PW Woods (Builder) Pty Ltd v Watch This Space Builders Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read
CITATION: PW Woods (Builder) Pty Ltd v Watch This Space Builders Pty Ltd [2014] QCAT 188
PARTIES: P W Woods (Builder) Pty Ltd
(First Applicant )
and
Watch This Space Builders Pty Ltd
(Second Applicant)
v
Mr Peter Hishon
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: BDL358-12
MATTER TYPE: Building matters
HEARING DATE: 25, 26 and 27 November 2013
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Member King-Scott
DELIVERED ON: 8 May 2014
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    The claims by the First and Second Applicants are dismissed;

2.    The Respondent’s counterclaim against the First Applicant is allowed and I direct the First Applicant pay the Respondent the sum of $76,973.27 by 30 June 2014;

3.    The Respondent’s counterclaim against the Second Applicant is allowed and I direct the Second Applicant to pay the Respondent the sum of $39,484.95 by 30 June 2014.  

CATCHWORDS: Building dispute – Wrongful repudiation – Construction manager liable for incomplete and defective work of contractors

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

APPLICANT: P W Woods (Builders) Pty Ltd and Watch This Space Builders Pty Ltd represented by their agent Mr Peter Woods.
RESPONDENT: Peter Hishon represented by Leonard Watt, Solicitor of Doyles Construction Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The First Applicant is a construction management company, PW Woods (Builders) Pty Ltd hereafter referred to as (“the Construction Manager”). The Second Applicant is a builder Watch This Space (Builders) Pty Ltd (WTP). Both companies have a common director Peter William Woods.

  2. Peter Hishon is a Commercial Manager employed by a large well-known construction company.  He is very experienced in the building industry and I expect skilled in project management.

  3. He engaged P W Woods (Builders) Pty Ltd (“the Construction Manager”) to manage the construction involved in the alteration and addition to his home at 9 Greggor Street, Wynnum West.

  4. The value of alterations and additions to be carried out were estimated to be $759,432.47 including GST.

  5. A dispute has arisen between the parties. The Construction Manager commenced proceedings in the Tribunal against Mr Hishon. The Construction Manager claims the sum of $59,938.10 comprising $8,163.10 as an amount still outstanding under the contract including a 15% late payment fee, additional administration services of $40,775.00, $5,004.00 for liquidated damages and $6,000.00 for time delays.

  6. WTS has claimed $59,938.00 being the amount owing under a trade contract with Mr Hishon and damages of $19,076.54.

  7. Mr Hishon has counterclaimed against the Construction Manager for $389,599.67 for unlawful termination of the contract, breach of contract and termination of agency.

  8. Against WTS Mr Hishon claims damages for repudiation of $53,066.86.

  9. The issues the Tribunal has been asked to determine, as I understand it, are these:

    a)    whether Mr Hishon was in substantial breach of contract thereby entitling the Construction Manager to terminate contract;

    b)    did the Construction Manager lawfully terminate the contract;

    c)    whether the Construction Manager was entitled to terminate the trade contracts between Mr Hishon and WTS and other contractors;

    d)    whether the Construction Manager was in breach of contract;

    e)    whether the Construction Manager wrongfully repudiated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PW Woods (Builder) Pty Ltd v Watch This Space Builders Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QCAT 188
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

