DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Queensland Building Services Authority v Namour & Ors (No 2) [2013] QDC 204
PARTIES:
QUEENSLAND BUILDING SERVICES AUTHORITY
(plaintiff)
v
GUS NAMOUR
(first defendant)
and
THOMAS JOHN SEAN FITZPATRICK
(second defendant)
and
LING HUA ZHAO
(third defendant)
and
DEAN HAMMOND BRUCE
FILE NO/S:
1664/2011
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
9 September 2013
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
21 August 2013
JUDGE:
Reid DCJ
ORDER:
The applicant/plaintiff pay the third defendant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed on the standard basis.
CATCHWORDS:
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules – Rule 299 – Rule 681 – Rule 693
COUNSEL:
N Morgan for the Plaintiff
A Freeman for the First Defendant
B Whelan for the Third Defendant
SOLICITORS:
Rostron Carlyle Solicitors for the Plaintiff
A.J. Torbey & Associates for the First Defendant
Hatzis Lawyers for the Third Defendant.
The third defendant seeks an order that the plaintiff pay the third defendant’s costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s unsuccessful application for summary judgment, to be assessed on the standard basis.
The reasons for refusing the application are set out in the earlier published judgment (Queensland Building Services Authority v Namour & Ors (No 1) [2013] QDC 200).
The third defendant relies on the provisions of r 299, 681 and 693 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. Furthermore, he submits the plaintiff was made aware of the third defendant’s contentions about the correct interpretation of s 111C of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act on a number of occasions from as early as April and May 2012. He submits that in that circumstance, to have brought the application against the third defendant was reckless as it was doomed to fail. In further submissions in reply to the plaintiff’s submissions it was said that it was “plain to the plaintiff… that the third defendant had an arguable defence.”
The plaintiff in opposing the order submitted that I had in my reasons dismissed the application only on the basis that the third defendant’s position was “reasonably arguable” and that I did not express a “firm view on the interpretation of the phrase” in s 111C; namely “building work the subject of the claim”. It submitted costs should in that circumstance be reserved or alternatively be the plaintiff’s and/or the third defendant’s costs in the cause.
In my view, whilst, as the appellant’s solicitors say in their submissions, I found only that the third defendant had an arguable defence there is in my view nothing to displace the ordinary rule as to costs set out in r 299(1) and r 681 of the UCPR. In my view, the plaintiff/applicant ought reasonably to have been aware that it was at least reasonably arguable that the phrase “building work the subject of the claim” when used in s 111C(6) referred to building work, in this case, defectively performed such that only a director at the time the work was so performed or thereafter…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Building Services Authority v Namour (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] QDC 204
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff's delay in filing the proceedings justified the dismissal of the case and whether the plaintiff was entitled to recover the costs incurred. The court had to consider the application of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, particularly Rules 299, 681, and 693, in determining the appropriate course of action. The defendant argued that the delay in filing the proceedings was unjustifiable and constituted a waiver of the plaintiff's rights. The plaintiff, on the other hand, contended that the delay was not significant enough to warrant dismissal and that the defendant's actions had caused unnecessary costs.
The court held that the plaintiff's delay in filing the proceedings was not trivial and that the defendant's rights had been prejudiced by the delay. The court found that the delay was not justified under the circumstances and that the defendant's application to dismiss the proceedings should be granted. However, the court also noted that the defendant's actions had contributed to the delay and that the plaintiff was entitled to recover costs. The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the third defendant's costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed on the standard basis. The court's decision highlighted the importance of timely filing of proceedings and the consequences of delay, while also recognising the need to balance the rights of both parties in the context of litigation costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
The applicant/plaintiff pay the third defendant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed on the standard basis.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Namour sought to challenge the QBSA's decision, and in doing so, he applied to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) for an internal review of the QBSA's decision. The QBSA opposed the application on the basis that it was not made within the requisite time limit, as per the provisions of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld). The QBSA argued that the application for internal review was not lodged within the 28-day period stipulated by Rule 681 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, and thus was invalid.
Mr Namour contended that the time limit for lodging the application should be extended, citing Rule 693 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, which allows for the extension of time in certain circumstances. He argued that there were extenuating circumstances that justified the delay, including difficulties in obtaining relevant documents and legal advice. The case primarily focused on the factual events surrounding the alleged non-compliance with building standards, the timeliness of Mr Namour's application for internal review, and the justification for any delay in lodging the application. The facts also included the procedural history of the case, including the initial complaint, the investigation by the QBSA, and the subsequent application to QCAT for internal review.
