Queensland Building Services Authority v J M Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Queensland Building Services Authority v J M Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd [2013] QCA 320

PARTIES:

QUEENSLAND BUILDING SERVICES AUTHORITY
(appellant)
v
J M KELLY (PROJECT BUILDERS) PTY LTD
ACN 010 280 412
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 5104 of 2013
SC No 3907 of 2013

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

25 October 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

11 October 2013

JUDGES:

Chief Justice and Fraser JA and Mullins J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

1.   Allow the appeal with costs.

2.   Vary the declaration ordered in the Trial Division so that it provides as follows:

“It is declared that Direction to Rectify and/or Complete numbered 36338 issued by the respondent to the applicant is void.”

3.   Dismiss the application made in the Trial Division for a declaration that Direction to Rectify and/or Complete numbered 35691 issued by the respondent to the applicant is void.

4.   The parties have leave to make submissions as to the costs of the proceedings in the Trial Division in accordance with paragraph 52(4) of Practice Direction No. 3 of 2013 within seven days or within such extended time as is ordered by the Court, a Judge of Appeal or Registrar.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS – STATUTORY POWER TO REQUIRE RECTIFICATION OF DEFECTIVE OR INCOMPLETE BUILDING WORK – where the appellant issued directions to the respondent pursuant to s 72 of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld) (‘the Act’) requiring rectification of certain building work within 28 days – where the appellant sent two directions to the respondent by post on 17 December 2010 and 17 June 2011 – where the primary judge held those directions were not validly given by post because they required the rectification work to be carried out within a period of less than 28 days – where the appellant also sent the 17 December 2010 direction to the respondent by email on that date – where the appellant argued that the primary judge erred in holding that the 17 December 2010 direction had not been effectively served by email – where the appellant contended that the respondent failed to fulfil the onus which lay upon it to prove that the email had not been opened on 17 December 2010 – where the respondent did not adduce direct evidence that the email had not been received and opened by an employee of the respondent acting in the scope of their employment – where the respondent argued that the evidence justified the primary judge in inferring that the email had not been opened on that date – whether the primary judge erred in holding that the 17 December 2010 direction was invalid

PROCEDURE – MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MATTERS – APPROPRIATE FORM OF RELIEF - DISCRETION OF COURT – FUTILITY OF DECLARATION – where the appellant argued that the declaration…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Building Services Authority v J M Kelly (Project... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QCA 320
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Queensland Building Services Authority appealed against a decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland, Trial Division, which had declared two directions issued by the appellant to be invalid. The directions were issued under section 72 of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991, requiring the respondent to rectify certain building work within 28 days. The court was required to determine whether the directions were validly given and whether the primary judge erred in holding that the directions were invalid. Specifically, the court needed to address whether the directions were validly served by post and whether the primary judge was correct in finding that the email served direction was invalid. The court also had to consider whether the declaration that the second direction was invalid should be set aside for lack of utility.

The court found that the primary judge had erred in holding that the 17 December 2010 direction was invalid. The court held that the primary judge should have found that the direction was effectively served by email, as the respondent had failed to provide sufficient evidence to prove that the email had not been opened. The court also found that the primary judge was correct in holding that the 17 June 2011 direction was invalid, as it did not comply with section 72(3) of the Act. However, the court held that there was no utility in declaring that the 17 June 2011 direction was invalid, as the appellant had only conceded its invalidity during the appeal. The court held that the declaration in the Trial Division should be varied to exclude reference to the 17 December 2010 direction.

The appeal was allowed, and the declaration ordered in the Trial Division was varied to state that Direction to Rectify and/or Complete numbered 36338 issued by the respondent to the applicant is void. The application made in the Trial Division for a declaration that Direction to Rectify and/or Complete numbered 35691 issued by the respondent to the applicant is void was dismissed. The parties were granted leave to make submissions as to the costs of the proceedings in the Trial Division within seven days or within such extended time as is ordered by the Court, a Judge of Appeal or Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Allow the appeal with costs.

2. Vary the declaration ordered in the Trial Division so that it provides as follows:

“It is declared that Direction to Rectify and/or Complete numbered 36338 issued by the respondent to the applicant is void.”

3. Dismiss the application made in the Trial Division for a declaration that Direction to Rectify and/or Complete numbered 35691 issued by the respondent to the applicant is void.

4. The parties have leave to make submissions as to the costs of the proceedings in the Trial Division in accordance with paragraph 52(4) of Practice Direction No. 3 of 2013 within seven days or within such extended time as is ordered by the Court, a Judge of Appeal or Registrar.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Because the appellant’s case relied upon the inadequacy of the respondent’s evidence rather than upon challenges to that evidence or inferences capable of arising from it, the fact that Mr Murphy was not cross-examined did not contravene the rule of practice in Browne v Dunn.[15] The language in Mr Murphy’s affidavit is clear and precise. It was incapable of being stretched to the large extent which would be necessary to fill the gaps in the respondent’s evidence. In the result, there was no evidence which was capable of giving rise to any “reasonable and definite inference”[16] to negate the inference, arising from Mr Murphy’s evidence of the respondent’s usual practice, that the email and attached electronic direction were opened and read by an employee of the respondent whose duties comprehended the receipt of that direction on the respondent’s behalf.[15](1894) 6 R 67. The rule requires the cross-examiner to put to the witness “the nature of the case upon which it is proposed to rely in contradiction of his evidence…”: Allied Pastoral Holdings Pty Ltd v Commission of Taxation [1983] 1 NSWLR 1 at 16 (Hunt J), followed in Smith v Advance Electronics Pty Ltd [2005] 1 Qd R 65 at [31]. See also Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services (2011) 243 CLR 361 at 387 (Heydon, Crennan and Bell JJ).[16]Penrith City Council v East Realisations Pty (in liq) [2013] NSWCA 64 at [62], citing Luxton v Vines (1952) 85 CLR 352 at 358, Holloway v McFeeters (1956) 94 CLR 470 at 477, and Derrick v Cheung (2001) ALR 301 at [13]. The declaration made in the Trial Division should be varied to omit reference to the 17 December 2010 direction. The appellant argued in the Trial Division that there was no utility in declaring that either direction was invalid. The primary judge rejected that argument. Separate proceedings had been brought by the respondent and by “Group Kildey” in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal under s 86(1)(e) of the Act for a review on the merits of the appellant’s decisions to issue the directions. The primary judge concluded, following McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority, that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to grant the declaration sought in the Supreme Court. For that reason, and because non‑compliance with a valid direction might constitute an offence against the Act, the primary judge considered that there was utility in granting declaratory relief. The appellant argued that if, as I would hold, the application for a declaration that the 17 December 2010 direction was void should have been dismissed, there was no utility in declaring that the 17 June 2011 direction was void. The ground of this submission, as I understood it, was that here there was no controversy to resolve because the appellant had conceded in the Trial Division that the 17 June 2011 direction was void. The appellant’s written submissions in the Trial Division did not clearly make such a concession. Rather, after submitting that the 17 December 2010 direction was valid, the appellant conceded only that the 17 June 2011 direction “does not comply with s.72(3) of the QBSA Act”.[17] Similarly, in oral argument the appellant’s counsel acknowledged only that the 17 June 2011 direction was “not in accordance with s 72”. Since the work described in that direction differed from the work described in the 17 December 2010 direction, a conclusion that the earlier is not void would have no bearing upon the utility of declaring that the later direction is void. The clear concession on appeal that the 17 June 2011 direction is void came too late to justify a submission that the primary judge’s declaration to that effect lacked utility.[17]Outline of submissions of the respondent, paragraph 11.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established