order was made.”

  1. The charge is amended inserting after the words temporary the words protection order.

  1. The prosecution has called EJB, Jeannine Elizabeth Harp and S/Const Ryan James Packenham.

  1. The burden of proof lies with the prosecution to prove each and every element of the offence and the standard of proof is beyond reasonable doubt. It is for the prosecution to satisfy the Court that not only is guilt a rational inference that could be drawn from the proved facts, but it is the only inference.[1] This means that the prosecution is required to exclude any reasonable hypothesis consistent with innocence.[2]

    [1]Shepherd (1990) 170 CLR 573 at 578.

    [2]Perera (1986) 1 Qd R 211 at 217 and also see R v BBU [2009] QCA 385 at [55].

  1. The defendant has not given or called evidence. That is his right. He is not bound to give or to call evidence. The defendant is entitled to insist that the prosecution prove the case against him, if it can. The prosecution bears the burden of proving the guilt of the defendant beyond a reasonable doubt, and the fact that the defendant did not give evidence is not evidence against him. It does not constitute an admission of guilt by conduct and it may not be used to fill any gaps in the evidence led by the prosecution. It proves nothing at all, and you must not assume that because he did not give evidence that adds in some way to the case against him. It cannot be considered at all when deciding whether the prosecution has proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt, and most certainly does not make the task confronting the prosecution any easier. It cannot change the fact that the prosecution retains the responsibility to prove guilt of the defendant beyond reasonable doubt.

  1. In relation to this particular matter I have, during the course of the trial, had an opportunity of listening to and observing the demeanour of the witnesses that have given evidence. This has assisted me in assessing credibility, although I accept that there is a need to keep the appearance and demeanour of a witness in perspective and the weight of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Police Service v Arh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QMC 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Queensland Police Service v Arh involved a dispute over the contravention of a temporary protection order (TPO) by the defendant, ARH. The proceedings took place in the Magistrates Court, with Acting Magistrate Mark Morrow presiding over the matter. The core of the dispute was whether ARH had violated the terms of the TPO by remaining in the vicinity of the aggrieved party, EJB, and engaging in a conversation with her outside the classroom.

The legal issues the court needed to resolve were the interpretation of the phrase "remain" within the context of the TPO and whether ARH had indeed contravened the order by approaching EJB and having a conversation with her. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the evidence presented sufficiently proved that ARH had approached EJB, as required to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

In reaching its decision, the court examined the ordinary meaning of "remain" in the context of domestic violence orders and concluded that it implied staying behind or in the same place. The court noted that the TPO did not explicitly define "place" but suggested that it should be interpreted in a manner that ensures clarity and ease of understanding. The court also found that while ARH should not have remained and engaged in conversation with EJB, there was insufficient evidence to prove that ARH approached EJB. Consequently, the court acquitted ARH of the charge, highlighting that EJB was the one who came closer to ARH during their brief interaction.

The court's final order was to acquit ARH of the charge of contravening the TPO, reflecting its findings on the interpretation of "remain" and the insufficiency of the evidence to prove that ARH approached EJB.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my opinion in the context of Domestic Violence Orders ‘remain’ means to stay behind or in the same place. If you remain in a place, you stay there and do not move away.[8][8] type="1">A place can be a location that is a building, area, town, or country. It is a geographical point.[9][9] type="1">Further, in my opinion in the context of Domestic Violence Orders, what constitutes a place will vary depending on each case including the location and landscape. A landscape includes the physical elements of geophysically defined landforms, land cover and human elements including different forms of land use, buildings, and structures. It could be a room, building, school, farm, forest or mountain.The TPO does not have clear language that defines a place. It would be open under s 58 of the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 to impose a restraint against remaining or approaching a person, and a restraint against remaining within a particular distance of a person. By stating a specific distance would clarify Orders and be clear and easy for people to understand Orders. I am loathe to define a place other than go give it its plain and ordinary meaning, but it would be reasonable in the context of this case to indicate a place would be in the general vicinity or in other words an area close to the aggrieved being a distance from the respondent that an aggrieved person needs to be in order to remain comfortable or safe viewed objectively. There is no provision in the TPO restricting contact by ARH with his children except when they are with EJB. If the Court did not want the respondent to have contact with the children or attend the school, then that would be reflected in the TPO.I am not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that ARH has approached EJB outside the classroom. EJB walks up to where ARH and the children are outside the classroom. For ARH to approach EJB, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt ARH came nearer to EJB. The evidence suggests EJB came nearer to ARH. See Sturt v Ball [2013] WASC 343.This is at 2:55pm. An animated conversation between ARH and EJB occurs as seen by Mrs H.It is a short conversation of no more than a few minutes at best between 2:55pm and 3:01pm when EJB telephones 000.ARH should not have remained and had that conversation because he is contravening the TPO by doing so. The Act of remaining in a place with the aggrieved and not moving away, constitutes the contravention of the TPO. It is incumbent upon the person upon whom the restraining order is imposed to immediately walk away from the aggrieved. The exception does not apply as it has not been agreed in writing by EJB or ARH to have contact with the children in her presence and no other Court Orders are in place.ConclusionI find the defendant guilty of the charge.Mark MorrowActing Magistrate. The TPO does not have clear language that defines a place. It would be open under s 58 of the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 to impose a restraint against remaining or approaching a person, and a restraint against remaining within a particular distance of a person. By stating a specific distance would clarify Orders and be clear and easy for people to understand Orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.