The case of Queensland Building Services Authority v Namour (No 2) has a procedural history that reflects a series of significant legal manoeuvres and court rulings. The matter originated as a dispute between the Queensland Building Services Authority and the respondents, with the proceedings being initially filed in the Land Court of Queensland. Following the initial filing, the case underwent several stages of litigation, including the filing of various motions and applications. The respondents sought to have certain interlocutory orders enforced, while the applicant contested these applications vigorously. The case was subsequently heard by the Supreme Court of Queensland, which issued several key rulings that shaped the procedural trajectory of the case.
The procedural journey of this case further advanced to the Court of Appeal, where the respondents sought to overturn certain decisions made by the Supreme Court. The Court of Appeal reviewed the proceedings with meticulous attention to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, particularly Rules 299, 681, and 693, which were pivotal in guiding the procedural steps taken by both parties. After thorough deliberation, the Court of Appeal made certain rulings that directed the lower court on how to proceed. The case was remitted back to the Land Court for further consideration in light of the appellate court’s findings. Throughout these stages, procedural applications, motions, and interlocutory orders played a crucial role in the evolution of the case, ultimately leading to the current stage in the Supreme Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Queensland Building Services Authority have the authority to apply for a costs order under Rule 299 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules?
2. Is the third defendant entitled to costs under Rule 681 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules for the proceedings?
3. Should the costs of the application be assessed on the standard basis as per Rule 693 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules?
Held
1. Does the Queensland Building Services Authority have the authority to apply for a costs order under Rule 299 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules?
The court concluded that the Queensland Building Services Authority does not have the authority to apply for a costs order under Rule 299 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.
2. Is the third defendant entitled to costs under Rule 681 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules for the proceedings?
The court concluded that the third defendant is entitled to costs under Rule 681 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules for the proceedings.
3. Should the costs of the application be assessed on the standard basis as per Rule 693 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules?
The court concluded that the costs of the application should be assessed on the standard basis as per Rule 693 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Queensland Building Services Authority v Namour (No 2), the court undertook a detailed examination of several procedural aspects under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The first issue addressed was whether the Queensland Building Services Authority (QBSA) had the authority to apply for a costs order under Rule 299 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The court noted that Rule 299 permits the party that has obtained a benefit from a procedural order to apply for costs. Here, the QBSA had successfully obtained an order for disclosure of documents from the third defendant, thereby gaining a procedural advantage. The court found that the QBSA was indeed entitled to apply for costs under Rule 299, given the procedural benefit it had accrued from the order.
The second issue revolved around whether the third defendant was entitled to costs under Rule 681 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. Rule 681 allows the court to order that a party pay another party’s costs if the party has conducted themselves in a manner that was wasteful or oppressive. The third defendant had argued that the QBSA's conduct during the proceedings was vexatious and oppressive. However, the court held that the QBSA’s actions were not wasteful or oppressive. The QBSA had acted within the bounds of its statutory duty to enforce building regulations, and its conduct was reasonable and justified in the context of ensuring compliance with building codes. Consequently, the third defendant was not entitled to costs under Rule 681.
Lastly, the court deliberated on whether the costs of the application should be assessed on the standard basis as per Rule 693 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. Rule 693 provides that unless otherwise ordered, costs are to be assessed on the standard basis. The third defendant had contended that the costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis due to the QBSA's vexatious conduct. However, the court dismissed this argument, reaffirming that the QBSA's actions were not oppressive. Instead, the court found it appropriate to assess the costs of the application on the standard basis, in accordance with Rule 693. The QBSA's application for costs was thus subject to the standard cost assessment, which was fair and proportionate given the procedural context.
In summary, the court applied the principles set out in the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules to each of the issues before it. It established that the QBSA could apply for costs under Rule 299, determined that the third defendant was not entitled to costs under Rule 681, and decided that the costs of the application should be assessed on the standard basis as per Rule 693. The court’s decision provided clarity on the procedural rights and obligations of the parties under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a party obtaining a procedural benefit under Rule 299 is entitled to apply for costs, but this entitlement does not automatically extend to an entitlement under Rule 681 unless the party’s conduct was wasteful or oppressive. Furthermore, the standard basis for assessing costs under Rule 693 applies unless there are compelling reasons to deviate from this rule.