Queensland Building and Construction Commission & Benton v Egan (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Queensland Building and Construction Commission & Benton v Egan (No 2) [2023] QCATA 163

PARTIES:

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(first applicant/appellant)

NIGEL BENTON

(second applicant/appellant)

v

ANGELA EGAN

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL161-21; APL166-21

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR360-19; GAR360-20

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

22 December 2023

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Judicial Member Peter Murphy SC

ORDERS:

1. BY CONSENT there be no order for costs in the appeal as between the QBCC and Dr Egan.

2.     The application for costs in the appeal filed by Mr Benton against Dr Egan be dismissed.

3.     There be no order for costs in the appeal as between Mr Benton and Dr Egan.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY TRIBUNALS – COSTS – POWERS OF TRIBUNAL AND RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS IN EXERCISE OF DISCRETION – where the builder second applicant was successful in an appeal pertaining to the Home Warranty Insurance Scheme – where the builder seeks costs against the home owner respondent – whether the Tribunal’s discretion to award costs in the “interests of justice” infers a strong contra-indication against costs orders – where no prior decisions could be found to assist questions of statutory interpretation at the appeal, but the parties were not faced with the task of “managing complex litigation” – where the submissions of the builder did not advance the arguments of the first applicant nor differently inform the conclusion reached in the appeal – whether denying costs would discourage litigation and subsequent determinations providing “certainty and guidance to the community at large” in the context of the first applicant’s statutory functions – where the appeal was determinative of the liability between the builder and the first applicant rather than between the builder and the respondent – whether the builder’s success at the appeal would be “eroded” if a costs order was not made – where the respondent’s arguments at the appeal, though unsuccessful, were not weaker than the arguments against her – whether the interests of justice require the Tribunal to award the builder costs    

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 100, s 102

Health Ombudsman v Antley [2016] QCAT 472

Lee v Medical Board of Australia (No 2) [2016] QCAT 321
Marzini v Health Ombudsman (No 4) [2020] QCAT 365
Queensland Building and Construction Commission v B&L Constructions Qld Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] QCATA 107
Ralacom Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Paradise Island Apartments (No 2) [2010] QCAT 412
Tamawood Ltd & Anor v Paans [2005] QCA 111

Thompson v Cannon [2020] QCAT 109

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. A decision by the QBCC[1] denied Dr Egan access to the Home Warranty Insurance Scheme legislated in Part 5 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld).[2] Dr Egan’s claim was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Building and Construction Commission & Benton v E... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCATA 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Queensland Building and Construction Commission & Benton v Egan (No 2) case involved a dispute between the builder, Mr Benton, and the homeowner, Dr Egan, with the Commission also a party. The central issue was whether Mr Benton was entitled to costs against Dr Egan following a successful appeal regarding the Home Warranty Insurance Scheme. The case was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal had the discretion to award costs in the interests of justice, considering the statutory provisions and the relevant considerations in exercising this discretion. The court had to determine if Mr Benton’s submissions advanced the arguments of the Commission or informed the conclusion reached in the appeal, and whether denying costs would discourage litigation and subsequent determinations providing certainty and guidance to the community. Additionally, the court had to consider if the builder's success at the appeal would be eroded without a costs order, given that Dr Egan's arguments, though unsuccessful, were not weaker than those against her.

The court concluded that Mr Benton’s application for costs should focus on whether the interests of justice required an order when considering the statutory provisions and relevant factors. The court found that no party acted in a way that disadvantaged Mr Benton or was denied natural justice, and the financial circumstances of both parties were not determinable from the evidence. Although Mr Benton's appeal succeeded on an error of law, the court found no compelling reasons to support a costs order against Dr Egan. The court further noted that Dr Egan’s arguments were arguable, and her case on the appeal was not weaker than Mr Benton's. Ultimately, the court dismissed Mr Benton’s application for costs against Dr Egan.

In summary, the Tribunal dismissed Mr Benton's application for costs against Dr Egan. The court found that no order for costs should be made in the appeal as between the Commission and Dr Egan, and no order for costs should be made between Mr Benton and Dr Egan.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. BY CONSENT there be no order for costs in the appeal as between the QBCC and Dr Egan.

2. The application for costs in the appeal filed by Mr Benton against Dr Egan be dismissed.

3. There be no order for costs in the appeal as between Mr Benton and Dr Egan.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my opinion it could not be said of Dr Egan’s argument ahead of the appeal decision that it suffered from the “unattractive proposition” contended for. Ultimately, her argument was not accepted, but it could not in my opinion be objectively viewed before the appeal hearing as any weaker than the arguments against her.Summary and Conclusion For the reasons earlier given, I conclude in summary:(a)It is not necessary for Mr Benton to show that the interests of justice “point so compellingly to a costs order that they overcome the strong contra-indication against costs orders in s 100”;(b)Mr Benton’s application for costs should pose the question for this Tribunal “do the interests of justice require an order for costs when due regard is had to a general rule that good reasons in terms of the interests for justice for that order should be shown, and when consideration is given to all circumstances considered relevant including, in particular, a consideration of the factors enumerated in s 102(3) of the QCAT Act?”;(c)No party has acted in a way that disadvantaged Mr Benton;(d)No party was denied natural justice on the appeal and nor did any party do other than assist the Appeal Tribunal;(e)No conclusions can be drawn about the financial circumstances of Mr Benton or Dr Egan;(f)Whatever the complexities involved in the task of statutory interpretation involved in the appeal, Mr Benton was not tasked with “managing complex litigation” in the sense referred to in Tamawood, above;(g)In that respect, as a result of the inadequacies of the reasons at first instance, the submissions relating to the complexity of intertwined legislation on the appeal were effectively the same as those at first instance;(h)Dr Egan’s claim that Mr Benton was not a proper party to the appeal is rejected as is her submission that Mr Benton simply “adopted” the submissions of the QBCC. However, nor did Mr Benton’s submissions or participation in the hearing expand or advance the arguments of the QBCC or differently or more cogently inform any conclusion reached in the appeal;(i)It was open to conduct the appeal in the manner he did, but given reasonable alternatives open to him, the interests of justice point against the conclusion that Dr Egan should pay for his choices in doing so;(j)Dr Egan’s case on the appeal was arguable and Mr Benton’s suggestion that she “consistently and steadfastly” resisted the appeal is rejected as irrelevant to the issue of costs;(k)The appeal succeeded on an error of law: the arguments of the parties were not considered and the reasons at first instance were manifestly inadequate. Dr Egan was a respondent to the appeal. Nothing in the proceedings or reasons at first instance suggest she should not have sought to uphold her arguments or the outcome there; (l)I reject Mr Benton’s contention that his appeal had as its purpose or effect giving the “certainty, guidance and assistance” for which he contends. Those characteristics are properly attributable to the QBCC’s appeal; (m)Mr Benton can be described as having succeeded in his appeal. I am not persuaded that this fact per se points to the interests of justice favouring costs in the circumstances of this case. The omission of that factor from s 102(3) after the repeal of s 71 informs that conclusion in part but I consider it important that Mr Benton’s true practical success in the appeal is avoiding liability to the QBCC; (n)Mr Benton’s success in the appeal leaves Dr Egan unremedied in respect of his work which is admitted to be defective. The work remains defective and unrectified; and(o)I do not consider that a reasonable assessment of the cases advanced by each of the parties prior to the outcome of the appeal results in the conclusion that Mr Benton’s case was stronger than Dr Egan’s case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.