PW Woods (Builder) Pty Ltd (the Construction Manager) and Watch This Space Builders Pty Ltd (WTS) commenced proceedings against Mr Peter Hishon in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The Construction Manager claimed $59,938.10 comprising $8,163.10 as an amount still outstanding under the contract including a 15% late payment fee, additional administration services of $40,775.00, $5,004.00 for liquidated damages and $6,000.00 for time delays. WTS has claimed $59,938.00 being the amount owing under a trade contract with Mr Hishon and damages of $19,076.54. Mr Hishon has counterclaimed against the Construction Manager for $389,599.67 for unlawful termination of the contract, breach of contract and termination of agency. Against WTS Mr Hishon claims damages for repudiation of $53,066.86. The issues to be determined were whether Mr Hishon was in substantial breach of contract thereby entitling the Construction Manager to terminate contract; whether the Construction Manager lawfully terminated the contract; whether the Construction Manager was entitled to terminate the trade contracts between Mr Hishon and WTS and other contractors; whether the Construction Manager was in breach of contract; whether the Construction Manager wrongfully repudiated the contract; the respective rights of the parties to payment under contract and/or damages and the quantum of damages. The Construction Manager failed to comply with the steps required by clause 27.1 of the Construction Management Contract. Mr Hishon’s Notice did not comply with clause 27.1 of the contract as it did not give notice to remedy the breach within seven working days and of its intention to terminate the contract. The Construction Manager’s breach in serving an invalid Notice may have been considered a trivial or immaterial breach, the subsequent suspension of the works amounted to a substantial breach, as defined in Clause 27.5 of the Contract. The Construction Manager had evinced every intention of not continuing with the Contract. The Construction Manager’s repudiation was not immediately accepted by Mr Hishon but he issued a Notice of Substantial Breach on 28 May 2012 and terminated the Contract by notice on 6 June 2012. The Construction Manager is not entitled to recover any payments outstanding and not performed. The Construction Manager’s claim includes an amount outstanding under the Contract of $7,098.35 and a 15% late payment fee, the total is $8,163.10. The Construction Manager has claimed $85,359.35 which represents 92.5% of the total fee of $92,273.00. It has in fact been paid 84.8% or $78,261.00. Mr Hishon claims that it has not completed work to the value claimed. The Construction Manager is not entitled to the further payments of $8,163.10 as it was in breach before that payment became due. Further, the claim for $40,775.00 by the Construction Manager is also not maintainable. The Construction Manager and WTS have failed to substantiate the claim. I am not satisfied that the claim has been proven. The claims by WTS have been challenged by Mr Hishon. The transaction report referred to above identifies 11 invoices totalling $21,067.66 all dated 24 May 2012 which was the date of the alleged termination of the contract. Mr Hishon says he has not seen nor been provided with these invoices. In cross-examination Mr Woods was asked to provide evidence of invoices relied on for this claim. Mr Woods undertook to do so before the end of the hearing. However, no invoices were ever produced. In the course of cross-examination, Mr Woods had initially said that all carpentry work had been completed, but later conceded that a timber fence had not been completed and fairly quickly conceded $4,000.00 could be deducted for that work not carried out. I have assessed the cost of the fence at $18,000.00. This concession casts doubt about other aspects of the claim; although on balance one is prepared to accept that some of these items have been completed and/or not paid for, there is doubt as to the accuracy of the final amount. I am not satisfied that the claim has been proven. The Construction Manager denies that it is liable for the defective work. Firstly, it says that the defects are not defects but rather the incomplete works brought about by the termination of the Contract. It then says that Mr Hishon is responsible for ensuring the various subcontractors rectify their alleged defective works as the Contract was validly terminated. It relies on clause 4.12 of the Contract. The above argument assumes that the Construction Manager was not responsible for the wrongful repudiation of the Contract. Having found that it is, Mr Hishon is entitled to claim damages for breach of contract which would include the costs of rectification services for building work carried out for the Principal under the Construction Management Trade Contracts. The Construction Manager denies that there is defective work but says rather that it is incomplete work brought about by the early termination of the Contract. It denies it is in any way responsible for the defects and says that Mr Hishon has fundamentally misinterpreted the terms of the Contract and his remedy lies in pursuing the individual subcontractors. The Construction Manager relies on clause 4.12 of the Contract. Further, it relies upon the indemnity provisions of the Contract, namely clause 18.6.2 of the Contract. It then argues that clause 18.6.2 of the Contract prevents Mr Hishon from bringing a counterclaim for the alleged defects to incomplete works. Clause 18 of the Contract is entitled Owner Taking Possession and all of the sub-clauses are prefaced on the fact that the owner has wrongfully taken possession of the works or the Construction Manager has consented to that course, it has no application to events where the Owner has lawfully terminated the Contract, which is the case here. It would be an absurd construction if the clause was construed in such a way that permitted the Construction Manager to avoid the consequences of its wrongful repudiation of the Contract and/or its neglectful supervision of the sub-contractors. In my opinion the defective and incomplete works are recoverable damages as for breach of contract. The claims by the First and Second Applicants are dismissed; the Respondent’s counterclaim against the First Applicant is allowed and I direct the First Applicant pay the Respondent the sum of $76,973.27; the Respondent’s counterclaim against the Second Applicant is allowed and I direct the Second Applicant to pay the Respondent the sum of $39,484.95.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.